CIRT: Cardiovascular Inflammation Reduction Trial

Sponsor
Brigham and Women's Hospital (Other)
Overall Status
Completed
CT.gov ID
NCT01594333
Collaborator
National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI) (NIH)
4,786
470
2
78.9
10.2
0.1

Study Details

Study Description

Brief Summary

The Cardiovascular Inflammation Reduction Trial (CIRT) is a randomized clinical trial investigating whether taking low-dose methotrexate reduces heart attacks, strokes, or death in people with type 2 diabetes or metabolic syndrome that have had a heart attack or multiple coronary blockages. This trial is funded by the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI)/National Institutes of Health (NIH).

Condition or Disease Intervention/Treatment Phase
Phase 3

Detailed Description

While inflammation contributes crucially to atherothrombosis, it is unknown whether inhibition of inflammation per se will lower vascular event rates. The primary aim of the Cardiovascular Inflammation Reduction Trial (CIRT) is to directly test the inflammatory hypothesis of atherothrombosis by evaluating whether or not low-dose methotrexate (LDM) will reduce rates of myocardial infarction, stroke, and cardiovascular death among stable coronary artery disease patients with type 2 diabetes or metabolic syndrome, conditions associated with an enhanced pro-inflammatory response. CIRT is a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, multi-center, event-driven trial that will randomize 7,000 men and women from the United States and Canada. Following a five- to six-week open-label run-in (maximum 8 weeks), eligible participants who have either suffered documented myocardial infarction in the past or have angiographically demonstrated multivessel coronary artery disease in the past will be randomly allocated over a three to four year period to usual care plus placebo or usual care plus LDM. The target methotrexate dose among those allocated to active therapy is 15 to 20 mg po per week, a dose within the range of that commonly used for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis. All study participants will additionally receive 1.0 mg oral folate to be taken daily six days per week. LDM complications will be minimized through education programs for all investigators and coordinators, through enhanced communication with study participants, by limiting enrollment to those with no evidence of malignancy, hepatitis, renal dysfunction, chronic infection, pulmonary disease, or other risk factors for toxicity; by conducting an initial 5- to 6-week active-therapy run-in (maximum 8 weeks) designed to eliminate individuals who are either intolerant of or unable to adhere to treatment before randomization; and through regular monitoring of liver function and hematologic indices using a centralized methodology designed to ensure participant safety, allow for dose adjustments while maintaining the study blind, and provide an efficient method to address issues of compliance and follow-up on a cost-effective centralized basis. The primary trial endpoint is the rate of myocardial infarction, stroke, or cardiovascular death. Secondary and tertiary endpoints include all-cause mortality, coronary revascularization, incident congestive heart failure, incident peripheral artery disease, incident venous thrombosis, clinically significant aortic stenosis, incident atrial fibrillation, incident diabetes among those with metabolic syndrome but not diabetes at study entry, and hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) control among those with diabetes at study entry. The trial is event driven such that in the absence of extreme effects, the trial will conclude after accrual of at least 530 primary endpoints, an effect estimated to provide 90 percent power to detect a 25 percent relative risk reduction. The potential clinical impact of CIRT is broad as it has sufficient power to directly address core issues in the inflammatory hypothesis of atherothrombosis, and thus, if successful, will open major new directions for cardiovascular treatment.

Study Design

Study Type:
Interventional
Actual Enrollment :
4786 participants
Allocation:
Randomized
Intervention Model:
Parallel Assignment
Masking:
Triple (Participant, Care Provider, Investigator)
Primary Purpose:
Treatment
Official Title:
A Randomized, Double-blind, Placebo-controlled, Event-driven Trial of Weekly Low-dose Methotrexate (LDM) in the Prevention of Cardiovascular Events Among Stable Coronary Artery Disease Patients With Type 2 Diabetes or Metabolic Syndrome
Study Start Date :
Apr 1, 2013
Actual Primary Completion Date :
Apr 15, 2019
Actual Study Completion Date :
Oct 30, 2019

Arms and Interventions

Arm Intervention/Treatment
Experimental: Methotrexate

Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week

Drug: Methotrexate
Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week
Other Names:
  • Trexall, TEVA Inc (brand of methotrexate)
  • Placebo Comparator: Placebo

    Placebo: Tablet, Oral weekly plus 1.0mg folic acid 6 days/week

    Drug: Placebo
    Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week

    Outcome Measures

    Primary Outcome Measures

    1. Number of Subjects With Major Adverse Cardiovascular Events [From randomization to trial end (April 2, 2018) up to a maximum of 5 years]

      The first occurrence of Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event which is defined as the occurrence of one or more of the following: Cardiovascular Death, Non-Fatal Myocardial Infarction or Non-Fatal Stroke.

    2. Number of Subjects With Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event or Hospitalization for Unstable Angina That Led to Urgent Coronary Revascularization [From randomization to trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to a maximum of 5 years]

      The first occurrence of Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event or Hospitalization for Unstable Angina that led to Urgent Coronary Revascularization.

    Secondary Outcome Measures

    1. Number of Subjects With All-cause Mortality [From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) up to a maximum of 5 years]

      Subjects who died from any cause.

    2. Number of Subjects With Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event or Any Coronary Revascularization [From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to a maximum of 5 years]

      The first occurrence of Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event or Any Coronary Revascularization.

    3. Number of Subjects With Hospitalization for Congestive Heart Failure [From randomization to trial end (April 2, 2018) up to a maximum of 5 years]

      The first occurrence of Hospitalization for Congestive Heart Failure

    4. Number of Subjects With Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event, Coronary Revascularization, Hospitalization for Congestive Heart Failure or All Cause Mortality [From randomization to trial end (April 2, 2018) up to a maximum of 5 years]

      The first occurrence of Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event, Coronary Revascularization, Hospitalization for Congestive Heart Failure or All Cause Mortality.

    5. Number of Subjects With New Onset Type 2 Diabetes [From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to 5 years]

      New onset type 2 diabetes among those without diabetes at baseline. Baseline diabetes is defined as any of the following prior to randomization: clinician report of diabetes, use of antidiabetic medication, hbA1c >=6.5 or fasting plasma glucose >=126.

    Other Outcome Measures

    1. Number of Subjects With Hospitalization for Unstable Angina That Led to Unplanned Coronary Revascularization [From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) up to 5 years]

      The first occurrence of hospitalization for unstable angina that led to unplanned coronary revascularization

    2. Number of Subjects With Coronary Revascularization [From randomization to trial end (April 2, 2018) up to 5 years]

      The first occurrence of coronary revascularization

    3. Number of Subjects With Peripheral Artery Disease [From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to 5 years]

      The first occurrence of new or worsening of peripheral artery disease

    4. Number of Subjects With Deep Vein Thrombosis or Pulmonary Embolism [From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to 5 years]

      The first occurrence of symptomatic deep vein thrombosis or pulmonary embolism

    5. Number of Subjects With Aortic Stenosis [From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to 5 years]

      The first occurrence of clinically significant aortic stenosis

    6. Number of Subjects With Atrial Fibrillation [From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to 5 years]

      The first occurrence of new or worsening of atrial fibrillation

    Eligibility Criteria

    Criteria

    Ages Eligible for Study:
    18 Years and Older
    Sexes Eligible for Study:
    All
    Accepts Healthy Volunteers:
    No
    Inclusion Criteria:
    • Age ≥ 18 years at screening

    • Documented past history of myocardial infarction OR past evidence of multivessel coronary artery disease by angiography.

    • To qualify on the basis of past history of myocardial infarction, the event must be documented either by hospital records or by evidence on current ECG of Q waves in two contiguous leads and/or an imaging test demonstrating wall motion abnormality or scar. The patient must also have completed any planned coronary revascularization procedures associated with the qualifying event, and be clinically stable for at least 60 days prior to screening.

    • To qualify on the basis of multivessel coronary disease, there must be past angiographic evidence of atherosclerosis in at least 2 major epicardial vessels defined either as the presence of a stent, a coronary bypass graft, or an angiographic lesion of 60% or greater. Left main coronary artery disease that has been revascularized with a stent or bypass graft will qualify as multivessel disease, as will the presence of a 50% or greater isolated left main stenosis. The patient must also have completed any planned coronary revascularization procedures associated with the qualifying event, and be clinically stable for at least 60 days prior to screening.

    • History of type 2 diabetes or metabolic syndrome at time of study enrollment

    • Willingness to participate as evidenced by signing the study informed consent

    Exclusion Criteria:
    • Prior history of chronic infectious disease, tuberculosis, or severe fungal disease; chronic hepatitis B or C infection; renal insufficiency; interstitial pneumonitis, bronchiectasis, or pulmonary fibrosis; known chronic pericardial effusion, pleural effusion, or ascites; chronic liver disease; myeloproliferative disorders in the past 5 years; non-basal cell malignancy or treated lymphoproliferative disease within the past 5 years; known HIV positive; life expectancy of < 3 years;

    • Chronic inflammatory condition such as lupus or rheumatoid arthritis, ulcerative colitis or Crohn's disease

    • White blood cell count < 3,500/ul, hematocrit < 32 percent, or platelet count < 75,000/ul

    • Liver transaminase levels (AST or ALT) >upper limit of normal (ULN) or albumin < the lower limit of normal (LLN);

    • Creatinine clearance < 40 ml/min as estimated with the Cockcroft-Gault equation;

    • History of alcohol abuse or unwillingness to limit alcohol consumption to less than 4 drinks per week

    • Women of child bearing potential, even if they are currently using contraception, and women intending to breastfeed.

    • Men who plan to father children during the study period or who are unwilling to use effective forms of contraception.

    • Requirement for use of drugs that alter folate metabolism (trimethoprim/sulfamethoxazol) or reduce tubular excretion (probenecid) or known allergies to antibiotics making avoidance of trimethoprim impossible;

    • Current indication for methotrexate therapy;

    • Chronic use of oral steroid therapy or other immunosuppressive or biologic response modifiers. Eligible study participants will be encouraged to have up to date pneumococcal and influenza vaccinations as recommended based on their age and underlying medical conditions.

    • Chest X-ray evidence in the past 12 months of interstitial pneumonitis, bronchiectasis, or pulmonary fibrosis. For participants who do not have a chest X-ray in the prior 12 months, a chest X-ray will be obtained at baseline as part of the study protocol.

    • New York Heart Association Class IV congestive heart failure.

