Non-invasive Brain Stimulation for Pediatric ADHD
Study Details
Study Description
Brief Summary
The possibility of influencing brain activity and steadily enhancing behavioral performance through external intervention has long fascinated neuroscientists. One of these techniques, transcranial electrical stimulation (tES), has received great interest. Transcranial electrical stimulation (tES) in the current research includes two types of stimulation: transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) and transcranial random noise stimulation (tRNS).
The tES techniques involve the application of constant weak direct current (e.g. 1-2 mA) to the brain via skin-electrode interface, creating electric field that modulates neuronal activity. The safety profile of tES is excellent.
Despite effective pharmacotherapy for ADHD there is a need for improvement of cognitive dysfunction and behavioral symptoms that are only inadequately covered by pharmacological or psycho-social interventions. Since ADHD is the most common neurodevelopmental disorder in childhood with significant negative lifetime outcomes, non-invasive brain stimulation methods have been investigated in childhood and adolescents neuropsychiatric disorders showing promising results.
If tES is significantly effective for certain symptoms of ADHD, it may offer many advantages as a therapy. Treatment of ADHD with non-invasive brain stimulation has recently been reviewed in the medical literature, concluding that this technique seems to have efficacy in ADHD, however, standardized study protocols are needed to determine it.
In this study we intend to further examine the efficacy of tDCS and tRNS for children with ADHD and its effect on ADHD symptoms, memory, executive functions, in a randomized controlled crossover study.
| Condition or Disease | Intervention/Treatment | Phase |
|---|---|---|
|
N/A |
Detailed Description
External influences on neuroplastic processes may be used for functional improvement of diseases, in particular for improving cortical functions. The possibility of influencing brain activity and steadily enhancing behavioral performance through external intervention has long fascinated neuroscientists. One of these techniques, transcranial electrical stimulation (tES), has received great interest because it has great potential use in basic research and clinical applications. Transcranial electrical stimulation (tES) in the current research includes two types of stimulation: transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) and transcranial random noise stimulation (tRNS). The tES techniques involve the application of constant weak direct current (e.g. 1-2 mA) to the brain via skin-electrode interface, creating electric field that modulates neuronal activity. This modulation is polarity dependent toward depolarization after anodal stimulation (excitatory) and toward hyperpolarization after cathodal stimulation (inhibitory), leading to transient changes in the resting membrane potential. The cumulative effect of longer stimulation results in a polarity-dependent facilitation or inhibition of the spontaneous neuronal firing rate and is considered neuromodulatory.
tDCS, provokes a sub-threshold modulation of neuronal excitability without depolarizing action potentials5. Post stimulation effects of tDCS depends on the duration of stimulation (lasting from several minutes up to hours) and can be found in the areas under the electrodes and also remote by network changes.
The mechanism by which tRNS influences brain activity differs from tDCS. The delivery of tRNS uses the same equipment as for tDCS. In tRNS, however, both electrodes can be used to stimulate either in homologous locations bilaterally or at different regions simultaneously. tRNS can be used to stimulate a region with a current that varies randomly in time. Such stimulation can induce excitability that lasts up to 60 minutes per 10 minutes of stimulation1. The most beneficial type of tRNS is at high-frequency (100-640Hz).
This is a randomized, double blinded, placebo-controlled, crossover study in ADHD children.
Eligible participants will be randomized into the 3 following groups:
-
tDCS-placebo (sham) group to receive either tDCS or matching placebo (sham( during 5 following days (one session each day). After a one week break, there will be a crossover between the control group and the sham group: those we received tDCS in the 1st week will get sham, while those who received sham in the 1st week will received tDCS at the 3rd week.
-
tRNS-sham group, who will receive the same type of intervention with the same intervals as above but with tRNS instead of tDCS.
-
tDCS-tRNS group. Here the same intervention as above will be provided with the same intervals, but real tDCS and real tRNS will be provided in a counterbalanced fashion. This would allow to compare the different treatment in a within-subject design, as well as to compare the effect of those to sham stimulation in the first two groups in a between-subject design.
