Ultrasound Guided Pain Control Versus Standard Treatment in Emergency Department HIP Fracture Patients

Sponsor
Antonios Likourezos (Other)
Overall Status
Completed
CT.gov ID
NCT01904071
Collaborator
Emergency Medicine Foundation (Other)
64
1
3
22
2.9

Study Details

Study Description

Brief Summary

Hip Fracture (HFx) is a painful injury that is often treated in the Emergency Department (ED) with intravenous opiates. However, this class of medications may cause deleterious side effects. An alternative analgesic approach involves regional anesthesia. The investigators attempted to determine (1) whether ultrasound guided peripheral nerve blocks (UPNBs) could be safely performed in an ED setting, (2) whether UPNBs would be more effective than standard treatment in controlling pain from HFx and (3) which of two UPNBs was superior for pain relief.

A convenience sample of patients with an isolated HFx and a pain score > 5/10 were enrolled and randomized to one of three arms: (1) Ultrasound guided 3-in-1 femoral nerve block (UFNB), (2) Ultrasound guided fascia iliaca compartment block (UFIB), or (3) IVMS. Patients indicated their pain from 0 (no pain) to 10 (extreme pain).

Condition or Disease Intervention/Treatment Phase
  • Procedure: UFNB (Ultrasound guided femoral nerve block)
  • Procedure: UFIB (Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block)
  • Drug: IVMS (IV Morphine)
Phase 4

Detailed Description

Hip fracture (HFx) is a painful orthopedic emergency that commonly presents to the Emergency Department (ED). There are approximately 320,000 HFx diagnosed annually in the United States, with this number expected to increase as the population ages. It has previously been shown that patients with pain from HFx are undermedicated while in the ED, particularly in overcrowded facilities. Current treatment for ED patients who are experiencing pain from acute HFx is often with intravenous morphine sulfate (IVMS). Morphine can have many undesirable side effects, but of particular concern are delirium, hypotension and respiratory depression. These complications may be accentuated in elderly patients and may necessitate increased patient monitoring and greater utilization of limited ED resources.An alternative to systemic opioid analgesia involves peripheral nerve blockade. Anesthesiologists frequently perform nerve blocks in the peri-operative and post-operative period to control pain in patients undergoing hip surgery. Traditionally, nerve stimulators were used to place the nerve block. However, ultrasonography is being used with increasing frequency to facilitate placement of these peripheral nerve blocks. As Emergency Physicians (EP) become more facile with the use of bedside sonography, ultrasound guided peripheral nerve blockade for HFx may be ideally suited for the ED environment, where one injection could control pain for many hours. The 3-in-1 femoral nerve block (FNB), in which anesthetic is injected adjacent to the femoral nerve but also affects the lateral femoral cutaneous and the obturator nerves, has been shown to be as effective as morphine for pain control of HFx in the ED. Sonographic guidance has been shown to increase the success rate of this block, decrease the time to analgesia, decrease the amount of local anesthetic needed to achieve adequate regional anesthesia, and decrease the incidence of inadvertent intravascular injection.

To date, there has been limited research describing the utilization of ultrasound guided femoral nerve blocks in an ED setting. Beaudoin et al. performed a feasibility study demonstrating that EP could effectively perform ultrasound guided femoral nerve blocks. Reid et al. found a significantly decreased time to complete analgesia when using sonographic guidance compared to an anatomic landmark technique. In this later study, anesthesia was assessed by checking skin sensation. Neither of these studies utilized a 3-in-1 nerve block, which may provide greater pain relief for patients with HFx.

The fascia iliaca compartment block (FIB) is also effective for treating pain due to HFx. It has been shown in the pediatric anesthesia and pediatric emergency medicine literature that it provides adequate analgesia, and may provide more effective analgesia than the FNB for femur fractures in children. Most of the studies describe the FIB being performed using a technique based on anatomic landmarks. One recent study described ultrasound guidance of the FIB (UFIB) increasing the efficacy of the sensory blockade (12). UFIB has not previously been studied in the ED setting.

We attempted to determine (1) whether ultrasound guided peripheral nerve blocks (UPNB) could be safely performed in an ED setting, (2) whether UPNB would be more effective than standard treatment in controlling pain from HFx in which a 2.5 unit decrease in pain scores was considered clinically significant, and (3) which of two UPNB was superior for pain relief.