    Contacts and Locations

    Locations

    Site City State Country Postal Code
    1 University of Alabama at Birmingham Birmingham Alabama United States 35294
    2 Appalachian Research Associates Fort Payne Alabama United States 35967
    3 Avant Research Associates, LLC Guntersville Alabama United States 35976
    4 Saadat Ansari MD LLC Huntsville Alabama United States 35801
    5 University of South Alabama: Division of Clinical Research Mobile Alabama United States 36617
    6 Heart Vascular of Northern Arizona Cottonwood Arizona United States 86326
    7 CardioVascular Associates of Mesa Mesa Arizona United States 85206
    8 Arizona Arthritis & Rheumatology Research Phoenix Arizona United States 85032
    9 Scottsdale Medical Imaging Scottsdale Arizona United States 85258
    10 The Heart Clinic Scottsdale Arizona United States 85258
    11 Pima Heart Tucson Arizona United States 85718
    12 Southern Arizona VA Health Care System Tucson Arizona United States 85723
    13 Arkansas Cardiology Little Rock Arkansas United States 72205
    14 Arkansas Heart Hospital Little Rock Arkansas United States 72211
    15 Oracle Clinical Research, Inc. Anaheim California United States 92801
    16 Medical Group of Culver City Culver City California United States 90230
    17 Touro University California- Solano County Affiliated Clinics Fairfield California United States 94533
    18 University Of California San Francisco Fresno California United States 93701
    19 VACCHCS Fresno California United States 93703
    20 UCSD Sulpizio Cardiovascular Center La Jolla California United States 92037
    21 University Of California San Diego La Jolla California United States 92093
    22 Desert Medical Care & Wellness La Quinta California United States 92253
    23 Kumar Medical Corporation Lancaster California United States 93534
    24 Loma Linda University Health Loma Linda California United States 92354
    25 VA Loma Linda Healthcare System Loma Linda California United States 92357
    26 Long Beach Center for Clinical Research Long Beach California United States 90807
    27 Cardiovascular Innovation and Research Long Beach California United States 90813
    28 Los Alamitos Cardiovascular Los Alamitos California United States 90720
    29 Faye Montegrande Md. Clinical Research Los Angeles California United States 90004
    30 Eastside Clinical Research Associates Los Angeles California United States 90022
    31 Salman Khan A. Medical Corporation Los Angeles California United States 90033
    32 University of Southern California Los Angeles California United States 90033
    33 West LA VA Medical Center Los Angeles California United States 90049
    34 VA Northern California Health Care Mather California United States 95655
    35 Valley Clinical Trials, Inc. Northridge California United States 91325
    36 Orange County Heart Institute & Research Orange California United States 92868
    37 University of CA Irvine Medical Center Orange California United States 92868
    38 Diverse Research Solutions Oxnard California United States 93030
    39 Huntington Memorial Hospital Pasadena California United States 91105
    40 Central Coast Cardiology Salinas California United States 93901
    41 Richard G. Friedman, MD San Diego California United States 92103
    42 Ritchken and First MDs San Diego California United States 92117
    43 Foundation for Cardiovascular Medicine San Diego California United States 92121
    44 San Diego Cardiac Center San Diego California United States 92123
    45 Veterans Affairs San Diego Healthcare System San Diego California United States 92161
    46 UCSF at Zuckerberg SF General Hospital San Francisco California United States 94110
    47 Coastal Heart Medical Group, Inc. Santa Ana California United States 92704
    48 Comprehensive Cardiovascular Care Santa Maria California United States 93454
    49 Pacific Heart and Vascular Medical Group Stockton California United States 95210
    50 Manoj D. Aswani M.D. Thousand Oaks California United States 91360
    51 Touro University California- Solano Public Health Affiliated Clinics Vallejo California United States 94592
    52 Munni R. Selagamsetty, Md, Pc Colorado Springs Colorado United States 80910
    53 Vijay - Aurora Denver Cardiology Denver Colorado United States 80218
    54 Colorado Health Medical Group Heart Center of the Rockies Fort Collins Colorado United States 80528
    55 Medical Center of the Rockies Research Fort Collins Colorado United States 80528
    56 Unrein - Rocky Vista University Health Center Parker Colorado United States 80134
    57 Connecticut Heart and Vascular Center Bridgeport Connecticut United States 06606
    58 Bridgeport Hospital Bridgeport Connecticut United States 06610
    59 Cardiology Physicians/Red Clay Research Newark Delaware United States 19713
    60 Boisey Barnes MD, PC Washington District of Columbia United States 20024
    61 GWU Medical Faculty Associatin, Inc. Washington District of Columbia United States 20037
    62 Pianko - Aventura Research Center, LLC Aventura Florida United States 33180
    63 North Ridge Heart Associates Boca Raton Florida United States 33434
    64 St. Francis Medical Institute Clearwater Florida United States 33765
    65 Gonzalez MD & Aswad MD Health Ser Coral Gables Florida United States 33134
    66 American Research Institute, Inc. Cutler Bay Florida United States 33157
    67 Daytona Heart Group Daytona Beach Florida United States 32114
    68 Daytona Heart Group DeLand Florida United States 32720
    69 Seidman Clinical Trials Delray Beach Florida United States 33484
    70 Steven Cohen MD Delray Beach Florida United States 33484
    71 Infinite Clinical Research Doral Florida United States 33126
    72 International Research Partners, LLC Doral Florida United States 33166
    73 Medical Research Institute at Doral, Inc. Doral Florida United States 33178
    74 Lake Internal Medicine Assocaties Eustis Florida United States 32726
    75 Invesclinic Fort Lauderdale Florida United States 33308
    76 Primary Care Associates Fort Myers Florida United States 33907
    77 Lee Physician Group Fort Myers Florida United States 33908
    78 The Cardiac and Vascular Institute Gainesville Florida United States 32605
    79 University of Florida Gainesville Florida United States 32610
    80 Qway Research Hialeah Florida United States 33010
    81 State of the Art Research Hialeah Florida United States 33010
    82 Healing Touch C&C Research Hialeah Florida United States 33012
    83 Luzmed Clinical Research Institute Hialeah Florida United States 33012
    84 Viviana Perez MD Research & Cosmetics Hialeah Florida United States 33012
    85 Elite Cardiac Research Center LLC Hialeah Florida United States 33013
    86 Nova Clinical Research Clinic Hialeah Florida United States 33013
    87 Best Quality Research, Inc. Hialeah Florida United States 33016
    88 South Florida Research Solutions, LLC Hollywood Florida United States 33021
    89 John Gutleber Medical Research Office Homestead Florida United States 33030
    90 Cardiovascular Medical Associates of Palm Beach Jupiter Florida United States 33458
    91 Hope Clinical Research Kissimmee Florida United States 34758
    92 SIH Research, LLC Kissimmee Florida United States 34759
    93 Lakes Research, LLC Miami Lakes Florida United States 33014
    94 Veritas Research Corp. Miami Lakes Florida United States 33014
    95 Ocean Blue Medical Research Center Miami Springs Florida United States 33166
    96 Medical Research Center of Florida Miami Florida United States 33122
    97 LG Diagnostics, Inc. Miami Florida United States 33126
    98 St. Paul Medical Research Center, Inc. Miami Florida United States 33126
    99 Team Medical Research Miami Florida United States 33134
    100 Paradise Clinical Research, LLC Miami Florida United States 33144
    101 GAD Research Center Miami Florida United States 33155
    102 Innovation Research Institute, Inc. Miami Florida United States 33155
    103 Sanitas Research Miami Florida United States 33155
    104 Segui - Med Care Research Miami Florida United States 33165
    105 South Florida Research Group, LLC Miami Florida United States 33176
    106 Vista Health Research, LLC Miami Florida United States 33176
    107 D De La Vega MD Research Group Miami Florida United States 33186
    108 Southwest Florida Research, LLC Naples Florida United States 34102
    109 Orlando Healthy Heart Institute Orlando Florida United States 32806
    110 Palm Beach Gardens Research Center, LLC Palm Beach Gardens Florida United States 33410
    111 Broward Research Center Pembroke Pines Florida United States 33024
    112 Pioneer Clinical Research Pembroke Pines Florida United States 33024
    113 Sandoval - Broward Research Center Pembroke Pines Florida United States 33204
    114 Bay Area Heart Center: 49th Street Saint Petersburg Florida United States 33705
    115 Bay Area Heart Center: 7th Avenue Saint Petersburg Florida United States 33705
    116 Lenus Research & Medical Group Sweetwater Florida United States 33172
    117 DBC Research Tamarac Florida United States 33321
    118 Asclepes Research Centers Weeki Wachee Florida United States 34607
    119 Gupta - Premier Heart and Vascular Center Wesley Chapel Florida United States 33544
    120 Athens Regional Medical Center Athens Georgia United States 30606
    121 Atlanta Veterans Affairs Medical Center Atlanta Georgia United States 30033
    122 Laureate Medical Group at Northside Atlanta Georgia United States 30308
    123 Synergy Therapeutic Partners Atlanta Georgia United States 30308
    124 Northside Hospital Atlanta Georgia United States 30342
    125 Atlanta Heart Specialists, LLC Cumming Georgia United States 30041
    126 Heart and Rhythm Specialists Dalton Georgia United States 30720
    127 Albert F. Johary MD, PC Dunwoody Georgia United States 30338
    128 Infinite Clinical Trials Riverdale Georgia United States 30274
    129 Atlanta Vanguard Medical Associates Smyrna Georgia United States 30082
    130 Herman Clinical Research, LLC Suwanee Georgia United States 30024
    131 Atlanta Heart Specialists, LLC Tucker Georgia United States 30084
    132 Cardiology Associates of Vidalia, P.C. Vidalia Georgia United States 30474
    133 VA Pacific Islands Health Care System Honolulu Hawaii United States 96819
    134 St. Luke's Idaho Cardiology Associates Boise Idaho United States 83712
    135 Clinical Research Prime Idaho Falls Idaho United States 83404
    136 Northwest Heart Clinical Research Arlington Heights Illinois United States 60005
    137 University of Chicago Medical Center Chicago Illinois United States 60637
    138 Advocate Med Group-Heart & Vascular Of Illinois Chicago Illinois United States 60657
    139 Illinois Heart & Lung Research Center, SC Normal Illinois United States 61761
    140 Captain James A. Lovell Federal Health North Chicago Illinois United States 60064
    141 Specialty Physicians of Illinois, LLC Olympia Fields Illinois United States 60461
    142 Advanced CardioVascular Consultants Rock Island Illinois United States 61201
    143 Cardiospecialists, LTD Dyer Indiana United States 46311
    144 Martin - Martin Family Practice and Research Evansville Indiana United States 47714
    145 Krannert Institute Of Cardiology Indianapolis Indiana United States 46202
    146 Community Hospital South Indianapolis Indiana United States 46227
    147 Indiana Heart Physicians Indianapolis Indiana United States 46237
    148 Medical Consultants, PC Muncie Indiana United States 47303
    149 Iowa Heart Center West Des Moines Iowa United States 50266
    150 Stahl - Midwest Heart & Vascular Specialists Overland Park Kansas United States 66209
    151 Professional Research Network of KS Wichita Kansas United States 67203
    152 Robert J. Dole VAMC Wichita Kansas United States 67230
    153 University of Kentucky Lexington Kentucky United States 40536
    154 Robley Rex VAMC Louisville Kentucky United States 40202
    155 Stoddard - University of Louisville Louisville Kentucky United States 40202
