Efficacy and Tolerability of a Fractional Erbium Laser vs. Hybrid Ablative Laser for the Treatment of Acne Scars in Patients With Skin of Color
Study Details
Study Description
Brief Summary
The investigators aim to investigate the efficacy and tolerability of fractional ablative erbium yag 2940 nm laser and hybrid non-ablative/ablative laser for acne scarring in skin of color.
| Condition or Disease | Intervention/Treatment | Phase |
|---|---|---|
|
N/A |
Detailed Description
Acne is chronic inflammatory condition involving the pilosebaceous unit. One of the most common complications of acne is scarring, which occurs as a result of dermal damage during the healing process of active acne. Studies have shown that acne scarring can have a negative impact on an individual's quality of life and has been described as a risk factor for multiple psychiatric conditions including depression, anxiety, suicide, and poor self-esteem. Unfortunately, treatment of acne scarring, particularly those of the atrophic subtype, prove difficult to treat. A 2016 Cochrane review failed to provide sufficient evidence to support the first-line use of any intervention. Laser technology has been emerging as an effective, non-invasive treatment of acne scarring. Ablative lasers work by delivering energy to the dermal layer of the skin, resulting in thermal injury and stimulation of dermal cells to produce collagen, thus resolving the scar. More recently, fractional lasers, which create multiple tiny columns of therma injury, have been introduced with the benefit of reduced downtime and adverse effects compared to ablative lasers. The fractional CO2 laser is widely used for the treatment of acne scarring, however its use is limited in patients of Fitzpatrick IV and V skin due to risk of hyperpigmentation among other adverse events. The erbium-YAG fractional laser serves as an alternative, and has shown to produce less thermal injury and thus be more well-tolerated with lower risk of adverse effects in patients. The hybrid fractional laser combines a 2940 nm wavelength with a 1470 wavelength and has an ablative component targeting the epidermis and a nonablative component targeting the dermis at the same spot. The investigators seek to investigate the Scinton laser, a fractional erbium-YAG laser, and Sciton Halo, hybrid fractional laser for their efficacy in treating acne scarring and tolerability in patients with a specific emphasis on those with Fitzpatrick IV and V skin.
Study Design
Arms and Interventions
| Arm | Intervention/Treatment |
|---|---|
| Experimental: Hybrid Fractional laser 10 participants with fitzpatrick skin type IV-V will be randomized to this treatment arm. At the first visit, participants will undergo informed consent, education about the procedure, education about proper sun-care, and will be provided sunscreen. Participants will be prescribed a prescription of hydroquinone or a retinol to prevent hyperpigmentation, per standard of care. If participants choose to take this they will wait one month of taking the prescription and then begin treatment sessions. If not, participants can begin treatment sessions right away. Treatment consists of 3 laser sessions with the Sciton Halo hybrid fractional laser. Session amount depends on the degree of improvement. At each session before and after images will be collected. At each session participants will fill out the dermatology quality of life survey as well as a patient satisfaction survey. |
Device: Sciton Halo
Laser treatment
Other Names:
|
| Experimental: Fractional erbium YAG 10 participants with fitzpatrick skin type IV-V will be randomized to this treatment arm. At the first visit, participants will undergo informed consent, education about the procedure, education about proper sun-care, and will be provided sunscreen. Participants will be prescribed a prescription of hydroquinone or a retinol to prevent hyperpigmentation, per standard of care. If participants choose to take this they will wait one month of taking the prescription and then begin treatment sessions. If not, participants can begin treatment sessions right away. Treatment consists of 3 laser sessions with the Sciton Joule X Erbium Yag Fractional Ablative 2940nm laser. Session amount depends on the degree of improvement. At each session before and after images will be collected. At each session participants will fill out the dermatology quality of life survey as well as a patient satisfaction survey. |
Device: Sciton Joule X Erbium Yag Fractional Ablative 2940nm laser
Laser treatment
Other Names:
|
Outcome Measures
Primary Outcome Measures
- Change from baseline acne scar severity [month 3]
2 Independent unbiased blinded dermatologists will rate before and after treatment images using Global Scale for Acne Scarring. This scale is rated on a scale of 0 to 5. 0 is the least severe, and 5 is the most severe.
- Change from baseline acne scar severity [month 5]
2 Independent unbiased blinded dermatologists will rate before and after treatment images using Global Scale for Acne Scarring. This scale is rated on a scale of 0 to 5. 0 is the least severe, and 5 is the most severe.
