Psychological Support for Patients With an Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillator

Sponsor
University Health Network, Toronto (Other)
Overall Status
Completed
CT.gov ID
NCT00152763
Collaborator
(none)
193
1
4
49
3.9

Study Details

Study Description

Brief Summary

About 30% of patients survive a cardiac arrest, and the majority of these receive an implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD) for prevention of sudden cardiac death (SCD). While ICD therapy offers survival benefit over drug therapy, there remain significant quality of life (QL) issues. About 50% of patients experience chronic anxiety about receiving an ICD shock. Anxiety and depression in turn appear to predispose to more arrhythmias necessitating

ICD therapy. The aims of the current study are:
  1. to evaluate a 8-session psychosocial intervention to help patients cope effectively with receiving an ICD for secondary prevention of SCD,

  2. to determine if baseline measures of depression and anxiety predict ICD therapies (i.e., anti-tachycardia pace terminations and shocks); and

  3. to explore if the psychosocial intervention results in less need for appropriate ICD therapies.

Condition or Disease Intervention/Treatment Phase
  • Behavioral: Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT)
  • Other: Usual Cardiac Care (UCC)
Phase 3

Detailed Description

About 30% of patients survive a cardiac arrest, and the majority of these receive an implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD) for prevention of sudden cardiac death (SCD). While ICD therapy offers survival benefit over drug therapy, there remain significant quality of life (QL) issues. About 50% of patients experience chronic anxiety about receiving an ICD shock. Anxiety and depression in turn appear to predispose to more arrhythmias necessitating

ICD therapy. The aims of the current study are:
  1. to evaluate a 8-session psychosocial intervention to help patients cope effectively with receiving an ICD for secondary prevention of SCD,

  2. to determine if baseline measures of depression and anxiety predict ICD therapies (i.e., anti-tachycardia pace terminations and shocks); and

  3. to explore if the psychosocial intervention results in less need for appropriate ICD therapies.

This study will randomize 218 ICD patients to receive either usual cardiac care (n=109) OR usual cardiac care plus CBT (n=109). Participants are recruited from two hospitals in Toronto that perform ICD implants (St. Michael's Hospital and the Toronto General Hospital). Counselling follows a CBT manual and involves both face-to-face sessions and telephone sessions. The telephone is employed as a means to deliver therapy as at least half of our ICD subjects reside outside of Toronto and all patients are prohibited from driving an automobile for the first six months following ICD implant. Outcome is assessed 6 and 12-months following the date of randomization and include measures of psychological function and quality of life. Secondary outcome is frequency of ICD therapies over follow-up (i.e., anti-tachycardia pacing terminations and DC shocks).

Inclusion Criteria:
  • Patients from either Toronto General hospital or St. Michael's Hospital who have coronary heart disease,

  • Receiving their first ICD implant for secondary prevention of SCD or primary prevention of SCD if their underlying heart disease was hypertrophic cardiomyopathy.

Exclusion Criteria:
  • Not able to read or understand English;

  • Evidence of psychosis, dementia or cognitive impairment as documented in the patients' hospital records;

  • Receiving an ICD for primary prevention of ICD.

Study Design

Study Type:
Interventional
Actual Enrollment :
193 participants
Allocation:
Randomized
Intervention Model:
Factorial Assignment
Masking:
Single (Outcomes Assessor)
Primary Purpose:
Treatment
Official Title:
Psychological Support for Patients With an Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillator
Study Start Date :
Oct 1, 2003
Actual Primary Completion Date :
Sep 1, 2007
Actual Study Completion Date :
Nov 1, 2007

Arms and Interventions

Arm Intervention/Treatment
Experimental: Cognitive Behavior Therapy - males

Eight telephone sessions of cognitive behavior therapy tailored to psychological adaptation to an ICD, plus a psycho-educational booklet for participants and a therapist manual. This arm included the males.

Behavioral: Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT)
Cognitive behavior therapy tailored to psychological adaptation to an ICD, included 8 telephone counselling sessions, plus psycho-educational booklet and a therapist manual.

Experimental: Cognitive Behavior Therapy - females

Eight telephone sessions of cognitive behavior therapy tailored to psychological adaptation to an ICD, plus a psycho-educational booklet for participants and a therapist manual. This arm included the females.

Behavioral: Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT)
Cognitive behavior therapy tailored to psychological adaptation to an ICD, included 8 telephone counselling sessions, plus psycho-educational booklet and a therapist manual.