    156 Bays - L-MARC Research Center Louisville Kentucky United States 40213
    157 Research Integrity LLC Owensboro Kentucky United States 42303
    158 Dorothy H. Banish, MD, APMC Study Group Covington Louisiana United States 70433
    159 Avant Research Associates, LLC Crowley Louisiana United States 70526
    160 North Oaks Cardiology Hammond Louisiana United States 70403
    161 American Clinical Research, LLC Marrero Louisiana United States 70072
    162 Otis Barnum D.O.P.C. Natchitoches Louisiana United States 71457
    163 Tulane University Office of Health Research New Orleans Louisiana United States 70112
    164 Veterans Affairs Medical Center Shreveport Shreveport Louisiana United States 71101
    165 Maine Research Associates Auburn Maine United States 04210
    166 Paul A. Shapero, M.D. Bangor Maine United States 04401
    167 Southern Maine Health Care Biddeford Maine United States 04005
    168 InterMed, PA Portland Maine United States 04101
    169 Maine Medical Partners Maine Health Cardiology South Portland Maine United States 04106
    170 Maine Centers for Healthcare Westbrook Maine United States 04092
    171 Sinai Center for Thrombosis Research Baltimore Maryland United States 21215
    172 St. Mary's Medical Center Charlotte Hall Maryland United States 20622
    173 Calvert Memorial Hospital Clinton Maryland United States 20735
    174 Shah Associates, MD, LLC Prince Frederick Maryland United States 20678
    175 Peninsula Cardiology Associates Salisbury Maryland United States 21804
    176 IRC Clinics Towson Maryland United States 21204
    177 Brigham and Women's Hospital Boston Massachusetts United States 02115
    178 St. Elizabeth's Medical Center Boston Massachusetts United States 02135
    179 MGH Cardiology Boston Massachusetts United States 02214
    180 Joslin Diabetes Center Boston Massachusetts United States 02215
    181 Lahey Hospital and Medical Center Burlington Massachusetts United States 01805
    182 Massachusetts General Hospital - Chelsea Health Care Center Chelsea Massachusetts United States 02150
    183 Pentucket Medical Associates, Inc. Haverhill Massachusetts United States 01830
    184 VA Central Western Massachusetts Healthca Leeds Massachusetts United States 01053
    185 South Shore Internal Medicine Milton Massachusetts United States 02186
    186 Lahey Medical Center Peabody Massachusetts United States 02149
    187 North Shore Cardiovascular Associates Salem Massachusetts United States 01907
    188 Reliant Medical Group Worcester Massachusetts United States 01608
    189 Endeavor Medical Research Alpena Michigan United States 49707
    190 John D. Dingell Veterans Affairs Medical Center Detroit Michigan United States 48201
    191 Trace Research Group at Wayne State University Detroit Michigan United States 48201
    192 Henry Ford Hospital Detroit Michigan United States 48202
    193 Flint Clinical Research Flint Michigan United States 48503
    194 Apex Medical Research MI, Inc. Flint Michigan United States 48504
    195 Garden City Hospital Garden City Michigan United States 48135
    196 Genesys Regional Medical Center Grand Blanc Michigan United States 48439
    197 National Clinical LLC Hamtramck Michigan United States 48212
    198 Academic Cardiology Associates PC Rochester Hills Michigan United States 48307
    199 Beaumont Health Center Royal Oak Michigan United States 48073
    200 Covenant Medical Center, Inc. Saginaw Michigan United States 48602
    201 Mid-Michigan Heart & Vascular Center Saginaw Michigan United States 48609
    202 Centra Care Heart & Vascular Center at St. Cloud Hospital Saint Cloud Minnesota United States 56303
    203 United Heart and Vascular Clinic Saint Paul Minnesota United States 55102
    204 Gulfside Clinical Research, LLC Gulfport Mississippi United States 39501
    205 University of MS Medical Center Jackson Mississippi United States 39216
    206 David M. Headley M.D. PA Planters Clinic Port Gibson Mississippi United States 39150
    207 Stern Cardiovascular Foundation, Inc. Southaven Mississippi United States 38671
    208 Center for Advanced Medicine and Research LLC Bridgeton Missouri United States 63044
    209 Clinical Research Center University of Missouri Columbia Missouri United States 65212
    210 Quantum Research LLC Festus Missouri United States 63028
    211 Midwest Cardiology Associates Independence Missouri United States 64057
    212 Freeman Health System Joplin Missouri United States 64804
    213 VA Medical Center Kansas City Kansas City Missouri United States 64128
    214 Lake Regional Cardiovascular Institute Osage Beach Missouri United States 65065
    215 VA St. Louis Health Care System (VASTLHCS) Saint Louis Missouri United States 63106
    216 SLUCare Cardiology Saint Louis Missouri United States 63110
    217 Washington University Saint Louis Missouri United States 63110
    218 Clinical Investigators LLC Saint Louis Missouri United States 63119
    219 Consult and Research Associates Saint Louis Missouri United States 63122
    220 Center for Advanced Medicine and Research Saint Peters Missouri United States 63303
    221 CoxHealth: Wheeler Heart & Vascular Center Springfield Missouri United States 65807
    222 Mercy Medical Research Institute Springfield Missouri United States 65807
    223 Great Falls Clinic Clinical Research Deptartment Great Falls Montana United States 59420
    224 Cone - Montana Medical Research Missoula Montana United States 59801
    225 Barrett Clinic, P.C. La Vista Nebraska United States 68128
    226 Heart Consultants Omaha Nebraska United States 68114
    227 Alegent Creighton Health Omaha Nebraska United States 68131
    228 University of Nebraska Medical Center Omaha Nebraska United States 68198
    229 Internal Medicine Clinic Las Vegas Nevada United States 89102
    230 Red Rock Clinical Research, LLC Las Vegas Nevada United States 89146
    231 Sierra Nevada Health Care System Reno Nevada United States 89502
    232 Renown Inst for Heart & Vasc Health Reno Nevada United States 89503
    233 Lahey Cardiology Nashua New Hampshire United States 03060
    234 Family Health at Mount Olive Flanders New Jersey United States 07836
    235 Cardiocare Hillsborough New Jersey United States 08844
    236 New Jersey Heart Linden New Jersey United States 07063
    237 Jersey Shore University Medical Center Neptune New Jersey United States 07753
    238 Cardiovascular Institute New Brunswick New Jersey United States 08901
    239 Palisade Medical Center North Bergen New Jersey United States 07047
    240 The Valley Hospital Ridgewood New Jersey United States 07450
    241 Mercer Bucks Cardiology Robbinsville New Jersey United States 08691
    242 Cardio Metabolic Institute Somerset New Jersey United States 08873
    243 Holy Name Medical Center, Inc. Teaneck New Jersey United States 07666
    244 Total Cardiology Care, LLC Wayne New Jersey United States 07470
    245 Westwood Cardiology Associates Westwood New Jersey United States 07675
    246 Presbyterian Heart Group Albuquerque New Mexico United States 87106
    247 Albany Medical College Albany New York United States 12208
    248 Albany Stratton VA Medical Center Albany New York United States 12208
    249 Novel Research of New York, LLC Bronx New York United States 10461
    250 Montefiore Medical Center Bronx New York United States 10467
    251 Brown - SUNY Downstate Medical Center Brooklyn New York United States 11203
    252 Buffalo Heart Group Buffalo New York United States 14215
    253 Bassett Healthcare Network Cooperstown New York United States 13326
    254 NYU Hudson Valley Cardiology Cortlandt Manor New York United States 10567
    255 NYHQ Flushing New York United States 11355
    256 Jamaica Hospital Medical Center Jamaica New York United States 11418
    257 Long Island Heart Associates Mineola New York United States 11501
    258 Winthrop University Hospital Mineola New York United States 11501
    259 Long Island Jewish Medical Center New Hyde Park New York United States 11040
    260 Queens Long Island Medical Group New Hyde Park New York United States 11577
    261 Chinatown Cardiology, PC New York New York United States 10013
    262 Weill Cornell Medical College and NY Presbyterian New York New York United States 10021
    263 Mount Sinai School of Medicine New York New York United States 10029
    264 DiGiovanna Institute for Medical Education and Research North Massapequa New York United States 11758
    265 Champlain Valley Physician Hospital Plattsburgh New York United States 12901
    266 Cardiology Associates of Schenectady Schenectady New York United States 12309
    267 Clinical Study Center of Asheville Asheville North Carolina United States 28801
    268 Metrolina Internal Medicine Charlotte North Carolina United States 28204
    269 Gaffney Health Services Charlotte North Carolina United States 28205
    270 Carolinas Research Center Charlotte North Carolina United States 28215
    271 Eastern Carolina Cardiovascular, PA Elizabeth City North Carolina United States 27909
    272 Eastern Cardiology Greenville North Carolina United States 27834
    273 Northside Clinical Research Lenoir North Carolina United States 28645
    274 Lake Shore Clinical Research, LLC. Mooresville North Carolina United States 28117
    275 Carteret Medical Group Morehead City North Carolina United States 28557
    276 Cardiology Associates of Carolinas, PA Morganton North Carolina United States 28655
    277 Eastern Nephrology Associates, PLLC New Bern North Carolina United States 28562
    278 Boice Willis Clinic Rocky Mount North Carolina United States 27804
    279 Sanford Cardiology Sanford North Carolina United States 27330
    280 Natalie A. Doyle, MD, PA Wilson North Carolina United States 27893
    281 Altru Health System Rehab Center Grand Forks North Dakota United States 58201
    282 Akron General Medical Center Akron Ohio United States 44307
    283 Ohio University Heritage College of Osteopathic Medicine Athens Ohio United States 45701
    284 Diabetes and Endocrinology Associates of Stark Cit Canton Ohio United States 44718
    285 The Lindner Research Center Cincinnati Ohio United States 45219
    286 Cleveland Clinic Cleveland Ohio United States 44195
    287 Optimed Research, LTD Columbus Ohio United States 43235
    288 Dayton Heart Center Dayton Ohio United States 45414
    289 Dayton Veteran Affairs Medical Center Dayton Ohio United States 45428
    290 Colonnade Medical Group Lancaster Ohio United States 43130
    291 Middletown Cardiovascular Associates Middletown Ohio United States 45044
    292 Comprehensive Heart Care, Inc. Toledo Ohio United States 43606
    293 Mount Carmel Clinical Cardiovascular Care Westerville Ohio United States 43081
    294 Premier Physicians Westlake Ohio United States 44154
    295 Wooster Heart Group Wooster Ohio United States 44691
    296 Unity Clinical Research Lindsay Oklahoma United States 73052
    297 COR Clinical Research, LLC Oklahoma City Oklahoma United States 73103
    298 Thadani - VA Medical Center Oklahoma City, OK Oklahoma City Oklahoma United States 73104
    299 Today Clinical Research Oklahoma City Oklahoma United States 73129
    300 Cardiovascular Health Clinic Oklahoma City Oklahoma United States 73134
    301 Oklahoma State University Center for Health Sciences Tulsa Oklahoma United States 74127
    302 Samaritan Health Services Corvallis Oregon United States 97330
    303 Southern Oregon Cardiology, LLC Medford Oregon United States 97504
    304 Oregon Health & Science University Portland Oregon United States 97239
    305 Center for Clinical Res. Abington Health Abington Pennsylvania United States 19001
    306 St. Luke's University Hospital Bethlehem Pennsylvania United States 18018
    307 Renu-Ca Research Institute, Lower Bucks Hospital Bristol Pennsylvania United States 19007
    308 Main Line Health Center, Broomall Broomall Pennsylvania United States 19008
    309 Spirit Physician Services, Inc Camp Hill Pennsylvania United States 17011
    310 The Chambersburg Hospital Chambersburg Pennsylvania United States 17201
