Effects of Visual Cues and Education for People Who Live Within Long Term Care Communities to Assist in Wayfinding

Sponsor

Grand Valley State University (Other)

Overall Status

Active, not recruiting

CT.gov ID

NCT03537729

Collaborator

Michigan State University (Other)

175

Enrollment

Locations

Arms

Anticipated Duration (Months)

87.5

Patients Per Site

1.6

Patients Per Site Per Month

Study Details

Study Description

Brief Summary

The ability to find one's way in the world is known as wayfinding. Many older adults who live in senior communities, such as independent living and assisted living residences, find wayfinding very challenging. Often times, these communities are not designed in a way that helps people find their way very easily. When people cannot find their way, they can get lost, be dependent upon others for getting out and about, or even be afraid to leave their rooms. The purpose of this study is to find out if distinctive signs and decorative elements, along with a special type of education called Spaced-Retrieval education, help residents in these communities find their way more effectively. Twelve senior communities will be assigned by chance to one of three conditions, including: 1) control - no change (the community stays the same); 2) signs and decorative elements enhanced; and 3) signs, decorative elements, and special education added. After agreeing to be in the study, the participants will be asked to find their way to certain places in their community four times over a year. Some people will be asked to participate in educational sessions on wayfinding. In addition, some people will be asked to wear a location tracker, (like a fitness tracker), for four weeks during the year. How well people find their way, along with how much they travel about within the communities, will be compared between the three groups. It is hypothesized that those in the communities with special signs and decorative elements will find their way more effectively than those in the control communities. It is also hypothesized that participants in the communities with the special education intervention will find their way better than those without the education. Finally, it is hypothesized that participants in the communities with signs and cues and education will travel about further distances than those in the control communities. The results of the study can help people who have a tendency to get lost find their way more effectively in their community, and this could result in more independence.

Condition or Disease	Intervention/Treatment	Phase
Alzheimer Disease Alzheimer Dementia Age-Related Memory Disorders Dementia	Behavioral: Salient Cues Behavioral: Spaced Retrieval Education	N/A

Detailed Description

The ability to locate and travel successfully to a destination, known as wayfinding, is a significant problem for older adults with cognitive disorders. Relocating to a new residence such as independent or assisted living is a time in which older adults with cognitive problems are most vulnerable to experiencing wayfinding problems. Often these communities are not designed to facilitate wayfinding as they are complex, confusing, and lack distinctiveness. Wayfinding problems can cause individuals' worlds to shrink, leading to a smaller life space (the spatial extent of travel within the community), decreased engagement, and dependence upon others for activities of daily living. The overall goal of the proposed project is to assess the contribution of salient visual cues and Spaced Retrieval (SR) on wayfinding ability and life space in older adults with wayfinding problems who live in senior communities. Salient cues, such as vivid pictures, statues and bright, distinctive signage can make senior residential communities more memorable and distinctive. This study has three specific aims: a) to examine the effect of salient cues with and without SR on wayfinding ability initially and over time in older adults who have wayfinding deficits in senior communities; and b) To determine the effects of salient visual cues and SR on life space; and

to determine subject characteristics that are most amenable to the intervention; wand which subject characteristics place persons at risk for less responsiveness to the intervention so that the intervention can be appropriately targeted. There are three arms to the clinical trial to which nine care communities will be randomly assigned, including Arm 1 (control; no change to the care community); Arm 2 (colorful and familiar objects and signage placed within the care community); and Arm 3 (Arm 2 cues plus SR). Participants will be individuals within the communities who exhibit problems finding their way. They will be asked to find their way repeatedly to specific destinations over a period of a year. Wayfinding performance, including how fast the participants find the test location and the errors they make compared between study Arms. Life space will also be measured and compared between Arms. It is hypothesized that individuals who are in care communities which are enhanced with salient cues will improve wayfinding when compared to care communities without salient cues. In addition, Spaced Retrieval, which is an evidence-based memory strategy, is hypothesized to positively influence subjects' use of the cues and improve wayfinding performance. Finally, it is hypothesized that wayfinding ability will correlate with life space. The long term goals of this research are to test an evidence based intervention to enhance senior residences so that older adults who have wayfinding problems can more easily learn and remember their environments so that they can maintain independence.