Active Comparator: Usual Cardiac Care - Males

The UCC was defined as whatever the respective ICD treatment sites routinely offer their patients. All patients received standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. This arm was just for males randomized.

Other: Usual Cardiac Care (UCC)
Usual cardiac care (UCC) was defined as whatever the respective ICD treatment sites routinely offer their patients. All patients received standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed.

Active Comparator: Usual Cardiac Care - females

The UCC was defined as whatever the respective ICD treatment sites routinely offer their patients. All patients received standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. This arm was for females randomized.

Other: Usual Cardiac Care (UCC)
Usual cardiac care (UCC) was defined as whatever the respective ICD treatment sites routinely offer their patients. All patients received standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed.

Outcome Measures

Primary Outcome Measures

  1. Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale - Depression Scale at Baseline [Baseline]

    Psychometric scale measuring symptoms of depression, score range is 0 to 24. Scores >= 8 represent clinically elevated scores. Higher scores represent greater depressive symptoms.

  2. Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale - Depression Scale at 6-months Follow-up [Six-months follow-up]

    Psychometric scale measuring symptoms of depression, score range is 0 to 24. Scores >= 8 represent clinically elevated scores. Higher scores represent greater depressive symptoms.

  3. Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale - Depression Scale at 12-months Follow-up [Twelve-months follow-up]

    Psychometric scale measuring symptoms of depression, score range is 0 to 24. Scores >= 8 represent clinically elevated scores. Higher scores represent greater depressive symptoms.

  4. Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale - Anxiety Scale at Baseline [Baseline]

    Psychometric scale measuring symptoms of anxiety,score range is 0 to 24. Scores >= 8 represent clinically elevated scores. Higher scores represent greater anxiety symptoms.

  5. Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale - Anxiety Scale at 6-months Follow-up [Six-months follow-up]

    Psychometric scale measuring symptoms of anxiety,score range is 0 to 24. Scores >= 8 represent clinically elevated scores. Higher scores represent greater anxiety symptoms.

  6. Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale - Anxiety Scale at 12-months Follow-up [Twelve-months follow-up]

    Psychometric scale measuring symptoms of anxiety,score range is 0 to 24. Scores >= 8 represent clinically elevated scores. Higher scores represent greater anxiety symptoms.

  7. Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Total Score at Baseline [Baseline]

    Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. A score threshold of 1.4 has been found to diagnostic of post traumatic stress disorder in war veterans. Higher scores represent greater total post traumatic stress disorder symptoms.

  8. Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Total Score at 6-months Follow-up [Six-months follow-up]

    Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. A score threshold of 1.4 has been found to diagnostic of post traumatic stress disorder in war veterans. Higher scores represent greater total post traumatic stress disorder symptoms.

  9. Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Total Score at 12-months Follow-up [Twelve-months follow-up]

    Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. A score threshold of 1.4 has been found to diagnostic of post traumatic stress disorder in war veterans. Higher scores represent greater total post traumatic stress disorder symptoms.

  10. Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Intrusiveness Scale at Baseline [Baseline]

    Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder intrusiveness symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder intrusiveness symptoms.

  11. Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Intrusiveness Scale at 6-months Follow-up [Six-months follow-up]

    Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder intrusiveness symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder intrusiveness symptoms.

  12. Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Intrusiveness Scale at 12-months Follow-up [Twelve-months follow-up]

    Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder intrusiveness symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder intrusiveness symptoms.

  13. Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Avoidance Scale at Baseline [Baseline]

    Psychometric assessment of post traumatic stress disorder avoidance symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder avoidance symptoms.

  14. Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Avoidance Scale at 6-months Follow-up [Six-months follow-up]

    Psychometric assessment of post traumatic stress disorder avoidance symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder avoidance symptoms.

  15. Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Avoidance Scale at 12-months Follow-up [Twelve-months follow-up]

    Psychometric assessment of post traumatic stress disorder avoidance symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder avoidance symptoms.

  16. Impact of Event Scale-Revised Hyperarousal Scale at Baseline [Baseline]

    Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder hyper-arousal symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder hyperarousal symptoms.

  17. Impact of Event Scale-Revised Hyperarousal Scale at 6-months Follow-up [Six-months follow-up]

    Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder hyper-arousal symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder hyperarousal symptoms.

