Cost-Effectiveness of Different Treatment Options for Lower Calyceal Stones
Study Details
Study Description
Brief Summary
The aim of the present study to perform a full cost analysis for the complete clearance of calyceal stones by retrograde intrarenal surgery (RIRS) and percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PNL) for the treatment of lower calyceal stones between 1 and 2 centimeters (cm) in size.
| Condition or Disease | Intervention/Treatment | Phase |
|---|---|---|
|
N/A |
Detailed Description
The lifelong prevalence of urinary system stone disease is approximately 15%. The lower calyx is the most common location where renal calculi occur. Because anatomical factors preclude spontaneous passage in this area, the need for treatment is more likely in lower calyceal stones. The European Association of Urology (EAU) suggests percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PNL) for stones larger than 2 centimeters (cm) and shock wave lithotripsy (SWL) or retrograde intrarenal surgery (RIRS) for stones smaller than 1cm as a first option, but controversy continues regarding the best treatment option for medium-sized lower calyceal stones of between 1cm and 2cm.
Medical costs are divided into two components: direct and indirect. Direct costs encompass all medical expenditures (e.g., drugs, hospital bed, all consumable and non-consumable materials used during the operation), while indirect costs include loss of working days for the patient. The stone-free rates (SFR) are reported as approximately 60% and 90% for one session of RIRS and PNL, respectively; however, no physician can guarantee a 100% SFR for one session. For this reason, a full cost analysis must include the direct and indirect costs of both the first and all auxiliary procedures.
The aim of this study was to perform a full cost analysis for the complete clearance of calyceal stones by RIRS and all PNL types for the treatment of lower calyceal stones between 1cm and 2cm in size.
Study Design
Arms and Interventions
| Arm | Intervention/Treatment |
|---|---|
| Active Comparator: RIRS Patients underwent retrograde intrarenal surgery for lower calyceal stone between 1cm and 2cm in size |
Procedure: Retrograde intrarenal surgery
The procedure was performed with the patient in the dorsal lithotomy position under general anesthesia. Firstly, diagnostic ureteroscopy was done with a 6/7.5 Fr semi-rigid ureteroscope (Richard Wolf, Knittlingen, Germany). A 0.035mm double-tipped sensor guidewire was placed to the renal pelvis. A 10/12 Fr ureteric access sheath (Cook Medical, Indiana, USA) was used. A 7.5 Fr flexible ureteroscope (Flex X2, Karl Storz, Tuttlingen, Germany) was used for the main procedure. The stones were fragmented using a Holmium:Yttrium Aluminum Garnet laser (272 microns). At the end of each procedure, a double-j ureteric catheter and urethral catheter were routinely placed.
|
| Active Comparator: Micro-PNL Patients underwent micro percutaneous nephrolithotomy (tract size <10 F) for lower calyceal stone between 1cm and 2cm in size |
Procedure: Micro-PNL
The PNL procedures were performed with the patient in the prone position under general anesthesia. A 6-F ureteric catheter was placed at the beginning of the procedure. Calyceal access was provided using a 22-G Chiba needle. A 0.038mm sensor-tipped guidewire was inserted through the calyceal puncture into the renal pelvis. After tract dilatation, a sheath was inserted. The instruments used were a 4.8 Fr for micro PNL (PolyDiagnost, Pfaffenhofen, Germany). Stone fragmentation was carried out using laser in micro PNL. No nephrostomy was placed in any patient whom underwent micro PNL surgical technique. A double- j stent was placed in necessary (e.g., pelvis perforation, rest stone, stone migration to ureter). A urethral catheter was placed routinely in all patients.
|
| Active Comparator: Ultramini-PNL Patients underwent ultra-mini percutaneous nephrolithotomy (tract size <15 F) for lower calyceal stone between 1cm and 2cm in size |
Procedure: Ultra-mini PNL
The PNL procedures were performed with the patient in the prone position under general anesthesia. A 6-F ureteric catheter was placed at the beginning of the procedure. Calyceal access was provided using a 22-G Chiba needle. A 0.038mm sensor-tipped guidewire was inserted through the calyceal puncture into the renal pelvis. After tract dilatation, a sheath was inserted. The instruments used were a 7.5 Fr for ultramini PNL (Karl Storz, Tuttlingen, Germany). Stone fragmentation was carried out using laser in ultramini PNL. No nephrostomy was placed in any patient whom underwent ultramini PNL surgical technique. A double- j stent was placed in necessary (e.g., pelvis perforation, rest stone, stone migration to ureter). A urethral catheter was placed routinely in all patients.
|
| Active Comparator: Mini-PNL Patients underwent mini percutaneous nephrolithotomy (tract size <20 F) for lower calyceal stone between 1cm and 2cm in size |
Procedure: Mini-PNL
The PNL procedures were performed with the patient in the prone position under general anesthesia. A 6-F ureteric catheter was placed at the beginning of the procedure. Calyceal access was provided using a 22-G Chiba needle. A 0.038mm sensor-tipped guidewire was inserted through the calyceal puncture into the renal pelvis. After tract dilatation, a sheath was inserted. The instruments used were a 12 Fr for mini PNL (Karl Storz, Tuttlingen, Germany). Stone fragmentation was carried out using pneumatic, ultrasonic or laser in mini PNL. No nephrostomy was placed in any patient whom underwent mini PNL surgical technique. A double- j stent was placed in necessary (e.g., pelvis perforation, rest stone, stone migration to ureter). A urethral catheter was placed routinely in all patients.
|
| Active Comparator: Standard PNL Patients underwent standard percutaneous nephrolithotomy (tract size >25 F) for lower calyceal stone between 1cm and 2cm in size |
Procedure: Standard PNL
The PNL procedures were performed with the patient in the prone position under general anesthesia. A 6-F ureteric catheter was placed at the beginning of the procedure. Calyceal access was provided using a 22-G Chiba needle. A 0.038mm sensor-tipped guidewire was inserted through the calyceal puncture into the renal pelvis. After tract dilatation, a sheath was inserted. The instruments used were a 24 Fr for standard PNL (Karl Storz, Tuttlingen, Germany). Stone fragmentation was carried out using pneumatic, ultrasonic or laser in standard PNL. A nephrostomy was placed in all standard PNL patients at the end of the procedure
|
Outcome Measures
Primary Outcome Measures
- Stone free status [3 months]
Stone-free was defined as no rest stone or ≤ 3mm clinical insignificance rest stone
Eligibility Criteria
Criteria
Inclusion Criteria:
- Patients who had a lower calyceal stone between 1cm and 2 cm in size
Exclusion Criteria:
-
solitary or anomaly (horseshoe or pelvic kidney) kidney,
-
renal insufficiency,
-
pregnancy,
-
patient younger than 18 or older than 75 years,
-
non-interrupted antithrombotic medication before surgery,
-
urinary tract infection,
-
double-j or nephrostomy insertion before surgery
Contacts and Locations
Locations
No locations specified.Sponsors and Collaborators
- Ankara Training and Research Hospital
- Ministry of Health, Turkey
Investigators
- Principal Investigator: Muhammet F Kilinc, M.D., Ankara Training and Research Hospital
Study Documents (Full-Text)
None provided.More Information
Publications
None provided.- 2730