Study Design

Study Type:
Interventional
Actual Enrollment :
64 participants
Allocation:
Randomized
Intervention Model:
Parallel Assignment
Masking:
None (Open Label)
Primary Purpose:
Treatment
Official Title:
Ultrasound Guided Femoral (3 in 1) Nerve Block Versus Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliacus Compartment Block Versus Standard Treatment for Pain Control in Patients With Hip Fractures in the Emergency Department
Study Start Date :
Oct 1, 2008
Actual Primary Completion Date :
Aug 1, 2010
Actual Study Completion Date :
Aug 1, 2010

Arms and Interventions

Arm Intervention/Treatment
Experimental: UFNB

Ultrasound guided 3 in 1 femoral nerve block: The UFNB was performed by first visualizing the femoral nerve in a transverse orientation just inferior to the inguinal ligament and lateral to the common femoral artery.

Procedure: UFNB (Ultrasound guided femoral nerve block)
Ultrasound Guided Femoral Nerve Block

Experimental: UFIB

Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block: For the UFIB, the two fascial planes, the fascia lata and the fascia iliaca, were sonographically visualized with the probe transverse to the thigh just inferior to the inguinal ligament and one-third of the distance from the anterior superior iliac spine to the pubic tubercle.

Procedure: UFIB (Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block)

Active Comparator: IVMS

IV Morphine: IV Morphine patients were also monitored for a minimum of one hour after they were given a second dose of IV morphine, 0.1 mg/kg, once the radiographs demonstrated fracture. The control group was also eligible to receive rescue analgesia of an additional 0.1 mg/kg of IV morphine, followed by repeat doses of 0.05 mg/kg

Drug: IVMS (IV Morphine)
Intravenous Morphine

Outcome Measures

Primary Outcome Measures

  1. Pain Score at 30 Minutes [30 minutes]

    Pain Score at 30 minutes post-administration of pain control treatment. Pain Scale: Scores range from 0 (no pain) to 10 (sever pain). A score of 5 is moderate pain

Secondary Outcome Measures

  1. Pain Score at 60 Minutes [60 minutes]

    Pain score at 60 minutes post-administration of pain control treatment. Pain Scale: Scores range from 0 (no pain) to 10 (sever pain). A score of 5 is moderate pain

Other Outcome Measures

  1. Pain Score at 120 Minutes [120 minutes]

    Pain score at 120 minutes post-administration of pain control treatment. Pain Scale: Scores range from 0 (no pain) to 10 (sever pain). A score of 5 is moderate pain

  2. Pain Score at 240 Minutes [240 minutes]

    Pain Score at 240 minutes post administration of pain control treatment. Pain Scale: Scores range from 0 (no pain) to 10 (sever pain). A score of 5 is moderate pain

  3. Pain Score at 480 Minutes [480 minutes]

    Pain score at 480 minutes post administration of pain control treatment. Pain Scale: Scores range from 0 (no pain) to 10 (sever pain). A score of 5 is moderate pain

Eligibility Criteria

Criteria

Ages Eligible for Study:
18 Years and Older
Sexes Eligible for Study:
All
Accepts Healthy Volunteers:
No
Inclusion Criteria:
  1. English speaking patients

  2. ≥18 years of age

  3. radiographic evidence of hip fracture

  4. Patients must be awake, alert and oriented to time, place and person.

  5. pain score of ≥ 5 in 10 point scale.

Exclusion Criteria:
  1. cognitive deficits

  2. allergic to amide-type local anesthetic or morphine

  3. more injuries than just hip fracture.

Contacts and Locations

Locations

Site City State Country Postal Code
1 Maimonides Medical Center Brooklyn New York United States 11219

Sponsors and Collaborators

  • Antonios Likourezos
  • Emergency Medicine Foundation

Investigators

  • Principal Investigator: Eitan Dickman, MD, Maimonides Medical Center

Study Documents (Full-Text)

None provided.