  18. Impact of Event Scale-Revised Hyperarousal Scale at 12-months Follow-up [Twelve-months follow-up]

    Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder hyper-arousal symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder hyperarousal symptoms.

  19. Crown-Crisp Experiential Index - Phobic Anxiety Scale at Baseline [Baseline]

    Psychometric measure of phobic anxiety, scores range from 1 to 3. Higher scores represent greater phobic anxiety symptoms.

  20. Crown-Crisp Experiential Index - Phobic Anxiety Scale at 6-months Follow-up [Six-months follow-up]

    Psychometric measure of phobic anxiety, scores range from 1 to 3. Higher scores represent greater phobic anxiety symptoms.

  21. Crown-Crisp Experiential Index - Phobic Anxiety Scale at 12-months Follow-up [Twelve-months follow-up]

    Psychometric measure of phobic anxiety, scores range from 1 to 3. Higher scores represent greater phobic anxiety symptoms.

Secondary Outcome Measures

  1. SF-36 Mental Component Summary Scale at Baseline [Baseline]

    Quality of life measure - mental health summary, scores range from 0 to 100 with higher scores representing better mental health.

  2. SF-36 Mental Component Summary Scale at 6-months Follow-up [Six-months follow-up]

    Quality of life measure - mental health summary, scores range from 0 to 100 with higher scores representing better mental health.

  3. SF-36 Mental Component Summary Scale at 12-months Follow-up [Twelve-months follow-up]

    Quality of life measure - mental health summary, scores range from 0 to 100 with higher scores representing better mental health.

  4. SF-36 Physical Component Summary Score at Baseline [Baseline]

    Quality of life measure of physical health, scores range from 0 to 100 with higher scores representing better physical health.

  5. SF-36 Physical Component Summary Score at 6-months Follow-up [Six-months follow-up]

    Quality of life measure of physical health, scores range from 0 to 100 with higher scores representing better physical health.

  6. SF-36 Physical Component Summary Score at 12-months Follow-up [Twelve-months follow-up]

    Quality of life measure of physical health, scores range from 0 to 100 with higher scores representing better physical health.

  7. Percentage of Participants Who Received ICD Therapies [12-months follow-up]

    Percentage of participants who received ICD shocks or anti-tachycardia therapies, data extracted from participants ICD devices over follow-up.

Eligibility Criteria

Criteria

Ages Eligible for Study:
18 Years and Older
Sexes Eligible for Study:
All
Accepts Healthy Volunteers:
No
Inclusion Criteria:
  • Patients from either Toronto General hospital or St. Michael's Hospital who have coronary heart disease,

  • Receiving their first ICD implant for secondary prevention of SCD or for primary prevention of SCD and their underlying heart disease was hypertrophic cardiomyopathy.

Exclusion Criteria:
  • Not able to read or understand English;

  • Evidence of psychosis, dementia or cognitive impairment as documented in the patients' hospital records;

  • Receiving an ICD for primary prevention of ICD.

Contacts and Locations

Locations

Site City State Country Postal Code
1 Toronto General Hospital Toronto Ontario Canada M5G 2C4

Sponsors and Collaborators

  • University Health Network, Toronto

Investigators

  • Principal Investigator: Jane Irvine, D.Phil., University Health Network, Toronto General Hospital

Study Documents (Full-Text)

None provided.

More Information

Publications

Responsible Party:
, ,
ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier:
NCT00152763
Other Study ID Numbers:
  • NA 5170
  • Grant number NA 5170
First Posted:
Sep 9, 2005
Last Update Posted:
Jan 28, 2011
Last Verified:
Jan 1, 2011
Keywords provided by , ,
Additional relevant MeSH terms:

Study Results

Participant Flow

Recruitment Details Recruitment commenced in October 2003 at Toronto General Hospital and St. Michael's Hospital in Toronto, Ontario, Canada and concluded in August 2006.
Pre-assignment Detail Upon recruitment, participants completed baseline psychological assessment prior to being randomized to the experimental intervention arm (cognitive behaviour therapy) or usual care.
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Period Title: Overall Study
STARTED 77 19 20 77
COMPLETED 67 14 16 63
NOT COMPLETED 10 5 4 14