    311 Central Bucks Cardiology Doylestown Pennsylvania United States 18901
    312 Altoona Center for Clinical Research Duncansville Pennsylvania United States 16635
    313 Heart Specialists of Lancaster County Ephrata Pennsylvania United States 17522
    314 Saint Vincent Consultants in Cardiovascular Diseases, LLC Erie Pennsylvania United States 16502
    315 Feasterville Family Healthcare Center Feasterville Pennsylvania United States 19053
    316 Christiana Care Health System Glen Mills Pennsylvania United States 19342
    317 Pinnacle Health Cardiovascular Institute Harrisburg Pennsylvania United States 17110
    318 George Isajiw, MD Lansdowne Pennsylvania United States 19050
    319 Bucks County Clinical Research Morrisville Pennsylvania United States 19067
    320 Drexel University College of Medicine Philadelphia Pennsylvania United States 19102
    321 Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania Philadelphia Pennsylvania United States 19104
    322 Lehigh Valley Health Services Sellersville Pennsylvania United States 18960
    323 Pish Medical Associates, Inc. Uniontown Pennsylvania United States 15401
    324 Lehigh Valley Family Practice Whitehall Pennsylvania United States 18052
    325 Wilkes-Barre VA Medical Center Wilkes-Barre Pennsylvania United States 18711
    326 Partners in Clinical Research Cumberland Rhode Island United States 02864
    327 Ocean State Clinical Research Prtnr Lincoln Rhode Island United States 02865
    328 Memorial Hospital of Rhode Island Pawtucket Rhode Island United States 02860
    329 The Miriam Hospital Providence Rhode Island United States 02906
    330 Ocean State Research Institute, Inc Providence Rhode Island United States 02908
    331 South Carolina Heart Center Columbia South Carolina United States 29204
    332 Amistad Research Center, LLC Columbia South Carolina United States 29223
    333 Charlotte Hearts Indian Land South Carolina United States 29707
    334 Miller - SC Internal Medicine Associates.: Irmo Irmo South Carolina United States 29063
    335 Inlet Cardiopulmonary & Associates Pawleys Island South Carolina United States 29585
    336 Fusion Clinical Research of Spartanburg Spartanburg South Carolina United States 29301
    337 Palmetto Research Center, LLC Spartanburg South Carolina United States 29302
    338 New Phase Research & Development Chattanooga Tennessee United States 37409
    339 Parkway Medical Group Fayetteville Tennessee United States 37334
    340 Stern Cardiovascular Foundation, Inc. Germantown Tennessee United States 38138
    341 Kore Cardiovascular Research Institutue Jackson Tennessee United States 38305
    342 New Phase Research & Development Knoxville Tennessee United States 37909
    343 Cardiovascular Research of Knoxville Knoxville Tennessee United States 37917
    344 Ramanathan - VAMC Memphis Memphis Tennessee United States 38104
    345 Clinical Research Center Meharry Medical College Nashville Tennessee United States 37208
    346 Avant Research Associates LLC Austin Texas United States 78704
    347 Texas Heart and Vascular Research, LLC Austin Texas United States 78745
    348 Southeast TX Clinical Research Center Beaumont Texas United States 77702
    349 Cornerstone Family Medicine Big Spring Texas United States 79720
    350 IMD Medical Center Carrollton Texas United States 75006
    351 Texas Health Physicians Group Carrollton Texas United States 75010
    352 Cardiovascular Research Institute of Dallas Dallas Texas United States 75231
    353 North Texas Health Center Dallas Texas United States 75231
    354 The Heart Center of Dallas Dallas Texas United States 75235
    355 Global Medical Research DeSoto Texas United States 75115
    356 The Medical Group of Texas Fort Worth Texas United States 76104
    357 Texas Health Physicians Group Fort Worth Texas United States 76107
    358 T&R Clinic, P.A. Haltom City Texas United States 76117
    359 Michele P. Sartori, MD Houston Texas United States 77030
    360 Grand Medical Care Katy Texas United States 77494
    361 Team Research Of Central Texas Killeen Texas United States 76543
    362 Houston Heart and Vascular Associates Kingwood Texas United States 77339
    363 Grace Research, LLC Marshall Texas United States 75670
    364 Valley Heart Consultants McAllen Texas United States 78503
    365 Heart Center, Palo Pinto General Hospital Mineral Wells Texas United States 76067
    366 Valley Central Research Inc Mission Texas United States 78572
    367 North Hills Medical Research, Inc North Richland Hills Texas United States 76180
    368 Grace Research, LLC Palestine Texas United States 75801
    369 Avant Research Associates, LLC Port Arthur Texas United States 77640
    370 Santoscoy - Health Texas Research Institute San Antonio Texas United States 78212
    371 Element Research Group San Antonio Texas United States 78229
    372 Schnitzler Cardiovascular Consultants San Antonio Texas United States 78229
    373 San Antonio Endovascular & Heart Institute San Antonio Texas United States 78268
    374 Acacia Medical Research Institute Sugar Land Texas United States 77478
    375 Health Plus Clinical Research Sugar Land Texas United States 77478
    376 Lone Star Heart and Vascular Center Tomball Texas United States 77375
    377 Northwest Houston Clinical Research Tomball Texas United States 77375
    378 Hillcrest Family Health Center Waco Texas United States 76710
    379 Utah Cardiology, P.C. Layton Utah United States 84041
    380 Utah Diabetes Center Salt Lake City Utah United States 84108
    381 VA Medical Center, White River Junction White River Junction Vermont United States 05009
    382 Burke Internal Medicine & Research Burke Virginia United States 22015
    383 Seven Corners Medical Research Center Falls Church Virginia United States 22044
    384 Hampton Family Practice Research Hampton Virginia United States 23666
    385 Tidewater Physicians Multispecialty Group Hampton Virginia United States 23666
    386 Virginia Cardiovascular Associates Manassas Virginia United States 20109
    387 Manassas Clinical Research Center Manassas Virginia United States 20110
    388 Tucker Cardiology Associates, P.C. Mechanicsville Virginia United States 23116
    389 TPMG Clinical Research Newport News Virginia United States 23606
    390 Sentara Norfolk General Hospital Norfolk Virginia United States 23507
    391 Roanoke Heart Institute PLC Roanoke Virginia United States 24014
    392 Cardinal Internal Medicine Associates Woodbridge Virginia United States 22192
    393 Tidewater Physicians Multispecialty Group Yorktown Virginia United States 23690
    394 Frandsen Family Medicine DBA Sound Medi Port Orchard Washington United States 98366
    395 Premier Clinical Research Spokane Washington United States 99202
    396 Kootenai Heart Clinics, LLC Spokane Washington United States 99204
    397 Northside Internal Medicine Spokane Washington United States 99208
    398 Northwest Medical Associates, P.S. Vancouver Washington United States 98684
    399 Cardiology Associates of Bellin Health Green Bay Wisconsin United States 54115
    400 Dean Foundation Madison Wisconsin United States 53715
    401 University Of Wisconsin Madison Wisconsin United States 53715
    402 Marshfield Clinic Marshfield Wisconsin United States 54449
    403 Columbia St. Mary's Milwaukee Wisconsin United States 53211
    404 Aurora St. Luke's Medical Center Milwaukee Wisconsin United States 53215
    405 The Medical Arts Health Research Group North Vancouver British Columbia Canada V7M 2H4
    406 The Medical Arts Health Research Group Penticton British Columbia Canada V2A 5C8
    407 Winnipeg Clinic Winnipeg Manitoba Canada R3C 0N2
    408 Bramalea Medical Centre Brampton Ontario Canada L6T 4S5
    409 Brampton Research Associates Brampton Ontario Canada L6Z 4N5
    410 Philippe R Beaudry Medicine Professional Corporation Burlington Ontario Canada L7R 4E2
    411 Vizel Cardiac Research Cambridge Ontario Canada N1R7R1
    412 Dr. Linda Sinnaeve's Office Chatham Ontario Canada N7L 1C1
    413 Scisco Clinical Research Cornwall Ontario Canada K6H 4M4
    414 Dr. Peter Spadafora Health Center Guelph Ontario Canada N1E 5G6
    415 John Stimac, MD Hamilton Ontario Canada L8L 5G4
    416 KMH Cardiology & Diagnostics: Hamilton Hamilton Ontario Canada L8P 3A9
    417 Dr. William Liang Hamilton Ontario Canada L8W3J6
    418 Source Unique Clinic Hawkesbury Ontario Canada K6A 1A1
    419 Dr. Ronald Fowlis Kitchener Ontario Canada N2M 5NG
    420 University Hospital London Ontario Canada N6A 5A5
    421 Malton Medical Research Mississauga Ontario Canada L4T 4J2
    422 KMH Cardiology & Diagnostics: Mississauga Mississauga Ontario Canada L5K 2L3
    423 Sewa Ram Singal Medicine Professional Corporation Mississauga Ontario Canada L5U 0A6
    424 Newmarket Cardiology Research Group Newmarket Ontario Canada l3y -8c3
    425 Newmarket Cardiology Research Group Newmarket Ontario Canada L3Y 8C3
    426 Portage Medical Centre Niagara Falls Ontario Canada I2E6A6
    427 Humber River Regional Hospital North York Ontario Canada M3N2V6
    428 Bakbak Medicine Professional Corporation Oshawa Ontario Canada L1H 1B9
    429 Dr. James Y. Cha Oshawa Ontario Canada L1J2K1
    430 University Of Ottawa Heart Institute Ottawa Ontario Canada k1y -4w7
    431 Kawartha Cardiology Clinical Trials Peterborough Ontario Canada K9J0B2
    432 Steeple Hill Medical Centre Pickering Ontario Canada L1V 2A6
    433 Sarnia Institute Of Clinical Research Sarnia Ontario Canada N7T 4X3
    434 Scarborough Cardiology Research Scarborough Ontario Canada M1E5E9
    435 Scarborough General Hospital Cardiology Research Associates Scarborough Ontario Canada M1PT27
    436 Milliken Medical Centre Scarborough Ontario Canada M1V5P6
    437 Canadian Centre for Research on Diabetes Smith Falls Ontario Canada K7A 4W8
    438 Lake Shore Cardiology St. Catharines Ontario Canada L2S 2Y3
    439 Sardar Medical Clinic St. Thomas Ontario Canada N5R 2R4
    440 G.S. Cardiac Lab Medicine Professional Corp Sudbury Ontario Canada P3C 1S8
    441 Dr. R. Labonte Professional Med Corp Sudbury Ontario Canada P3E 3B8
    442 Dr. G. Garrioch, Independent Practice Sudbury Ontario Canada P3E 3C6
    443 Dr. Laurence Gibbs Medicine Professional Corp. Thedford Ontario Canada N0M 2N0
    444 Tillsonburg Medical Centre Tillsonburg Ontario Canada N4G 5A7
    445 Humber River Hospital Toronto Ontario Canada M3M 0B2
    446 Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre Toronto Ontario Canada M4N 3M5
    447 St. Michael's Hospital Toronto Ontario Canada M5B 1W8
    448 Mount Sinai Hospital Toronto Ontario Canada M5G 1X5
    449 Toronto General Hospital Toronto Ontario Canada M5G 2N2
    450 Weston Road Medical Clinic Toronto Ontario Canada M9N 2A7
    451 Dr. Nigel Jagan Medicine Professional Corporation Whitby Ontario Canada L1N 2L1
    452 Dr. Nwadiaro Medicine Professional Corp Windsor Ontario Canada N8X 1L9
    453 Viacar Recherche Clinique Inc. Brossard Quebec Canada J4X1S4
    454 Ecogene-21 Chicoutimi Quebec Canada G7H 7K9
    455 Q&T Research Chicoutimi Chicoutimi Quebec Canada G7H 7Y8
    456 Viacar Recherche Clinique Inc. Greenfield Park Quebec Canada J4V2G8
    457 CHUM Hotel-Dieu Montreal Quebec Canada H2W 1T8
    458 Iucpq Quebec City Quebec Canada G1V 4G5
    459 ALPHA Recherche Clinique Québec Quebec Canada G3K 2P8
    460 CardioVasc HR Saint-Jean-sur-Richelieu Quebec Canada j3a-1c3
    461 ViaCar Recherche Clinique Inc Saint-Lambert Quebec Canada J4P 2H4
    462 Viacar Recherche Clinique St. Lambert Quebec Canada J4P 2J2
    463 Hopital Pierre-Le Gardeur Terrebonne Quebec Canada J6V 2H2
    464 Recherche Clinique Sigma, Inc. Quebec Canada G1G3Z4
    465 Instituto Sanacoop Bayamón Puerto Rico 00961
    466 San Juan Bautista School of Medicine Caguas Puerto Rico 00727
    467 Norma S. Severino-Pacheco, MD Canovanas Puerto Rico 00729
    468 Cardiometabolic Research Center Ponce Puerto Rico 00717
    469 Miguel Sosa-Padilla, MD San Juan Puerto Rico 00926-2832
    470 Yolanda Sierra Quinones, MD Toa Baja Puerto Rico 00949

