EGFGP: Assessment of "Gut Feelings" Accuracy Regarding the Effect of Professional Experience in General Practitioners in Clinical Decision Making
Study Details
Study Description
Brief Summary
Knowledge, experience and professional development limit the risk of diagnostic error for the clinician in daily practice. However, research has shown that other non-analytical factors are involved in clinical decision making. Intuition (or "gut feelings") is a subjective element involved in medical decision-making, and its place and relevance are being explored. The concept of "gut feelings" comes from General Practitioners (GPs) themselves and their description of their own practice. Several studies have shown its place in medical decision-making models, particularly in the face of diagnostic uncertainty.
A questionnaire used as a standardized measurement tool for gut feelings was created to address this issue. The Gut Feelings Questionnaire (GFQ) has been translated into French, German and Polish during a standardized linguistic validation procedure. It is currently validated and available in five languages. The QGF has been tested and validated in clinical practice by Belgian, French and Dutch physicians. Its feasibility has been evaluated in these three health systems.
The Gut Feelings Questionnaire was used in a prospective study to determine the accuracy of the sense of alarm in patients consulting their GP for chest pain and/or dyspnea. But the role of the practitioner's experience has not been studied: is the gut feeling more accurate in experienced GPs than in first semester interns in general practice?
| Condition or Disease | Intervention/Treatment | Phase |
|---|---|---|
|
Study Design
Arms and Interventions
| Arm | Intervention/Treatment |
|---|---|
| General practitioner Answer the Gut Fellings questionnaire |
Other: Gut Fellings questionnaire
Answer the Gut Fellings questionnaire
|
| Internal Answer the Gut Fellings questionnaire |
Other: Gut Fellings questionnaire
Answer the Gut Fellings questionnaire
|
Outcome Measures
Primary Outcome Measures
- Error assessment [Day 1]
Gut Feelings Questionnaire response score comparaison for each of 12 clinical vignettes. Gut Feelings Questionnaire is a 10-item questionnaire based on the definitions of the sense of alarm and the sense of reassurance. The purpose of the Gut Feelings Questionnaire is to determine the presence or absence of gut feelings in the diagnostic reasoning. These gut feelings are defined as a 'sense of alarm' and a 'sense of reassurance'. A 'sense of alarm' implies that a GP worries about a patient's health status, even though he/she has found no specific indications yet; it is a sense that 'there's something wrong here'. A 'sense of reassurance' means that a GP feels secure about the further management and course of a patient's problem, even though he/she may not be certain about the diagnosis: everything fits in.
Secondary Outcome Measures
- Types of professional activity of installed GPs [Day 1]
To study the relationship between professional variables and GFQ response score errors in the GP population. Professional variables are be : University training supervisor (yes/no); type of activity (group of physicians, alone, multiprofessional group); place of practice (town of <2000 inhabitants, between 2000 and 5000, over 5000); number of years of practice in general medicine.
- Type of care [Day 1]
Care proposed at the end of each clinical vignette (answers to question n°11 of the questionnaire)
- Practitioner's orientation [Day 1]
Items highlighted by each participant within the clinical vignette that contributed to the practitioner's orientation (identification of a sense of alarm or a sense of reassurance) to complete the Gut Fellings Questionnaire.
Eligibility Criteria
Criteria
Inclusion Criteria:
-
GP population: General practitioners established for more than 3 years
-
Intern population: Interns in general medicine in the first year of the third cycle of the diploma of specialized studies in general medicine
Exclusion Criteria:
-
For the 2 populations: Refusal to participate
-
Intern population: Interns in the second and third year of the diploma of specialized studies in general medicine
Contacts and Locations
Locations
| Site | City | State | Country | Postal Code | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Dr Marie BARAIS | Brest | France |
Sponsors and Collaborators
- University Hospital, Brest
Investigators
None specified.Study Documents (Full-Text)
None provided.More Information
Publications
None provided.- 29BRC21.0359 (EGFGP)