Baseline Characteristics

Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men Total
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet. Total of all reporting groups
Overall Participants 77 19 20 77 193
Age (years) [Mean (Standard Deviation) ]
Mean (Standard Deviation) [years]
61.29
(13.17)
54.58
(15.75)
55.35
(18.30)
64.2
(13.35)
61.68
(14.18)
Sex: Female, Male (Count of Participants)
Female
0
0%
19
100%
20
100%
0
0%
39
20.2%
Male
77
100%
0
0%
0
0%
77
100%
154
79.8%

Outcome Measures

1. Primary Outcome
Title Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale - Depression Scale at Baseline
Description Psychometric scale measuring symptoms of depression, score range is 0 to 24. Scores >= 8 represent clinically elevated scores. Higher scores represent greater depressive symptoms.
Time Frame Baseline

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Intention to treat analyses but data on participants who died over follow-up were omitted.
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
4.70
(3.41)
7.47
(5.02)
5.35
(3.82)
4.12
(4.01)
2. Secondary Outcome
Title SF-36 Mental Component Summary Scale at Baseline
Description Quality of life measure - mental health summary, scores range from 0 to 100 with higher scores representing better mental health.
Time Frame Baseline

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
45.90
(13.40)
37.44
(13.69)
42.33
(12.43)
49.84
(10.56)
3. Primary Outcome
Title Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale - Depression Scale at 6-months Follow-up
Description Psychometric scale measuring symptoms of depression, score range is 0 to 24. Scores >= 8 represent clinically elevated scores. Higher scores represent greater depressive symptoms.
Time Frame Six-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Intention to treat analyses but data on participants who died over follow-up were omitted.
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
4.21
(3.31)
4.86
(3.25)
5.50
(4.22)
3.82
(3.39)
4. Secondary Outcome
Title SF-36 Mental Component Summary Scale at 6-months Follow-up
Description Quality of life measure - mental health summary, scores range from 0 to 100 with higher scores representing better mental health.
Time Frame Six-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
48.73
(10.34)
43.82
(11.64)
45.67
(10.84)
51.32
(10.99)
5. Primary Outcome
Title Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale - Depression Scale at 12-months Follow-up
Description Psychometric scale measuring symptoms of depression, score range is 0 to 24. Scores >= 8 represent clinically elevated scores. Higher scores represent greater depressive symptoms.
Time Frame Twelve-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Intention to treat analyses but data on participants who died over follow-up were omitted.
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
4.52
(3.29)
4.67
(4.19)
5.87
(3.12)
4.15
(3.36)
6. Primary Outcome
Title Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale - Anxiety Scale at Baseline
Description Psychometric scale measuring symptoms of anxiety,score range is 0 to 24. Scores >= 8 represent clinically elevated scores. Higher scores represent greater anxiety symptoms.
Time Frame Baseline

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Intention to treat analyses but data on participants who died over follow-up were omitted.
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
6.53
(4.26)
9.32
(5.50)
7.70
(3.85)
4.80
(3.93)
7. Primary Outcome
Title Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale - Anxiety Scale at 6-months Follow-up
Description Psychometric scale measuring symptoms of anxiety,score range is 0 to 24. Scores >= 8 represent clinically elevated scores. Higher scores represent greater anxiety symptoms.
Time Frame Six-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Intention to treat analyses but data on participants who died over follow-up were omitted.
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
6.06
(3.84)
7.28
(4.01)
6.83
(4.67)
4.69
(3.92)
8. Primary Outcome
Title Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale - Anxiety Scale at 12-months Follow-up
Description Psychometric scale measuring symptoms of anxiety,score range is 0 to 24. Scores >= 8 represent clinically elevated scores. Higher scores represent greater anxiety symptoms.
Time Frame Twelve-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Intention to treat analyses but data on participants who died over follow-up were omitted.
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
6.06
(3.97)
8.00
(3.70)
7.25
(3.57)
4.43
(3.77)
9. Primary Outcome
Title Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Total Score at Baseline
Description Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. A score threshold of 1.4 has been found to diagnostic of post traumatic stress disorder in war veterans. Higher scores represent greater total post traumatic stress disorder symptoms.
Time Frame Baseline