    Sponsors and Collaborators

    • Brigham and Women's Hospital
    • National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI)

    Investigators

    • Principal Investigator: Paul Ridker, MD, MPH, Brigham and Women's Hospital

    Study Documents (Full-Text)

    More Information

    Publications

    None provided.
    Responsible Party:
    Paul Ridker, Director, Center for Cardiovascular Disease and Prevention, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Brigham and Women's Hospital
    ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier:
    NCT01594333
    Other Study ID Numbers:
    • 2012P-000857
    • U01HL101422
    • U01HL101389
    First Posted:
    May 9, 2012
    Last Update Posted:
    Jul 24, 2020
    Last Verified:
    Jul 1, 2020
    Keywords provided by Paul Ridker, Director, Center for Cardiovascular Disease and Prevention, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Brigham and Women's Hospital
    Additional relevant MeSH terms:

    Study Results

    Participant Flow

    Recruitment Details 9321 subjects were screened and 4786 subjects were randomized starting from April, 2013 through March 2018 in 417 clinical sites in Canada and the United States
    Pre-assignment Detail 9321 subjects were screened, 2987 were found to be ineligible and 176 were discontinued due to premature trial closure prior to entering the open label run-in. 6158 started the run-in. Of those, 1171 were ineligible, 201 were discontinued due to premature trial closure and 4786 subjects were randomly assigned to either Methotrexate or Placebo
    Arm/Group Title Methotrexate Placebo
    Arm/Group Description Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Placebo: Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week
    Period Title: Overall Study
    STARTED 2391 2395
    COMPLETED 2230 2244
    NOT COMPLETED 161 151

    Baseline Characteristics

    Arm/Group Title Methotrexate Placebo Total
    Arm/Group Description Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Placebo: Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Total of all reporting groups
    Overall Participants 2391 2395 4786
    Age (years) [Median (Inter-Quartile Range) ]
    Median (Inter-Quartile Range) [years]
    65.6
    66.0
    65.8
    Sex: Female, Male (Count of Participants)
    Female
    461
    19.3%
    437
    18.2%
    898
    18.8%
    Male
    1930
    80.7%
    1958
    81.8%
    3888
    81.2%
    Race/Ethnicity, Customized (Count of Participants)
    Hispanic/Latino
    206
    8.6%
    177
    7.4%
    383
    8%
    White/Non-hispanic or Latino
    1801
    75.3%
    1837
    76.7%
    3638
    76%
    Asian
    89
    3.7%
    92
    3.8%
    181
    3.8%
    Black or African American
    186
    7.8%
    152
    6.3%
    338
    7.1%
    American Indian or Alaska Native
    6
    0.3%
    6
    0.3%
    12
    0.3%
    Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander
    3
    0.1%
    6
    0.3%
    9
    0.2%
    Multiracial
    13
    0.5%
    7
    0.3%
    20
    0.4%
    Other
    42
    1.8%
    45
    1.9%
    87
    1.8%
    White, Unknown Ethnicity
    45
    1.9%
    73
    3%
    118
    2.5%
    Region of Enrollment (participants) [Number]
    Canada
    407
    17%
    404
    16.9%
    811
    16.9%
    Puerto Rico
    19
    0.8%
    17
    0.7%
    36
    0.8%
    United States
    1965
    82.2%
    1974
    82.4%
    3939
    82.3%
    Smoking status (Count of Participants)
    Current smoker
    267
    11.2%
    270
    11.3%
    537
    11.2%
    Past smoker
    1173
    49.1%
    1215
    50.7%
    2388
    49.9%
    Never smoked cigarettes
    951
    39.8%
    910
    38%
    1861
    38.9%
    Alcohol use (Count of Participants)
    Rarely/Never
    1487
    62.2%
    1473
    61.5%
    2960
    61.8%
    <=1 drink/week
    514
    21.5%
    520
    21.7%
    1034
    21.6%
    >1 drink/week
    390
    16.3%
    402
    16.8%
    792
    16.5%
    Body Mass Index (kilograms per meter squared) [Median (Inter-Quartile Range) ]
    Median (Inter-Quartile Range) [kilograms per meter squared]
    31.6
    31.3
    31.5
    History of diagnosed hypertension (Count of Participants)
    Yes
    2153
    90%
    2169
    90.6%
    4322
    90.3%
    No
    238
    10%
    225
    9.4%
    463
    9.7%
    Qualifying event (Count of Participants)
    Myocardial infarction
    1451
    60.7%
    1458
    60.9%
    2909
    60.8%
    Multivessel coronary disease
    940
    39.3%
    937
    39.1%
    1877
    39.2%
    Qualifying coexisting condition (Count of Participants)
    Diabetes only
    788
    33%
    823
    34.4%
    1611
    33.7%
    Metabolic syndrome only
    771
    32.2%
    780
    32.6%
    1551
    32.4%
    Diabests and metabolic syndrome
    832
    34.8%
    792
    33.1%
    1624
    33.9%
    History of congestive heart failure (Count of Participants)
    Yes
    288
    12%
    332
    13.9%
    620
    13%
    No
    2103
    88%
    2062
    86.1%
    4165
    87%
    History of percutaneous coronary intervention (Count of Participants)
    Yes
    1396
    58.4%
    1420
    59.3%
    2816
    58.8%
    No
    995
    41.6%
    974
    40.7%
    1969
    41.1%
    History of coronary-artery bypass grafting (Count of Participants)
    Yes
    1010
    42.2%
    1032
    43.1%
    2042
    42.7%
    No
    1381
    57.8%
    1362
    56.9%
    2743
    57.3%
    Family history of premature myocardial infarction (Count of Participants)
    Yes
    550
    23%
    536
    22.4%
    1086
    22.7%
    No
    1568
    65.6%
    1580
    66%
    3148
    65.8%
    Family history of premature stroke (Count of Participants)
    Yes
    142
    5.9%
    136
    5.7%
    278
    5.8%
    No
    2002
    83.7%
    2024
    84.5%
    4026
    84.1%
    Use of ACE inhibitor or ARB (Count of Participants)
    Yes
    1736
    72.6%
    1724
    72%
    3460
    72.3%
    No
    655
    27.4%
    671
    28%
    1326
    27.7%
    Use of a statin (Count of Participants)
    Yes
    2058
    86.1%
    2052
    85.7%
    4110
    85.9%
    No
    333
    13.9%
    343
    14.3%
    676
    14.1%
    Use of a beta-blocker (Count of Participants)
    Yes
    1870
    78.2%
    1905
    79.5%
    3775
    78.9%
    No
    521
    21.8%
    490
    20.5%
    1011
    21.1%
    Use of antiplatelet or antithrombotic agent (Count of Participants)
    Yes
    2082
    87.1%
    2054
    85.8%
    4136
    86.4%
    No
    309
    12.9%
    341
    14.2%
    650
    13.6%
    Total cholesterol (mg/dL) [Median (Inter-Quartile Range) ]
    Median (Inter-Quartile Range) [mg/dL]
    141.0
    140.9
    141.0
    Low density lipoprotein cholesterol (mg/dL) [Median (Inter-Quartile Range) ]
    Median (Inter-Quartile Range) [mg/dL]
    68.0
    68.0
    68.0
    High density lipoprotein cholesterol (mg/dL) [Median (Inter-Quartile Range) ]
    Median (Inter-Quartile Range) [mg/dL]
    41.0
    41.0
    41.0
    Triglycerides (mg/dL) [Median (Inter-Quartile Range) ]
    Median (Inter-Quartile Range) [mg/dL]
    135.4
    136.0
    135.4
    High-sensitivity C-reactive protein level (mg/liter) [Median (Inter-Quartile Range) ]
    Median (Inter-Quartile Range) [mg/liter]
    1.53
    1.50
    1.51
    Glycated hemoglobin level (%) [Median (Inter-Quartile Range) ]
    Median (Inter-Quartile Range) [%]
    6.6
    6.5
    6.5

    Outcome Measures

    1. Primary Outcome
    Title Number of Subjects With Major Adverse Cardiovascular Events
    Description The first occurrence of Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event which is defined as the occurrence of one or more of the following: Cardiovascular Death, Non-Fatal Myocardial Infarction or Non-Fatal Stroke.
    Time Frame From randomization to trial end (April 2, 2018) up to a maximum of 5 years