The total duration of subject participation will be 4 weeks. The study is conducted in the ADHD clinic of the Neuro-Cognitive Centre, at Hadassah-Hebrew University Medical Center.
tDCS: Stimulation would be applied using semi-dry 5X5 cm electrodes. The current would be 0.75mA, which based on previous computational modeling of tDCS in children and is estimated to equal that of 1-1.5 mA in adults. This decision was made after considering the parameters that would influence current distribution and density at the site of stimulation such as thinner scalp, less cerebrospinal fluid, and smaller head size of the paediatric population. A similar dosage using tDCS was well tolerated by children, and was not associated with adverse effects29. The anodal electrode will be positioned above the dlPFC (F3 based on the International 10-20 system, while the cathodal electrode would be placed over the right supraorbital. tRNS: Children in the active tRNS group will received 0.75mA of tRNS (100-640Hz) to their left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC) and the right inferior frontal gyrus (IFG) via semi-dry 5cm X 5cm electrodes, attached under designated electrode positions (F3, F8) of a tES cap that followed the International 10-20 system (InnoSphere Inc., Haifa). The left dlPFC and right IFG were chosen, based on their contribution in executive control and inhibition. tRNS will be applied for 20 minutes per session during an iPad cognitive training. Similar duration has also been used in paediatrics using tDCS29. Similar to a previous tRNS study in children, and the rational provided for tDCS we will apply 0.75mA.
Sham: For sham-tRNS we will use the same montage as in active tRNS. For sham-tDCS we will use the same montage as in active tDCS. The only difference between active and sham tES would be that in the case of the sham tES the 30 sec of ramp up of the current from 0 to 0.75mA would not be followed by 19 min of stimulation at 0.75mA as in active tES, but would immediately be followed by 30 sec ramp down period to 0mA. Such method has been shown to provide effective blindness of the stimulation condition as both active and sham tES would lead to slight itching sensation that would disappear due scalp habitation. No further stimulation would be provided in the sham group during the daily session.
The study will include 60 boys aged 7 to 12 years. The participants will be recruited among children referred to the clinic by pediatricians, general practitioners, teachers, psychologists or parents.
Study Design
Arms and Interventions
| Arm | Intervention/Treatment |
|---|---|
| Experimental: tDCS - placebo tDCS-placebo (sham) group to receive either transcranial direct stimulation (tDCS) or matching placebo (sham( during 5 following days (one session each day). After a one week break, there will be a crossover between the control group and the sham group: those we received tDCS in the 1st week will get sham, while those who received sham in the 1st week will received tDCS at the 3rd week. |
Device: tDCS
Stimulation would be applied using semi-dry 5X5 cm electrodes. The current would be 0.75mA, which based on previous computational modeling of tDCS in children and is estimated to equal that of 1-1.5 mA in adults. This decision was made after considering the parameters that would influence current distribution and density at the site of stimulation such as thinner scalp, less cerebrospinal fluid, and smaller head size of the paediatric population. A similar dosage using tDCS was well tolerated by children, and was not associated with adverse effects29. The anodal electrode will be positioned above the dlPFC (F3 based on the International 10-20 system, while the cathodal electrode would be placed over the right supraorbital.
Device: sham
For sham-tRNS we will use the same montage as in active tRNS. For sham-tDCS we will use the same montage as in active tDCS. The only difference between active and sham tES would be that in the case of the sham tES the 30 sec of ramp up of the current from 0 to 0.75mA would not be followed by 19 min of stimulation at 0.75mA as in active tES, but would immediately be followed by 30 sec ramp down period to 0mA. Such method has been shown to provide effective blindness of the stimulation condition as both active and sham tES would lead to slight itching sensation that would disappear due scalp habitation. No further stimulation would be provided in the sham group during the daily session.
|
| Experimental: tRNS - placebo trans cranial random stimulation (tRNS)-sham group, who will receive the same type of intervention with the same intervals as above but with tRNS instead of tDCS. |
Device: tRNS
Children in the active tRNS group will received 0.75mA of tRNS (100-640Hz) to their left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC) and the right inferior frontal gyrus (IFG) via semi-dry 5cm X 5cm electrodes, attached under designated electrode positions (F3, F8) of a tES cap that followed the International 10-20 system (InnoSphere Inc., Haifa). The left dlPFC and right IFG were chosen, based on their contribution in executive control and inhibition. tRNS will be applied for 20 minutes per session during an iPad cognitive training. Similar duration has also been used in paediatrics using tDCS29. Similar to a previous tRNS study in children, and the rational provided for tDCS we will apply 0.75mA.