Study Design

Study Type:

Interventional

Actual Enrollment :

175 participants

Allocation:

Randomized

Intervention Model:

Parallel Assignment

Masking:

None (Open Label)

Primary Purpose:

Supportive Care

Official Title:

A Randomized Controlled Trial of Visual Cues, Signage, and Spaced-Retrieval Education Within Long Term Care Communities to Assist With Wayfinding

Actual Study Start Date :

Apr 1, 2019

Anticipated Primary Completion Date :

Sep 30, 2023

Anticipated Study Completion Date :

Sep 30, 2023

Arms and Interventions

Arm	Intervention/Treatment
No Intervention: Control There will be no modifications to décor or signage in the existing care community, and no education on wayfinding. However, subjects will receive the same testing that is provided for the other arms at the designated time periods.
Experimental: Salient Cues Special signs and salient cues will be added to the community along the routes being measured for wayfinding. The cues will be comprised of pictures, objects, and signage.	Behavioral: Salient Cues Salient cues are those that capture the individual's attention. Information that is complex, novel, and difficult to identify takes more processing resources than those that are simple and familiar. Cues such as pictures and wall hangings, along with bright and meaningful signs, will be placed at key decision points within the senior communities.
Experimental: Spaced retrieval education This condition will have signage and cues as in Arm 2 added to the care communities. In addition, a spaced retrieval (SR) memory intervention strategy will be implemented individually for each resident participating in the study to help them remember the presence and function of the environmental wayfinding cues.	Behavioral: Salient Cues Salient cues are those that capture the individual's attention. Information that is complex, novel, and difficult to identify takes more processing resources than those that are simple and familiar. Cues such as pictures and wall hangings, along with bright and meaningful signs, will be placed at key decision points within the senior communities. Behavioral: Spaced Retrieval Education Spaced Retrieval (SR) is an evidence-based memory strategy that is used to teach individuals with memory loss new or previously known information. In this study, participants in Arm 3 will receive twelve 30-minute educational sessions to help them use the salient cues to find their way.

Arm

Intervention/Treatment

No Intervention: Control

There will be no modifications to décor or signage in the existing care community, and no education on wayfinding. However, subjects will receive the same testing that is provided for the other arms at the designated time periods.

Experimental: Salient Cues

Special signs and salient cues will be added to the community along the routes being measured for wayfinding. The cues will be comprised of pictures, objects, and signage.

Behavioral: Salient Cues

Salient cues are those that capture the individual's attention. Information that is complex, novel, and difficult to identify takes more processing resources than those that are simple and familiar. Cues such as pictures and wall hangings, along with bright and meaningful signs, will be placed at key decision points within the senior communities.

Experimental: Spaced retrieval education

This condition will have signage and cues as in Arm 2 added to the care communities. In addition, a spaced retrieval (SR) memory intervention strategy will be implemented individually for each resident participating in the study to help them remember the presence and function of the environmental wayfinding cues.

Behavioral: Salient Cues

Behavioral: Spaced Retrieval Education

Spaced Retrieval (SR) is an evidence-based memory strategy that is used to teach individuals with memory loss new or previously known information. In this study, participants in Arm 3 will receive twelve 30-minute educational sessions to help them use the salient cues to find their way.

Outcome Measures

Primary Outcome Measures

Change in Wayfinding Speed at 12 months [12 months]
Wayfinding speed is a single value, and is calculated using the following formula: v=(total distance) / (total time) for the subject to find his/her way from the starting to end point of the route. Wayfinding speed will be compared between baseline and 12 months.

Secondary Outcome Measures

Change in wayfinding errors at 12 months [12 months]
Wayfinding errors are calculated by dividing the number of wrong turns (errors) made on a route by the number of possible turns. This value will be compared between baseline and 12 months.
Change in Life Space at 12 months [12 months]
Life space is defined as the spatial extent of mobility within an environment, and varies from a small life space (limited to one's room) to a large life space (travels outside of the care community). Life space will be measured using a modified version of Tinetti's Nursing Home Life-Space Diameter and scores will be compared between baseline and 12 months.
Change in Spatial Tracking - Life space at 12 months [12 months]
For a sub-sample, an electronic monitoring device will provide data regarding the life space of participants. The location of the participants will be mapped onto Tinetti's life space zones and the extent of life space will be compared between baseline and the end of the study at 12 months.
Change in Spatial Tracking (Time spent at each life space zone) at 12 months [12 months]
For a subsample, an electronic monitoring device will provide data regarding the life space of participants. The amount of time in seconds will be recorded for each life space zone. This value will be compared from baseline to the end of the study at 12 months.

Eligibility Criteria

Criteria

Ages Eligible for Study:

62 Years and Older

Sexes Eligible for Study:

All

Accepts Healthy Volunteers:

Inclusion Criteria:

Age 62 or older;
Wayfinding impairment identified by the subject or staff and exhibited at baseline, including problems finding their way among three defined locations (these may differ among care communities);
Ability to move self either independently by walking or using mobility aids (self-mobile; any mobility aids are acceptable)
Ability to communicate with researchers and follow directions
Ability to see and read signs in English.

Exclusion Criteria:

Chronic health conditions that impair the ability to participate in the study, such as severe chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) (limiting movement) or terminal illness;
Signs of rapid deterioration in health during the past 6 months as evidenced by staff communication or medical records.