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    All randomized subjects
    Arm/Group Title Methotrexate Placebo
    Arm/Group Description Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Placebo: Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week
    Measure Participants 2391 2395
    Number [participants]
    170
    7.1%
    167
    7%
    Statistical Analysis 1
    Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection Methotrexate, Placebo
    Comments
    Type of Statistical Test Superiority
    Comments
    Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value 0.91
    Comments 2-sided unadjusted p-value
    Method Log Rank
    Comments Stratified according to type of qualifying event, time of qualifying event and risk status(diabetes or metabolic syndrome alone)
    Method of Estimation Estimation Parameter Cox Proportional Hazard
    Estimated Value 1.01
    Confidence Interval (2-Sided) 95%
    0.82 to 1.25
    Parameter Dispersion Type:
    Value:
    Estimation Comments Confidence intervals have not been adjusted for multiplicity, and therefore inferences drawn from these intervals may not be reproducible.
    2. Primary Outcome
    Title Number of Subjects With Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event or Hospitalization for Unstable Angina That Led to Urgent Coronary Revascularization
    Description The first occurrence of Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event or Hospitalization for Unstable Angina that led to Urgent Coronary Revascularization.
    Time Frame From randomization to trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to a maximum of 5 years

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    All randomized participants
    Arm/Group Title Methotrexate Placebo
    Arm/Group Description Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Placebo: Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week
    Measure Participants 2391 2395
    Number [participants]
    201
    8.4%
    207
    8.6%
    Statistical Analysis 1
    Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection Methotrexate, Placebo
    Comments
    Type of Statistical Test Superiority
    Comments
    Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value 0.67
    Comments 2-sided unadjusted p-value
    Method Log Rank
    Comments Stratified according to type of qualifying event, time of qualifying event and risk status(metabolic syndrome alone or diabetes at enrollment).
    Method of Estimation Estimation Parameter Cox Proportional Hazard
    Estimated Value 0.96
    Confidence Interval (2-Sided) 95%
    0.79 to 1.16
    Parameter Dispersion Type:
    Value:
    Estimation Comments Confidence intervals have not been adjusted for multiplicity, and therefore inferences drawn from these intervals may not be reproducible.
    3. Secondary Outcome
    Title Number of Subjects With All-cause Mortality
    Description Subjects who died from any cause.
    Time Frame From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) up to a maximum of 5 years

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    All Randomized Participants
    Arm/Group Title Methotrexate Placebo
    Arm/Group Description Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Placebo: Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week
    Measure Participants 2391 2395
    Number [participants]
    96
    4%
    83
    3.5%
    Statistical Analysis 1
    Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection Methotrexate, Placebo
    Comments
    Type of Statistical Test Superiority
    Comments
    Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value 0.32
    Comments 2-sided unadjusted p-value
    Method Log Rank
    Comments Stratified according to type of qualifying event, time of qualifying event and risk status (metabolic syndrome alone or diabetes at enrollment).
    Method of Estimation Estimation Parameter Cox Proportional Hazard
    Estimated Value 1.16
    Confidence Interval (2-Sided) 95%
    0.87 to 1.56
    Parameter Dispersion Type:
    Value:
    Estimation Comments Confidence intervals have not been adjusted for multiplicity, and therefore inferences drawn from these intervals may not be reproducible.
    4. Secondary Outcome
    Title Number of Subjects With Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event or Any Coronary Revascularization
    Description The first occurrence of Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event or Any Coronary Revascularization.
    Time Frame From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to a maximum of 5 years

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    All randomized participants
    Arm/Group Title Methotrexate Placebo
    Arm/Group Description Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Placebo: Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week
    Measure Participants 2391 2395
    Number [participants]
    278
    11.6%
    288
    12%
    Statistical Analysis 1
    Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection Methotrexate, Placebo
    Comments
    Type of Statistical Test Superiority
    Comments
    Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value 0.57
    Comments 2-sided unadjusted p-value
    Method Log Rank
    Comments Stratified according to type of qualifying event, time of qualifying event and risk status (metabolic syndrome alone or diabetes) at enrollment.
    Method of Estimation Estimation Parameter Cox Proportional Hazard
    Estimated Value 0.95
    Confidence Interval (2-Sided) 95%
    0.81 to 1.12
    Parameter Dispersion Type:
    Value:
    Estimation Comments Confidence intervals have not been adjusted for multiplicity, and therefore inferences drawn from these intervals may not be reproducible.
    5. Secondary Outcome
    Title Number of Subjects With Hospitalization for Congestive Heart Failure
    Description The first occurrence of Hospitalization for Congestive Heart Failure
    Time Frame From randomization to trial end (April 2, 2018) up to a maximum of 5 years

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    All randomized participants
    Arm/Group Title Methotrexate Placebo
    Arm/Group Description Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Placebo: Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week
    Measure Participants 2391 2395
    Number [participants]
    48
    2%
    53
    2.2%
    Statistical Analysis 1
    Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection Methotrexate, Placebo
    Comments
    Type of Statistical Test Superiority
    Comments
    Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value 0.54
    Comments 2-sided unadjusted p-value
    Method Log Rank
    Comments Stratified according to type of qualifying event, type of qualifying event and risk status (diabetes or metabolic syndrome alone) at enrollment
    Method of Estimation Estimation Parameter Cox Proportional Hazard
    Estimated Value 0.89
    Confidence Interval (2-Sided) 95%
    0.60 to 1.31
    Parameter Dispersion Type:
    Value:
    Estimation Comments Confidence intervals have not been adjusted for multiplicity, and therefore inferences drawn from these intervals may not be reproducible.
    6. Secondary Outcome
    Title Number of Subjects With Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event, Coronary Revascularization, Hospitalization for Congestive Heart Failure or All Cause Mortality
    Description The first occurrence of Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event, Coronary Revascularization, Hospitalization for Congestive Heart Failure or All Cause Mortality.
    Time Frame From randomization to trial end (April 2, 2018) up to a maximum of 5 years

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    All randomized participants
    Arm/Group Title Methotrexate Placebo
    Arm/Group Description Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Placebo: Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week
    Measure Participants 2391 2395
    Number [participants]
    344
    14.4%
    345
    14.4%
    Statistical Analysis 1
    Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection Methotrexate, Placebo
    Comments
    Type of Statistical Test Superiority
    Comments
    Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value 0.80
    Comments 2-sided unadjusted p-value
    Method Log Rank
    Comments Stratified according to type of qualifying event, time since qualifying event and risk status (diabetes or metabolic syndrome alone) at enrollment.
    Method of Estimation Estimation Parameter Cox Proportional Hazard
    Estimated Value 0.98
    Confidence Interval (2-Sided) 95%
    0.84 to 1.14
    Parameter Dispersion Type:
    Value:
    Estimation Comments Confidence intervals have not been adjusted for multiplicity, and therefore inferences drawn from these intervals may not be reproducible.
    7. Secondary Outcome
    Title Number of Subjects With New Onset Type 2 Diabetes
    Description New onset type 2 diabetes among those without diabetes at baseline. Baseline diabetes is defined as any of the following prior to randomization: clinician report of diabetes, use of antidiabetic medication, hbA1c >=6.5 or fasting plasma glucose >=126.
    Time Frame From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to 5 years

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    Randomized participants without pre-randomization diabetes
    Arm/Group Title Methotrexate Placebo
    Arm/Group Description Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Placebo: Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week
    Measure Participants 605 620
    Count of Participants [Participants]
    4
    0.2%
    6
    0.3%
    8. Other Pre-specified Outcome
    Title Number of Subjects With Hospitalization for Unstable Angina That Led to Unplanned Coronary Revascularization
    Description The first occurrence of hospitalization for unstable angina that led to unplanned coronary revascularization
    Time Frame From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) up to 5 years

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    All randomized participants
    Arm/Group Title Methotrexate Placebo
    Arm/Group Description Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Placebo: Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week
    Measure Participants 2391 2395
    Number [participants]
    41
    1.7%
    50
    2.1%
    Statistical Analysis 1
    Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection Methotrexate
    Comments
    Type of Statistical Test Superiority
    Comments
    Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value 0.31
    Comments 2-sided unadjusted p-value
    Method Log Rank
    Comments Stratified according to type of qualifying event, time of qualifying event and risk status (diabetes or metabolic syndrome alone) at enrollment.
    Method of Estimation Estimation Parameter Cox Proportional Hazard
    Estimated Value 0.81
    Confidence Interval (2-Sided) 95%
    0.53 to 1.22
    Parameter Dispersion Type:
    Value:
    Estimation Comments Confidence intervals have not been adjusted for multiplicity, and therefore inferences drawn from these intervals may not be reproducible.
    9. Other Pre-specified Outcome
    Title Number of Subjects With Coronary Revascularization
    Description The first occurrence of coronary revascularization
    Time Frame From randomization to trial end (April 2, 2018) up to 5 years

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    All randomized participants
    Arm/Group Title Methotrexate Placebo
    Arm/Group Description Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Placebo: Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week
    Measure Participants 2391 2395
    Number [participants]
    190
    7.9%
    205
    8.6%
    Statistical Analysis 1
    Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection Methotrexate, Placebo
    Comments
    Type of Statistical Test Superiority
    Comments
    Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value 0.38
    Comments 2-sided unadjusted p-value
    Method Log Rank
    Comments Stratified according to type of qualifying event, time of qualifying event and risk status (diabetes or metabolic syndrome alone) at enrollment
    Method of Estimation Estimation Parameter Cox Proportional Hazard
    Estimated Value 0.92
    Confidence Interval (2-Sided) 95%
    0.75 to 1.12
    Parameter Dispersion Type:
    Value:
    Estimation Comments Confidence intervals have not been adjusted for multiplicity, and therefore inferences drawn from these intervals may not be reproducible.
    10. Other Pre-specified Outcome
    Title Number of Subjects With Peripheral Artery Disease
    Description The first occurrence of new or worsening of peripheral artery disease
    Time Frame From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to 5 years

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    [Not Specified]
    Arm/Group Title
    Arm/Group Description
    11. Other Pre-specified Outcome
    Title Number of Subjects With Deep Vein Thrombosis or Pulmonary Embolism
    Description The first occurrence of symptomatic deep vein thrombosis or pulmonary embolism
    Time Frame From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to 5 years

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    The trial was ended prematurely. There were not sufficient outcome measures for analysis
    Arm/Group Title Methotrexate Placebo
    Arm/Group Description Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Placebo: Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week
    Measure Participants 0 0
    12. Other Pre-specified Outcome
    Title Number of Subjects With Aortic Stenosis
    Description The first occurrence of clinically significant aortic stenosis
    Time Frame From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to 5 years

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    The trial ended prematurely. There were not sufficient outcome measures for analysis.
    Arm/Group Title Methotrexate Placebo
    Arm/Group Description Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Placebo: Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week
    Measure Participants 0 0
    13. Other Pre-specified Outcome
    Title Number of Subjects With Atrial Fibrillation
    Description The first occurrence of new or worsening of atrial fibrillation
    Time Frame From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to 5 years

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    [Not Specified]
    Arm/Group Title
    Arm/Group Description