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Intention to treat analysis although data for participants who died over follow-up were omitted.
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 12 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.81
(0.66)
1.56
(0.99)
1.20
(0.85)
0.63
(0.51)
10. Secondary Outcome
Title SF-36 Mental Component Summary Scale at 12-months Follow-up
Description Quality of life measure - mental health summary, scores range from 0 to 100 with higher scores representing better mental health.
Time Frame Twelve-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
49.92
(10.50)
46.26
(14.00)
41.58
(9.02)
51.61
(46.26)
11. Primary Outcome
Title Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Total Score at 6-months Follow-up
Description Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. A score threshold of 1.4 has been found to diagnostic of post traumatic stress disorder in war veterans. Higher scores represent greater total post traumatic stress disorder symptoms.
Time Frame Six-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Intention to treat analysis although data for participants who died over follow-up were omitted.
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 12 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.70
(0.52)
0.76
(0.83)
0.68
(0.64)
0.54
(0.62)
12. Primary Outcome
Title Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Total Score at 12-months Follow-up
Description Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. A score threshold of 1.4 has been found to diagnostic of post traumatic stress disorder in war veterans. Higher scores represent greater total post traumatic stress disorder symptoms.
Time Frame Twelve-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Intention to treat analysis although data for participants who died over follow-up were omitted.
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 12 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.70
(0.64)
0.69
(0.53)
0.82
(0.69)
0.46
(0.47)
13. Primary Outcome
Title Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Intrusiveness Scale at Baseline
Description Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder intrusiveness symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder intrusiveness symptoms.
Time Frame Baseline

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.80
(0.71)
1.53
(0.98)
1.25
(0.95)
0.61
(0.64)
14. Primary Outcome
Title Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Intrusiveness Scale at 6-months Follow-up
Description Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder intrusiveness symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder intrusiveness symptoms.
Time Frame Six-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.61
(0.52)
0.82
(0.96)
0.73
(0.73)
0.56
(0.73)
15. Primary Outcome
Title Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Intrusiveness Scale at 12-months Follow-up
Description Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder intrusiveness symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder intrusiveness symptoms.
Time Frame Twelve-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.62
(0.62)
0.64
(0.60)
0.80
(0.70)
0.42
(0.47)
16. Primary Outcome
Title Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Avoidance Scale at Baseline
Description Psychometric assessment of post traumatic stress disorder avoidance symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder avoidance symptoms.
Time Frame Baseline

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Intention to treat analysis although data from participants who died were omitted from analysis
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 12 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.84
(0.62)
1.68
(1.10)
1.25
(0.82)
0.64
(0.58)
17. Primary Outcome
Title Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Avoidance Scale at 6-months Follow-up
Description Psychometric assessment of post traumatic stress disorder avoidance symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder avoidance symptoms.
Time Frame Six-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Intention to treat analysis although data from participants who died were omitted from analysis
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 12 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.86
(0.64)
0.77
(0.87)
0.74
(0.71)
0.55
(0.64)
18. Primary Outcome
Title Impact of Events Scale-Revised - Avoidance Scale at 12-months Follow-up
Description Psychometric assessment of post traumatic stress disorder avoidance symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder avoidance symptoms.
Time Frame Twelve-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Intention to treat analysis although data from participants who died were omitted from analysis
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 12 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.82
(0.74)
0.84
(0.65)
0.98
(0.86)
0.57
(0.66)
19. Primary Outcome
Title Impact of Event Scale-Revised Hyperarousal Scale at Baseline
Description Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder hyper-arousal symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder hyperarousal symptoms.
Time Frame Baseline

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.78
(0.86)
1.40
(1.11)
1.07
(0.98)
0.64
(0.67)
20. Primary Outcome
Title Impact of Event Scale-Revised Hyperarousal Scale at 6-months Follow-up
Description Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder hyper-arousal symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder hyperarousal symptoms.
Time Frame Six-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.61
(0.70)
0.64
(0.87)
0.56
(0.61)
0.52
(0.70)
21. Primary Outcome
Title Impact of Event Scale-Revised Hyperarousal Scale at 12-months Follow-up
Description Psychometric measure of post traumatic stress disorder hyper-arousal symptoms, scores range from 0 to 4. Higher scores represent greater post traumatic stress disorder hyperarousal symptoms.
Time Frame Twelve-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.64
(0.73)
0.57
(0.54)
0.67
(0.70)
0.39
(0.43)
22. Primary Outcome
Title Crown-Crisp Experiential Index - Phobic Anxiety Scale at Baseline
Description Psychometric measure of phobic anxiety, scores range from 1 to 3. Higher scores represent greater phobic anxiety symptoms.
Time Frame Baseline