More Information

Publications

Responsible Party:
Antonios Likourezos, Research Manager, Maimonides Medical Center
ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier:
NCT01904071
Other Study ID Numbers:
  • 08/09/VA09
First Posted:
Jul 22, 2013
Last Update Posted:
Jun 6, 2018
Last Verified:
May 1, 2014
Keywords provided by Antonios Likourezos, Research Manager, Maimonides Medical Center
Additional relevant MeSH terms:

Study Results

Participant Flow

Recruitment Details
Pre-assignment Detail
Arm/Group Title UFNB UFIB IVMS
Arm/Group Description Ultrasound guided 3 in 1 femoral nerve block: The UFNB was performed by first visualizing the femoral nerve in a transverse orientation just inferior to the inguinal ligament and lateral to the common femoral artery. UFNB (Ultrasound guided femoral nerve block) Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block: For the UFIB, the two fascial planes, the fascia lata and the fascia iliaca, were sonographically visualized with the probe transverse to the thigh just inferior to the inguinal ligament and one-third of the distance from the anterior superior iliac spine to the pubic tubercle. UFIB (Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block) IV Morphine: IV Morphine patients were also monitored for a minimum of one hour after they were given a second dose of IV morphine, 0.1 mg/kg, once the radiographs demonstrated fracture. The control group was also eligible to receive rescue analgesia of an additional 0.1 mg/kg of IV morphine, followed by repeat doses of 0.05 mg/kg IVMS (IV Morphine)
Period Title: Overall Study
STARTED 24 20 20
COMPLETED 24 20 20
NOT COMPLETED 0 0 0

Baseline Characteristics

Arm/Group Title UFNB UFIB IVMS Total
Arm/Group Description Ultrasound guided 3 in 1 femoral nerve block: The UFNB was performed by first visualizing the femoral nerve in a transverse orientation just inferior to the inguinal ligament and lateral to the common femoral artery. UFNB (Ultrasound guided femoral nerve block) Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block: For the UFIB, the two fascial planes, the fascia lata and the fascia iliaca, were sonographically visualized with the probe transverse to the thigh just inferior to the inguinal ligament and one-third of the distance from the anterior superior iliac spine to the pubic tubercle. UFIB (Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block) IV Morphine: IV Morphine patients were also monitored for a minimum of one hour after they were given a second dose of IV morphine, 0.1 mg/kg, once the radiographs demonstrated fracture. The control group was also eligible to receive rescue analgesia of an additional 0.1 mg/kg of IV morphine, followed by repeat doses of 0.05 mg/kg IVMS (IV Morphine) Total of all reporting groups
Overall Participants 24 20 20 64
Age (years) [Mean (Standard Deviation) ]
Mean (Standard Deviation) [years]
82
(9.96)
82
(7.74)
85
(7.91)
83
(8.64)
Sex: Female, Male (Count of Participants)
Female
17
70.8%
11
55%
13
65%
41
64.1%
Male
7
29.2%
9
45%
7
35%
23
35.9%
Region of Enrollment (participants) [Number]
United States
24
100%
20
100%
20
100%
64
100%
Pain Score at Triage (units on a scale) [Mean (Standard Deviation) ]
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
5.17
(3.29)
5.50
(3.99)
6.98
(1.87)
5.84
(3.23)

Outcome Measures

1. Primary Outcome
Title Pain Score at 30 Minutes
Description Pain Score at 30 minutes post-administration of pain control treatment. Pain Scale: Scores range from 0 (no pain) to 10 (sever pain). A score of 5 is moderate pain
Time Frame 30 minutes

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title UFNB UFIB IVMS
Arm/Group Description Ultrasound guided 3 in 1 femoral nerve block: The UFNB was performed by first visualizing the femoral nerve in a transverse orientation just inferior to the inguinal ligament and lateral to the common femoral artery. UFNB (Ultrasound guided femoral nerve block) Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block: For the UFIB, the two fascial planes, the fascia lata and the fascia iliaca, were sonographically visualized with the probe transverse to the thigh just inferior to the inguinal ligament and one-third of the distance from the anterior superior iliac spine to the pubic tubercle. UFIB (Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block) IV Morphine: IV Morphine patients were also monitored for a minimum of one hour after they were given a second dose of IV morphine, 0.1 mg/kg, once the radiographs demonstrated fracture. The control group was also eligible to receive rescue analgesia of an additional 0.1 mg/kg of IV morphine, followed by repeat doses of 0.05 mg/kg IVMS (IV Morphine)
Measure Participants 24 20 20
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
1.94
(2.43)
2.05
(2.61)
5.13
(2.70)
Statistical Analysis 1
Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection UFNB, UFIB, IVMS
Comments
Type of Statistical Test Superiority or Other
Comments
Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value <.0001
Comments
Method ANOVA
Comments
2. Secondary Outcome
Title Pain Score at 60 Minutes
Description Pain score at 60 minutes post-administration of pain control treatment. Pain Scale: Scores range from 0 (no pain) to 10 (sever pain). A score of 5 is moderate pain
Time Frame 60 minutes