    Adverse Events

    Time Frame From randomization to the trial end (April 2, 2018) - up to 5 years.
    Adverse Event Reporting Description Pre-specified adverse events were collected via questions on the case report forms (CRFs) at each visit. Sites queried participants about any other adverse events and recorded them using a standard adverse event form that included the seriousness, relatedness, severity and outcomes. Those adverse events were MedDRA coded.
    Arm/Group Title Methotrexate Placebo
    Arm/Group Description Methotrexate: Tablet, Oral, Target dose 15-20 mg weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week Placebo: Tablet, Oral, weekly plus 1.0 mg folic acid 6 days/week
    All Cause Mortality
    Methotrexate Placebo
    Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
    Total 96/2391 (4%) 83/2395 (3.5%)
    Serious Adverse Events
    Methotrexate Placebo
    Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
    Total 569/2391 (23.8%) 549/2395 (22.9%)
    Blood and lymphatic system disorders
    Anaemia 7/2391 (0.3%) 9/2395 (0.4%)
    Febrile neutropenia 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Leukopenia 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Leukopenia (AE & Lab Combined) 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Thrombocytopenia 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Thrombocytopenia (AE & Lab Combined) 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Iron deficiency anaemia 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Leukocytosis 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Leukoerythroblastic anaemia 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Lymphadenopathy mediastinal 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Neutropenia 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Neutropenia (AE & Lab Combined) 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Normochromic normocytic anaemia 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Pancytopenia 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    White blood cell disorder 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Cardiac disorders
    Angina unstable 12/2391 (0.5%) 19/2395 (0.8%)
    Angina pectoris 12/2391 (0.5%) 6/2395 (0.3%)
    Bradycardia 5/2391 (0.2%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Ventricular tachycardia 0/2391 (0%) 7/2395 (0.3%)
    Ischaemic cardiomyopathy 1/2391 (0%) 4/2395 (0.2%)
    Cardiac failure congestive 1/2391 (0%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Acute coronary syndrome 2/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Atrial fibrillation 2/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Atrial flutter 2/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Supraventricular tachycardia 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Ventricular extrasystoles 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Ventricular fibrillation 3/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Arrhythmia 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Sick sinus syndrome 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Atrioventricular block complete 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Cardiac arrest 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Cardiac failure 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Cardiogenic shock 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Cardiomegaly 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Cardiomyopathy 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Coronary artery dissection 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Coronary artery occlusion 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Coronary artery stenosis 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Mitral valve disease 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Myocardial infarction 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Palpitations 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Pericardial effusion 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Pneumopericardium 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Sinus tachycardia 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Tachycardia 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Congenital, familial and genetic disorders
    Hydrocele 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Ear and labyrinth disorders
    Vertigo 0/2391 (0%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Tinnitus 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Eye disorders
    Retinal detachment 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Eye pain 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Glaucoma 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Retinal haemorrhage 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Retinal vein occlusion 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Visual impairment 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Gastrointestinal disorders
    Gastrointestinal haemorrhage 8/2391 (0.3%) 10/2395 (0.4%)
    Abdominal pain 9/2391 (0.4%) 6/2395 (0.3%)
    Small intestinal obstruction 5/2391 (0.2%) 6/2395 (0.3%)
    Diarrhoea 4/2391 (0.2%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Pancreatitis acute 2/2391 (0.1%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Intestinal obstruction 3/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Pancreatitis 1/2391 (0%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Rectal haemorrhage 3/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Abdominal pain upper 2/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Colitis 3/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Gastritis 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Ascites 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Constipation 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Diarrhoea haemorrhagic 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Enteritis 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Gastric ulcer 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Gastrooesophageal reflux disease 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Inguinal hernia 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Lower gastrointestinal haemorrhage 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Mouth ulceration 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Nausea 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Retroperitoneal mass 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Stomatitis 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Umbilical hernia 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Vomiting 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Abdominal hernia 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Dyspepsia 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Enterocolitis 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Gastric haemorrhage 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Haemorrhoids 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Hiatus hernia 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Ileus 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Irritable bowel syndrome 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Melaena 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Obstruction gastric 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Oesophageal obstruction 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Oesophagitis 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Oral pain 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Pancreatic mass 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Peptic ulcer 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Tooth socket haemorrhage 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    General disorders
    Chest pain 76/2391 (3.2%) 67/2395 (2.8%)
    Non-cardiac chest pain 8/2391 (0.3%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Chest discomfort 4/2391 (0.2%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Pyrexia 3/2391 (0.1%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Oedema peripheral 0/2391 (0%) 4/2395 (0.2%)
    Asthenia 3/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Systemic inflammatory response syndrome 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Adverse event 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Device malfunction 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Fatigue 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Malaise 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Medical device complication 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Oedema 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Organ failure 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Swelling 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Ulcer haemorrhage 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Hepatobiliary disorders
    Cholecystitis 5/2391 (0.2%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Cholecystitis acute 2/2391 (0.1%) 4/2395 (0.2%)
    Cholelithiasis 3/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Hepatic cirrhosis 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Acute hepatic failure 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Bile duct stone 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Cholangitis 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Hepatic lesion 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Liver disorder 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Pneumobilia 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Immune system disorders
    Hypersensitivity 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Infections and infestations
    Pneumonia 29/2391 (1.2%) 28/2395 (1.2%)
    Cellulitis 19/2391 (0.8%) 15/2395 (0.6%)
    Urinary tract infection 12/2391 (0.5%) 9/2395 (0.4%)
    Sepsis 12/2391 (0.5%) 7/2395 (0.3%)
    Infection 6/2391 (0.3%) 7/2395 (0.3%)
    Diverticulitis 4/2391 (0.2%) 8/2395 (0.3%)
    Bronchitis 7/2391 (0.3%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Osteomyelitis 8/2391 (0.3%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Gastroenteritis 2/2391 (0.1%) 4/2395 (0.2%)
    Influenza 1/2391 (0%) 4/2395 (0.2%)
    Localised infection 4/2391 (0.2%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Pyelonephritis 1/2391 (0%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Septic shock 1/2391 (0%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Upper respiratory tract infection 2/2391 (0.1%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Appendicitis 0/2391 (0%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Bacteraemia 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Gastroenteritis viral 2/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Necrotising fasciitis 0/2391 (0%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Urosepsis 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Abdominal wall abscess 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Abscess limb 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Arthritis bacterial 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Bacterial disease carrier 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Bronchitis viral 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Escherichia bacteraemia 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Groin abscess 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Periorbital cellulitis 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Perirectal abscess 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Sinusitis 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Skin infection 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Staphylococcal infection 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Wound infection staphylococcal 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Abscess 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Anal abscess 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Atypical pneumonia 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Bacterial sepsis 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Cholecystitis infective 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Clostridium difficile colitis 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Device related infection 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Diabetic foot infection 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Enterobacter infection 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Epididymitis 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Escherichia infection 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Gangrene 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Gastroenteritis shigella 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Genital herpes 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Infected skin ulcer 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Labyrinthitis 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Lower respiratory tract infection 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Lyme disease 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Meningitis aseptic 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Osteomyelitis chronic 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Perineal abscess 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Pharyngitis 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Pneumonia bacterial 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Respiratory syncytial virus infection 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Respiratory tract infection 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Sialoadenitis 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Staphylococcal bacteraemia 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Tinea pedis 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Urinary Tract Infection 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Viral infection 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Viral upper respiratory tract infection 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Wound infection 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Injury, poisoning and procedural complications
    Fall 3/2391 (0.1%) 5/2395 (0.2%)
    Hip fracture 4/2391 (0.2%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Rib fracture 2/2391 (0.1%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Road traffic accident 2/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Subdural haematoma 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Upper limb fracture 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Femur fracture 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Lower limb fracture 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Abdominal injury 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Accidental overdose 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Alcohol poisoning 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Ankle fracture 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Clavicle fracture 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Concussion 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Contusion 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Facial bones fracture 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Femoral neck fracture 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Fibula fracture 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Head injury 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Meniscus injury 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Muscle strain 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Pelvic fracture 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Spinal cord injury 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Tendon rupture 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Testicular injury 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Thermal burn 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Thoracic vertebral fracture 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Toxicity to various agents 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Traumatic arthropathy 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Vascular pseudoaneurysm 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Wound 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Wound dehiscence 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Investigations
    Blood glucose increased 2/2391 (0.1%) 5/2395 (0.2%)
    Catheterisation cardiac 6/2391 (0.3%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Arteriogram coronary 3/2391 (0.1%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Liver function test abnormal 2/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    White blood cell count decreased 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Biopsy bladder 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Stress echocardiogram abnormal 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Alanine aminotransferase increased 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Aspiration pleural cavity 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Biopsy breast 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Biopsy liver 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Biopsy lung 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Blood creatinine increased 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Blood glucose decreased 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Blood pressure increased 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Blood triglycerides increased 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Blood urine present 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Bronchoscopy 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Cardiac stress test abnormal 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Cystoscopy 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Haemoglobin increased 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Hepatic enzyme increased 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Hepatitis C virus test positive 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Lipase increased 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Platelet count decreased 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Prostatic specific antigen increased 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Red blood cell count decreased 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Shift to the right 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Transaminases increased 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Troponin increased 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Weight decreased 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Weight increased 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    White blood cell count increased 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Metabolism and nutrition disorders
    Dehydration 2/2391 (0.1%) 7/2395 (0.3%)
    Hypoglycaemia 4/2391 (0.2%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Hyperglycaemia 2/2391 (0.1%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Diabetic ketoacidosis 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Hypercalcaemia 3/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Hyperkalaemia 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Hyponatraemia 0/2391 (0%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Diabetes mellitus inadequate control 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Hypokalaemia 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Obesity 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Electrolyte imbalance 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Hypomagnesaemia 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Hypovolaemia 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders
    Musculoskeletal chest pain 2/2391 (0.1%) 5/2395 (0.2%)
    Arthralgia 3/2391 (0.1%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Back pain 3/2391 (0.1%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Flank pain 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Pain in extremity 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Rhabdomyolysis 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Rheumatoid arthritis 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Spinal osteoarthritis 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Ankylosing spondylitis 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Cervical spinal stenosis 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Compartment syndrome 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Intervertebral disc protrusion 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Lumbar spinal stenosis 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Musculoskeletal pain 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Neck mass 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Osteitis 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Osteitis deformans 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Osteoarthritis 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Pain in jaw 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Soft tissue mass 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Neoplasms benign, malignant and unspecified (incl cysts and polyps)