Device: sham
For sham-tRNS we will use the same montage as in active tRNS. For sham-tDCS we will use the same montage as in active tDCS. The only difference between active and sham tES would be that in the case of the sham tES the 30 sec of ramp up of the current from 0 to 0.75mA would not be followed by 19 min of stimulation at 0.75mA as in active tES, but would immediately be followed by 30 sec ramp down period to 0mA. Such method has been shown to provide effective blindness of the stimulation condition as both active and sham tES would lead to slight itching sensation that would disappear due scalp habitation. No further stimulation would be provided in the sham group during the daily session.
|
| Experimental: tDCS-tRNS tDCS-tRNS group. Here the same intervention as above will be provided with the same intervals, but real tDCS and real tRNS will be provided in a counterbalanced fashion. This would allow to compare the different treatment in a within-subject design, as well as to compare the effect of those to sham stimulation in the first two groups in a between-subject design. |
Device: tDCS
Stimulation would be applied using semi-dry 5X5 cm electrodes. The current would be 0.75mA, which based on previous computational modeling of tDCS in children and is estimated to equal that of 1-1.5 mA in adults. This decision was made after considering the parameters that would influence current distribution and density at the site of stimulation such as thinner scalp, less cerebrospinal fluid, and smaller head size of the paediatric population. A similar dosage using tDCS was well tolerated by children, and was not associated with adverse effects29. The anodal electrode will be positioned above the dlPFC (F3 based on the International 10-20 system, while the cathodal electrode would be placed over the right supraorbital.
Device: tRNS
Children in the active tRNS group will received 0.75mA of tRNS (100-640Hz) to their left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC) and the right inferior frontal gyrus (IFG) via semi-dry 5cm X 5cm electrodes, attached under designated electrode positions (F3, F8) of a tES cap that followed the International 10-20 system (InnoSphere Inc., Haifa). The left dlPFC and right IFG were chosen, based on their contribution in executive control and inhibition. tRNS will be applied for 20 minutes per session during an iPad cognitive training. Similar duration has also been used in paediatrics using tDCS29. Similar to a previous tRNS study in children, and the rational provided for tDCS we will apply 0.75mA.
|
Outcome Measures
Primary Outcome Measures
- ADHD Rating Scale (ADHD-RS) parameters [4 weeks]
Assessment before and after intervention
Secondary Outcome Measures
- Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC-IV) [4 weeks]
All these parametres are part of the same scale (WISC-IV) including - Digit Span, Coding, Letter-Numbering Sequencing, Symbol Search. Assessment before and after intervention.
- Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive Function (BRIEF) [4 weeks]
Assessment before and after intervention
- MOXO-Continuous Performance Test standardized attention test [4 weeks]
Assessment before and after intervention
Other Outcome Measures
- Resting state Electroencephalography (EEG) [4 weeks]
Assessment before and after intervention
- CGI-S Scale = Clinical Global Impression - Severity [4 weeks]
Assessment before and after intervention
Eligibility Criteria
Criteria
Inclusion Criteria:
-
Meet ADHD criteria according to the DSM-5
-
Meet ADHD criteria according to "gold standard" AAP criteria = semi-structured interview, medical/neurological examination
-
Score above the standard clinical cut off values for ADHD symptoms on ADHD-RS
-
Drug naïve. -
Exclusion Criteria:
-
Chronic neurological disease
-
Epilepsy in subject or first degree relative
-
Intellectual disability
-
Any other chronic conditions
-
Chronic use of medications
-
Other primary psychiatric diagnosis (e.g., depression, anxiety, psychosis) -
Contacts and Locations
Locations
| Site | City | State | Country | Postal Code | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Neuro-Cognitive Center, Pediatric Division, Hadassah-Hebrew University Medical Center | Jerusalem | Mount Scopus | Israel | 91240 |
Sponsors and Collaborators
- Hadassah Medical Organization
Investigators
None specified.Study Documents (Full-Text)
None provided.More Information
Publications
None provided.- HMO-17-0180