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title UFNB UFIB IVMS
Arm/Group Description Ultrasound guided 3 in 1 femoral nerve block: The UFNB was performed by first visualizing the femoral nerve in a transverse orientation just inferior to the inguinal ligament and lateral to the common femoral artery. UFNB (Ultrasound guided femoral nerve block) Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block: For the UFIB, the two fascial planes, the fascia lata and the fascia iliaca, were sonographically visualized with the probe transverse to the thigh just inferior to the inguinal ligament and one-third of the distance from the anterior superior iliac spine to the pubic tubercle. UFIB (Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block) IV Morphine: IV Morphine patients were also monitored for a minimum of one hour after they were given a second dose of IV morphine, 0.1 mg/kg, once the radiographs demonstrated fracture. The control group was also eligible to receive rescue analgesia of an additional 0.1 mg/kg of IV morphine, followed by repeat doses of 0.05 mg/kg IVMS (IV Morphine)
Measure Participants 24 20 20
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
2.58
(3.06)
1.90
(2.38)
4.40
(2.92)
Statistical Analysis 1
Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection UFNB, UFIB, IVMS
Comments
Type of Statistical Test Superiority or Other
Comments
Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value <.05
Comments
Method ANOVA
Comments
3. Other Pre-specified Outcome
Title Pain Score at 120 Minutes
Description Pain score at 120 minutes post-administration of pain control treatment. Pain Scale: Scores range from 0 (no pain) to 10 (sever pain). A score of 5 is moderate pain
Time Frame 120 minutes

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Pain score was not obtained for one patient in the IVMS group at 120 minutes.
Arm/Group Title UFNB UFIB IVMS
Arm/Group Description Ultrasound guided 3 in 1 femoral nerve block: The UFNB was performed by first visualizing the femoral nerve in a transverse orientation just inferior to the inguinal ligament and lateral to the common femoral artery. UFNB (Ultrasound guided femoral nerve block) Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block: For the UFIB, the two fascial planes, the fascia lata and the fascia iliaca, were sonographically visualized with the probe transverse to the thigh just inferior to the inguinal ligament and one-third of the distance from the anterior superior iliac spine to the pubic tubercle. UFIB (Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block) IV Morphine: IV Morphine patients were also monitored for a minimum of one hour after they were given a second dose of IV morphine, 0.1 mg/kg, once the radiographs demonstrated fracture. The control group was also eligible to receive rescue analgesia of an additional 0.1 mg/kg of IV morphine, followed by repeat doses of 0.05 mg/kg IVMS (IV Morphine)
Measure Participants 24 20 19
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
2.65
(2.49)
1.30
(1.89)
4.00
(2.98)
Statistical Analysis 1
Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection UFNB, UFIB, IVMS
Comments
Type of Statistical Test Superiority or Other
Comments
Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value <.005
Comments
Method ANOVA
Comments
4. Other Pre-specified Outcome
Title Pain Score at 240 Minutes
Description Pain Score at 240 minutes post administration of pain control treatment. Pain Scale: Scores range from 0 (no pain) to 10 (sever pain). A score of 5 is moderate pain
Time Frame 240 minutes

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Pain score was not obtained for one patient in the UFNB group at 240 minutes
Arm/Group Title UFNB UFIB IVMS
Arm/Group Description Ultrasound guided 3 in 1 femoral nerve block: The UFNB was performed by first visualizing the femoral nerve in a transverse orientation just inferior to the inguinal ligament and lateral to the common femoral artery. UFNB (Ultrasound guided femoral nerve block) Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block: For the UFIB, the two fascial planes, the fascia lata and the fascia iliaca, were sonographically visualized with the probe transverse to the thigh just inferior to the inguinal ligament and one-third of the distance from the anterior superior iliac spine to the pubic tubercle. UFIB (Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block) IV Morphine: IV Morphine patients were also monitored for a minimum of one hour after they were given a second dose of IV morphine, 0.1 mg/kg, once the radiographs demonstrated fracture. The control group was also eligible to receive rescue analgesia of an additional 0.1 mg/kg of IV morphine, followed by repeat doses of 0.05 mg/kg IVMS (IV Morphine)
Measure Participants 23 20 20
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
3.15
(2.70)
1.72
(1.98)
4.83
(2.58)
Statistical Analysis 1
Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection UFNB, UFIB, IVMS
Comments
Type of Statistical Test Superiority or Other
Comments
Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value <.001
Comments
Method ANOVA
Comments
5. Other Pre-specified Outcome
Title Pain Score at 480 Minutes
Description Pain score at 480 minutes post administration of pain control treatment. Pain Scale: Scores range from 0 (no pain) to 10 (sever pain). A score of 5 is moderate pain
Time Frame 480 minutes

