MD-VR-THA: VR Simulation and Basic Skills in THA
Study Details
Study Description
Brief Summary
This prospective randomised clinical trial aims to test if virtual reality (VR) simulation helps acquire basic surgical skills in total hip arthroplasty (THA) by medical students.
The main question[s] it aims to answer are:
-
Can VR simulation develop the medical students' basic surgical skills and medical knowledge in THA?
-
Will VR simulation become a part of orthopaedic surgical education?
Participants will be randomised into two groups (VR and control).
-
They will be asked to watch a very detailed video explaining basic rules and skills in implanting the acetabular cup and femoral stem in THA
-
The VR group will perform at least three VR THA sessions concerning cup (inclination) and stem (version) implantation
-
Then all participants will be asked to implant a cup and a stem in a predefined inclination and version, respectively, in sawbones
-
The mean difference between the predefined and the actual implanted cup inclination and version of the stem will be compared between groups
| Condition or Disease | Intervention/Treatment | Phase |
|---|---|---|
|
N/A |
Detailed Description
This study is a prospective randomized controlled trial and received approval from the A.U.Th. Institutional Review Board.
Eligible study participants include undergraduate medical students at our university.
Exclusion criteria include a. postgraduate medical students b. prior experience in THA or general surgery.
One week before the planned VR-THA surgery session, all eligible A.U.Th. Medical students will be invited to an information session regarding the study and will be voluntarily enrolled, providing inform consent.
Medical students were explicitly chosen for participation because they are surgically naïve and would most likely benefit from basic skills training in THA.
Immediately after enrollment, medical students will be asked to complete a multiple-choice pretest to quantify their baseline medical and procedural knowledge of hip arthritis and THA. All participants will be unaware and unable to prepare for the pretest assessment, which allows the test scores to be considered an accurate measure of baseline knowledge.
The medical students will be asked to watch a detailed video explaining basic rules and skills for implanting the acetabular cup and femoral stem in THA. The video will be focused on practices and methods to achieve specific cup inclination and stem version during implantation.
All participants will be randomized to the VR simulation or control group for cup inclination assessment by a computerized random number generator. Participants will be privately notified of their randomization by e-mail and asked not to disclose their designated cohort with any other study participant or research personnel. Only a research team member will be aware of the cohort assignments during this study. The participants enrolled on the VR group for cup inclination will be the control group for the stem version group and vice versa.
Before the VR-THA, participants will be asked to complete a survey evaluating their previous video games and VR technology experience.
All control group participants will then be asked to implant a cup or a stem in a predefined inclination and version in sawbones. The cup inclination and stem version will be evaluated using specific goniometers and assessment of photographs taken during implantation. The evaluation will be performed by study personnel unaware of the participants' group assignment.
All VR group participants will then be asked to complete three consecutive VR sessions using the VR system (ORama VR, Geneva, Switzerland), performing cup or stem implantation based on their group. All VR group participants will then be asked to implant a cup or a stem in a predefined inclination and version in sawbones. The cup inclination and stem version will be evaluated using the same specific goniometers and assessment of photographs that will be taken during implantation. The evaluation will be performed by the same study personnel unaware of the participants' group assignment. This personnel will also record the time needed for implantation.
During implantation in sawbones, a study assistant will be present who will be instructed to intervene only if the study participants request assistance or cannot progress through the task.
Upon completion of the VR-THAs, participants will complete a survey focused on their interest in using VR simulations for surgical skills training and assessing for potential negative consequences. Power analysis was performed, indicating that more than 30 participants will be necessarily enrolled in each group.
The primary outcome will be the mean difference between the asked predefined and the actual implanted cup inclination or cup version between the control and VR groups.
The secondary outcomes will be
-
the percentage difference of the target approach between the asked and the actual implanted cup inclination or cup version for each participant performing implantation (one task will be performed as the VR and the other as the control group).
-
Differences in completing the task between groups will also be recorded ( time needed to complete the task and asking for assistance).
Two weeks later, all participants will perform the implantation on sawbones once again.
Study Design
Arms and Interventions
| Arm | Intervention/Treatment |
|---|---|
| Other: Control Group This group will include medical students who will only watch instructional videos on basic THA skills on the cup and stem implantation before actual implantation on sawbones |
Procedure: VR simulation on basic THA skills
The medical students' VR group will perform three VR simulation sessions on basic THA skills on the cup and stem implantation before actual implantation.
|
| Other: VR Group This group will include medical students who will watch instructional videos and perform three consecutive VR sessions on basic THA skills on the cup and stem implantation before actual implantation on sawbones |
Procedure: VR simulation on basic THA skills
The medical students' VR group will perform three VR simulation sessions on basic THA skills on the cup and stem implantation before actual implantation.
|
Outcome Measures
Primary Outcome Measures
- Medical students surgical skills differences between VR and control group. [2 Months]
The primary outcome will be the mean difference between the asked predefined and the actual implanted cup inclination or cup version between the control and VR groups.
Secondary Outcome Measures
- Surgical skills differences between cup and stem implantation for each medical student (the one implantation will be performed following VR training and the other not) [2 months]
The secondary outcome will be the percentage difference of the target approach between the asked and the actual implanted cup inclination or cup version for each participant performing implantation. Differences in completing the task between groups will also be recorded ( time needed to complete the task and asking for assistance).
Eligibility Criteria
Criteria
Inclusion criteria:
- undergraduate medical students at Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
Exclusion criteria:
-
postgraduate medical students
-
prior experience in THA or general surgery.
Contacts and Locations
Locations
| Site | City | State | Country | Postal Code | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Aristotle University Medical School | Thessaloniki | Greece |
Sponsors and Collaborators
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki
Investigators
- Principal Investigator: Eleftherios Tsiridis, Professor, Aristotle University Medical School
Study Documents (Full-Text)
None provided.More Information
Publications
- 79/2023