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 12 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.98
(0.39)
1.17
(0.28)
1.23
(0.41)
0.83
(0.33)
23. Primary Outcome
Title Crown-Crisp Experiential Index - Phobic Anxiety Scale at 6-months Follow-up
Description Psychometric measure of phobic anxiety, scores range from 1 to 3. Higher scores represent greater phobic anxiety symptoms.
Time Frame Six-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 12 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.92
(0.40)
1.04
(0.38)
1.07
(0.36)
0.84
(0.35)
24. Primary Outcome
Title Crown-Crisp Experiential Index - Phobic Anxiety Scale at 12-months Follow-up
Description Psychometric measure of phobic anxiety, scores range from 1 to 3. Higher scores represent greater phobic anxiety symptoms.
Time Frame Twelve-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 12 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
0.98
(0.40)
1.13
(0.35)
1.07
(0.40)
0.93
(0.35)
25. Secondary Outcome
Title SF-36 Physical Component Summary Score at Baseline
Description Quality of life measure of physical health, scores range from 0 to 100 with higher scores representing better physical health.
Time Frame Baseline

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
39.19
(10.46)
36.13
(7.06)
37.60
(11.81)
38.85
(10.15)
26. Secondary Outcome
Title SF-36 Physical Component Summary Score at 6-months Follow-up
Description Quality of life measure of physical health, scores range from 0 to 100 with higher scores representing better physical health.
Time Frame Six-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
42.54
(10.58)
41.46
(12.43)
41.22
(12.85)
42.69
(10.06)
27. Secondary Outcome
Title SF-36 Physical Component Summary Score at 12-months Follow-up
Description Quality of life measure of physical health, scores range from 0 to 100 with higher scores representing better physical health.
Time Frame Twelve-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
Measure Participants 73 18 16 76
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
42.65
(10.33)
42.70
(10.44)
42.82
(14.53)
41.54
(11.23)
28. Secondary Outcome
Title Percentage of Participants Who Received ICD Therapies
Description Percentage of participants who received ICD shocks or anti-tachycardia therapies, data extracted from participants ICD devices over follow-up.
Time Frame 12-months follow-up

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care Cognitive Behaviour Therapy
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. This includes all men and women who received UCC. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet. These data are on men and women combined within CBT.
Measure Participants 97 96
Number [Percentage of participants]
30.5
39.6%
31.9
167.9%

Adverse Events

Time Frame
Adverse Event Reporting Description Death was the only adverse event collected.
Arm/Group Title Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Arm/Group Description Cardiac care as usual for the hospital clinic which includesstandard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight individual sessions of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered via telephone counselling, plus a participant psycho-educational booklet Cardiac care as usual which includes standard educational materials explaining their heart disease and the ICD device. Follow-up appointments include device interrogation (i.e., to extract arrhythmia events and ICD therapies) and trouble-shooting at 6-months intervals, cardiac care as necessary, and nonsystematic supportive reassurance delivered informally in the clinic. Each centre also had access to a cardiac rehabilitation program and psychiatric consultation as needed. Eight sessions of individual cognitive therapy delivered via telephone plus a psycho-educational booklet.
All Cause Mortality
Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
Total / (NaN) / (NaN) / (NaN) / (NaN)
Serious Adverse Events
Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
Total 4/77 (5.2%) 1/19 (5.3%) 2/20 (10%) 1/77 (1.3%)
General disorders
Deaths 4/77 (5.2%) 1/19 (5.3%) 2/20 (10%) 1/77 (1.3%)
Other (Not Including Serious) Adverse Events
Usual Cardiac Care - Men Cognitive Behaviour Therapy - Women Usual Cardiac Care - Women Cognitive Therapy Group - Men
Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
Total 0/0 (NaN) 0/0 (NaN) 0/0 (NaN) 0/0 (NaN)

Limitations/Caveats

[Not Specified]

More Information

Certain Agreements

All Principal Investigators ARE employed by the organization sponsoring the study.

There is NOT an agreement between Principal Investigators and the Sponsor (or its agents) that restricts the PI's rights to discuss or publish trial results after the trial is completed.

Results Point of Contact

Name/Title Dr. Jane Irvine
Organization University Health Network, Toronto General Hospital
Phone (416) 736-5115 ext 22444
Email jirvine@yorku.ca
Responsible Party:
, ,
ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier:
NCT00152763
Other Study ID Numbers:
  • NA 5170
  • Grant number NA 5170
First Posted:
Sep 9, 2005
Last Update Posted:
Jan 28, 2011
Last Verified:
Jan 1, 2011