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Pain scores were not obtained for 4 patients in the UFNB group, 3 patients in the UFIB group, and 3 patients in the IVMS group at 480 minutes
Arm/Group Title UFNB UFIB IVMS
Arm/Group Description Ultrasound guided 3 in 1 femoral nerve block: The UFNB was performed by first visualizing the femoral nerve in a transverse orientation just inferior to the inguinal ligament and lateral to the common femoral artery. UFNB (Ultrasound guided femoral nerve block) Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block: For the UFIB, the two fascial planes, the fascia lata and the fascia iliaca, were sonographically visualized with the probe transverse to the thigh just inferior to the inguinal ligament and one-third of the distance from the anterior superior iliac spine to the pubic tubercle. UFIB (Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block) IV Morphine: IV Morphine patients were also monitored for a minimum of one hour after they were given a second dose of IV morphine, 0.1 mg/kg, once the radiographs demonstrated fracture. The control group was also eligible to receive rescue analgesia of an additional 0.1 mg/kg of IV morphine, followed by repeat doses of 0.05 mg/kg IVMS (IV Morphine)
Measure Participants 20 17 17
Mean (Standard Deviation) [units on a scale]
3.20
(2.28)
2.35
(3.07)
3.74
(2.89)
Statistical Analysis 1
Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection UFNB, UFIB, IVMS
Comments
Type of Statistical Test Superiority or Other
Comments
Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value 0.342
Comments
Method ANOVA
Comments

Adverse Events

Time Frame 240 minutes
Adverse Event Reporting Description
Arm/Group Title UFNB UFIB IVMS
Arm/Group Description Ultrasound guided 3 in 1 femoral nerve block: The UFNB was performed by first visualizing the femoral nerve in a transverse orientation just inferior to the inguinal ligament and lateral to the common femoral artery. UFNB (Ultrasound guided femoral nerve block) Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block: For the UFIB, the two fascial planes, the fascia lata and the fascia iliaca, were sonographically visualized with the probe transverse to the thigh just inferior to the inguinal ligament and one-third of the distance from the anterior superior iliac spine to the pubic tubercle. UFIB (Ultrasound Guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block) IV Morphine: IV Morphine patients were also monitored for a minimum of one hour after they were given a second dose of IV morphine, 0.1 mg/kg, once the radiographs demonstrated fracture. The control group was also eligible to receive rescue analgesia of an additional 0.1 mg/kg of IV morphine, followed by repeat doses of 0.05 mg/kg IVMS (IV Morphine)
All Cause Mortality
UFNB UFIB IVMS
Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
Total / (NaN) / (NaN) / (NaN)
Serious Adverse Events
UFNB UFIB IVMS
Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
Total 0/24 (0%) 0/20 (0%) 0/20 (0%)
Other (Not Including Serious) Adverse Events
UFNB UFIB IVMS
Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
Total 0/24 (0%) 0/20 (0%) 0/20 (0%)

Limitations/Caveats

[Not Specified]

More Information

Certain Agreements

All Principal Investigators ARE employed by the organization sponsoring the study.

There is NOT an agreement between Principal Investigators and the Sponsor (or its agents) that restricts the PI's rights to discuss or publish trial results after the trial is completed.

Results Point of Contact

Name/Title Dr. Eitan Dickman, Director of EM Ultrasound
Organization Maimonides Medical Center
Phone 718-283-6057
Email edickman@maimonidesmed.org
Responsible Party:
Antonios Likourezos, Research Manager, Maimonides Medical Center
ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier:
NCT01904071
Other Study ID Numbers:
  • 08/09/VA09
First Posted:
Jul 22, 2013
Last Update Posted:
Jun 6, 2018
Last Verified:
May 1, 2014