    Prostate cancer 7/2391 (0.3%) 13/2395 (0.5%)
    Squamous cell carcinoma 7/2391 (0.3%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Basal cell carcinoma 5/2391 (0.2%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Breast cancer 3/2391 (0.1%) 4/2395 (0.2%)
    Malignant melanoma 2/2391 (0.1%) 5/2395 (0.2%)
    Skin cancer 5/2391 (0.2%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Squamous cell carcinoma of skin 3/2391 (0.1%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Lung neoplasm malignant 2/2391 (0.1%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Bladder cancer 2/2391 (0.1%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Colon cancer 2/2391 (0.1%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Renal cell carcinoma 0/2391 (0%) 4/2395 (0.2%)
    Meningioma 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Pancreatic carcinoma 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Bladder neoplasm 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Leiomyosarcoma 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Neoplasm malignant 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Prostate cancer recurrent 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Renal cancer 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Acute lymphocytic leukaemia 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Acute myeloid leukaemia 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Adenocarcinoma Of The Prostate 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Adenocarcinoma of colon 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Basal & Squamous Cell Carcinoma's Discovered 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Bladder transitional cell carcinoma 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Brain Cancer 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Brain neoplasm 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Branchogenic Adenocarcinoma/Right Upper Lobectomy And M 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Cholangiocarcinoma 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Clear cell renal cell carcinoma 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Cytopathology Diagnosis Of Aus/Flus Or Follicular Hurth 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Diagnosed With Non Basal Cell Malignancy 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Diagnosis Of Bladder Cancer, Highly Invasive, With Live 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Diffuse large B-cell lymphoma 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Endometrial cancer 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Essential thrombocythaemia 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Gastric cancer 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Hodgkin's disease 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Invasive Squamous Cell Carcinoma (Right Cheek) 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Laryngeal cancer 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Left Descending Colon Cancer 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Left Ureteropelvic Junction, Papillary Urothelial Carci 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Lesion, Mid-Parietal Scalp, Squamous Cell Carcinoma 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Liver Cancer 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Lung adenocarcinoma 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Lung carcinoma cell type unspecified stage IV 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Lymphoma 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Malignant Bladder Polyps 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Malignant Spindle Cell Neoplasm 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Malignant Transitional Cell Cancer Of The Bladder 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Metastases to central nervous system 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Metastatic Liver Cancer 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Micrometastatic Disease Melanoma 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    New Lung Cancer Diagnosis 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Oesophageal adenocarcinoma 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Papillary Urothelial Carcinoma 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Parathyroid tumour benign 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Peritoneal Carcinomatosis From A Low-Grade Mucinous Tum 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Plasma cell myeloma 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Pt Newly Diagnosed With Stage 4 Cancer 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Recurrent Bladder Tumor 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Recurrent Bladder Tumor: Papillary Lesion , Proximal An 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Relapsed Non-Hodgkins Lymphoma 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Reported Diagnosis Lymphoma On Passive Follow Up 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Right Parietal Craniotomy For Benign Neoplasm Of Brain 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Ruptured Mucinous Neoplasm Of The Appendix With Periton 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Skin Biopsy- Possible Lymphoma 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Small cell lung cancer 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Sqamous Cell Carcinoma In Situ, Bowenoid Type 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Stage Ii Adenocarcinoma Of The Ascending Colon 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Stage Iv T2n0m1 Adenocarcinoma Of Theh Ead And Tail Of 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    T-cell lymphoma 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Throat cancer 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Treatment For Metastasized Clear Cell Renal Cell Carcin 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Uterine cancer 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Any Cancer 52/2391 (2.2%) 30/2395 (1.3%)
    Any Cancer 106/2391 (4.4%) 95/2395 (4%)
    Non-basal-cell skin cancer (not known if SAE) 31/2391 (1.3%) 10/2395 (0.4%)
    Non-basal-cell skin cancer (not known if SAE) 33/2391 (1.4%) 12/2395 (0.5%)
    Nervous system disorders
    Syncope 24/2391 (1%) 16/2395 (0.7%)
    Transient ischaemic attack 9/2391 (0.4%) 9/2395 (0.4%)
    Dizziness 6/2391 (0.3%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Presyncope 4/2391 (0.2%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Convulsion 2/2391 (0.1%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Headache 3/2391 (0.1%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Dysarthria 2/2391 (0.1%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Dementia 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Encephalopathy 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Hemiparesis 2/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Migraine 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    VIIth nerve paralysis 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Aphasia 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Ataxia 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Carotid artery stenosis 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Clonus 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Dyskinesia 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Epilepsy 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Facial paresis 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Haemorrhage intracranial 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Hypertensive encephalopathy 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Lethargy 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Loss of consciousness 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Metabolic encephalopathy 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Myoclonus 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Neuromyopathy 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Paraesthesia 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Paresis 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Parkinson's disease 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Radicular pain 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Radiculopathy 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Subarachnoid haemorrhage 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Transient global amnesia 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Psychiatric disorders
    Mental status changes 1/2391 (0%) 4/2395 (0.2%)
    Confusional state 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Depression 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Alcohol withdrawal syndrome 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Delirium 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Disorientation 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Suicidal ideation 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Renal and urinary disorders
    Renal failure acute 17/2391 (0.7%) 21/2395 (0.9%)
    Haematuria 4/2391 (0.2%) 4/2395 (0.2%)
    Nephrolithiasis 2/2391 (0.1%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Renal failure 3/2391 (0.1%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Renal failure chronic 3/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Renal mass 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Urinary retention 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Calculus ureteric 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Bladder mass 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Dysuria 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Polyuria 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Proteinuria 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Urethral stenosis 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Reproductive system and breast disorders
    Benign prostatic hyperplasia 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Breast mass 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Female genital tract fistula 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Postmenopausal haemorrhage 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Prostatitis 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Prostatomegaly 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Vaginal haemorrhage 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Respiratory, thoracic and mediastinal disorders
    Dyspnoea 13/2391 (0.5%) 12/2395 (0.5%)
    Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease 9/2391 (0.4%) 9/2395 (0.4%)
    Acute respiratory failure 7/2391 (0.3%) 4/2395 (0.2%)
    Pleural effusion 4/2391 (0.2%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Epistaxis 4/2391 (0.2%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Pulmonary mass 2/2391 (0.1%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Respiratory failure 2/2391 (0.1%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Asthma 2/2391 (0.1%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Haemoptysis 2/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Hypoxia 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Interstitial lung disease 2/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Cough 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Dyspnoea exertional 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Pneumonia aspiration 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Pneumothorax 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Pulmonary fibrosis 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Acute pulmonary oedema 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Acute respiratory distress syndrome 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Choking 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Emphysema 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Haemothorax 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Nasal polyps 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Pneumomediastinum 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Pneumonitis 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Pneumothorax spontaneous 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Pulmonary embolism 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Pulmonary oedema 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Skin and subcutaneous tissue disorders
    Rash 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Diabetic foot 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Skin lesion 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Skin ulcer 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Actinic keratosis 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Alopecia 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Angioedema 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Cutaneous lupus erythematosus 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Dermatitis 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Diabetic ulcer 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Surgical and medical procedures
    Knee arthroplasty 10/2391 (0.4%) 11/2395 (0.5%)
    Hospitalisation 4/2391 (0.2%) 6/2395 (0.3%)
    Hip arthroplasty 6/2391 (0.3%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Surgery 2/2391 (0.1%) 7/2395 (0.3%)
    Spinal laminectomy 3/2391 (0.1%) 4/2395 (0.2%)
    Gastrectomy 3/2391 (0.1%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Implantable defibrillator insertion 3/2391 (0.1%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Cardiac pacemaker insertion 4/2391 (0.2%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Hip surgery 2/2391 (0.1%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Knee operation 3/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Toe amputation 2/2391 (0.1%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Cardiac ablation 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Carotid endarterectomy 1/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Gallbladder operation 2/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Joint arthroplasty 2/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Shoulder arthroplasty 2/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Aortic valve replacement 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Cardioversion 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Colectomy 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Gastric bypass 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Intervertebral disc operation 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Mitral valve repair 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Nephrectomy 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Penile prosthesis insertion 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Shoulder operation 2/2391 (0.1%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Stent placement 0/2391 (0%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Tooth extraction 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Abdominal hernia repair 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Ankle operation 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Aortic aneurysm repair 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Appendicectomy 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Bladder neoplasm surgery 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Cancer surgery 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Cardiac pacemaker battery replacement 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Cataract operation 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Central venous catheterisation 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Cholecystectomy 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Craniotomy 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Finger amputation 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Fistula repair 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Foot amputation 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Hernia repair 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Implantable defibrillator replacement 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Intestinal resection 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Lung lobectomy 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Mastectomy 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Oesophagectomy 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Oesophagogastric fundoplasty 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Partial lung resection 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Pelvic floor repair 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Prolapse repair 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Prostatectomy 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Radical cystectomy 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Radiotherapy 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Removal of internal fixation 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Retinopexy 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Small intestinal resection 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Spinal cord operation 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Spinal fusion surgery 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Thyroidectomy 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Umbilical hernia repair 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Urinary cystectomy 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Vascular disorders
    Hypotension 8/2391 (0.3%) 3/2395 (0.1%)
    Hypertension 2/2391 (0.1%) 2/2395 (0.1%)
    Orthostatic hypotension 4/2391 (0.2%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Aneurysm 2/2391 (0.1%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Aortic stenosis 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Hypertensive crisis 1/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Accelerated hypertension 0/2391 (0%) 1/2395 (0%)
    Aortic aneurysm 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Peripheral artery aneurysm 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Temporal arteritis 1/2391 (0%) 0/2395 (0%)
    Other (Not Including Serious) Adverse Events
    Methotrexate Placebo
    Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
    Total 1488/2391 (62.2%) 1399/2395 (58.4%)
    Blood and lymphatic system disorders
    Any 340/2391 (14.2%) 244/2395 (10.2%)
    Leukopenia 241/2391 (10.1%) 172/2395 (7.2%)
    Gastrointestinal disorders
    Any 350/2391 (14.6%) 284/2395 (11.9%)
    General disorders
    Any 279/2391 (11.7%) 254/2395 (10.6%)
    Chest pain 126/2391 (5.3%) 142/2395 (5.9%)
    Infections and infestations
    Any 659/2391 (27.6%) 584/2395 (24.4%)
    Injury, poisoning and procedural complications
    Any 150/2391 (6.3%) 163/2395 (6.8%)
    Investigations
    Any 220/2391 (9.2%) 211/2395 (8.8%)
    Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders
    Any 223/2391 (9.3%) 230/2395 (9.6%)
    Neoplasms benign, malignant and unspecified (incl cysts and polyps)
    Any 124/2391 (5.2%) 101/2395 (4.2%)
    Nervous system disorders
    Any 213/2391 (8.9%) 195/2395 (8.1%)
    Respiratory, thoracic and mediastinal disorders
    Any 279/2391 (11.7%) 210/2395 (8.8%)
    Skin and subcutaneous tissue disorders
    Any 97/2391 (4.1%) 121/2395 (5.1%)
    Surgical and medical procedures
    Any 137/2391 (5.7%) 147/2395 (6.1%)

    Limitations/Caveats

    The trial was terminated early because the pre-specified boundary for futility was crossed for both the original and the final primary endpoints and because of the lack of evidence of a reduction in hsCRP level with methotrexate treatment.

    More Information

    Certain Agreements

    All Principal Investigators ARE employed by the organization sponsoring the study.

    There is NOT an agreement between Principal Investigators and the Sponsor (or its agents) that restricts the PI's rights to discuss or publish trial results after the trial is completed.

    Results Point of Contact

    Name/Title Dr. Paul Ridker and Dr. Robert Glynn
    Organization Brigham & Women's Hospital
    Phone 617-732-4965
    Email pridker@bwh.harvard.edu
    Responsible Party:
    Paul Ridker, Director, Center for Cardiovascular Disease and Prevention, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Brigham and Women's Hospital
    ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier:
    NCT01594333
    Other Study ID Numbers:
    • 2012P-000857
    • U01HL101422
    • U01HL101389
    First Posted:
    May 9, 2012
    Last Update Posted:
    Jul 24, 2020
    Last Verified:
    Jul 1, 2020