- Change from baseline acne scar severity [month 8]
2 Independent unbiased blinded dermatologists will rate before and after treatment images using Global Scale for Acne Scarring. This scale is rated on a scale of 0 to 5. 0 is the least severe, and 5 is the most severe.
- Baseline Patient Satisfaction [month 0 (patient consultation visit )]
Patient Satisfaction Questionnaire. Questions are on a scale of -3 to 3, with -3 meaning the condition greatly decreased, and 3 meaning the condition greatly increased.
- Patient Satisfaction [throughout study completion, an average of 8 months]
Patient Satisfaction Questionnaire. Questions are on a scale of -3 to 3, with -3 meaning the condition greatly decreased, and 3 meaning the condition greatly increased.
- Patient Satisfaction [month 3]
Patient Satisfaction Questionnaire. Questions are on a scale of -3 to 3, with -3 meaning the condition greatly decreased, and 3 meaning the condition greatly increased.
- Patient Satisfaction [month 5]
Patient Satisfaction Questionnaire. Questions are on a scale of -3 to 3, with -3 meaning the condition greatly decreased, and 3 meaning the condition greatly increased.
- Patient Satisfaction [month 8]
Patient Satisfaction Questionnaire. Questions are on a scale of -3 to 3, with -3 meaning the condition greatly decreased, and 3 meaning the condition greatly increased.
- Dermatology Quality of Life Survey Baseline [month 0 (patient consultation visit)]
Dermatology Life Quality Index. This is a standardized dermatology scale. Questions are subjectively answered by participants with answer choices ranging from "very much, a lot, a little, and not at all."
- Dermatology Quality of Life Survey [throughout study completion, an average of 8 months]
Dermatology Life Quality Index. This is a standardized dermatology scale. Questions are subjectively answered by participants with answer choices ranging from "very much, a lot, a little, and not at all."
- Dermatology Quality of Life Survey [month 3]
Dermatology Life Quality Index. This is a standardized dermatology scale. Questions are subjectively answered by participants with answer choices ranging from "very much, a lot, a little, and not at all."
- Dermatology Quality of Life Survey [month 5]
Dermatology Life Quality Index. This is a standardized dermatology scale. Questions are subjectively answered by participants with answer choices ranging from "very much, a lot, a little, and not at all."
- Dermatology Quality of Life Survey [month 8]
Dermatology Life Quality Index. This is a standardized dermatology scale. Questions are subjectively answered by participants with answer choices ranging from "very much, a lot, a little, and not at all."
Eligibility Criteria
Criteria
Inclusion Criteria:
-
Healthy males and females, ≥ 18 years of age at time of informed consent, seeking treatment for acne scarring
-
Subject must be Fitzpatrick skin type III-VI
-
Subject must voluntarily sign and date an IRB approved informed consent form
-
Subjects with diagnosis of acne scarring recorded over the past 6 months
-
Able to read, understand and voluntarily provide written informed consent.
-
Subject is determined to be healthy, non-smoker
-
Subjects able and willing to comply with the treatment protocol and follow-up schedule and requirements.
-
Understands and accepts the obligation not to undergo any other procedures in the areas to be treated through the follow-up period.
Exclusion Criteria:
-
Subjects does not have the capacity to consent to the study
-
subject underwent any acne scar treatments in the past 6 months prior to enrollment in the study
-
Subject has active papulopustular or cystic acne within the past 6 months.
-
Any history of keloidal scarring.
-
Any previous surgical procedure in the treatment area in the past 12 months, or major surgery in the last 6 months.
-
History of immunosuppression/immune deficiency disorders (including AIDS and HIV infection), and/or any history of systemic chemotherapy for prior 12 months.
-
History or current use of the following prescription medications:
Immunosuppressive medications/biologics, 6 months prior to and during the study
-
Accutane or other systemic retinoids within the past twelve months
-
Smoking or vaping in the past 12 months.
-
History of photosensitivity and/or connective tissue disease
-
History of hyperlipidemia, diabetes mellitus, hepatitis, or bleeding disorders.
-
History of major depressive disorders or endocrine disorders including but not limited to; hypothyroidism, Hashimoto's thyroiditis, or hyperthyroidism.
-
History of ongoing pregnancy, active breastfeeding, cancer, and epilepsy
Contacts and Locations
Locations
No locations specified.Sponsors and Collaborators
- Albert Einstein College of Medicine
Investigators
- Principal Investigator: Kseniya Kobets, MD, Montefiore Medical Center
Study Documents (Full-Text)
None provided.More Information
Publications
None provided.- 2022-14024