Searching for Masses and Calcifications at the Same Time in Breast Cancer Screening
Study Details
Study Description
Brief Summary
Brief Summary
A task like breast cancer screening (mammography) can be described as a "hybrid search" task. In basic visual search tasks, observers search for a target among distractors that are not the target. In hybrid search, observers search for two or more target types. In mammography, observers are searching for masses, calcifications ("calcs"), and some other signs of cancer like architectural distortion. In this experiment, the investigators have created a simulated version of mammography where non-expert (non-radiologist) observers can look for simulated masses and calcs. There are two types of stimuli, a 2D version (like an x-ray) and a 3D version (like the output of Digital Breast Tomosynthesis - DBT). The question that is being asked is whether it is better to ask about masses and calcs separately (first one, then the other) or to just let observers look for both at the same time.
| Condition or Disease | Intervention/Treatment | Phase |
|---|---|---|
|
N/A |
Detailed Description
Brief Summary
A task like breast cancer screening (mammography) can be described as a "hybrid search" task. In basic visual search tasks, observers search for a target among distractors that are not the target. In hybrid search, observers search for two or more target types. In mammography, observers are searching for masses, calcifications ("calcs"), and some other signs of cancer like architectural distortion. In this experiment, the investigators have created a simulated version of mammography where non-expert (non-radiologist) observers can look for simulated masses and calcs. There are two types of stimuli, a 2D version (like an x-ray) and a 3D version (like the output of Digital Breast Tomosynthesis - DBT). The question that is being asked is whether it is better to ask about masses and calcs separately (first one, then the other) or to just let observers look for both at the same time.
Extended protocol
NOTE: This registration is linked to a Human Subjects registration in ASSIST. That, in turn, is part of an NCI Grant, CA207490. The grant describes many proposed experiments and notes that many others might be done as follow-up studies. At the suggestion of the NIH, the investigators grouped these studies into three "studies", each covering multiple experiments. The experiment described here is part of "Study ID 386409 Projects 1,2,3: Experiments with Non experts". It is not possible to register a set of experiments through the PRS system in CT.gov and it is not possible to file an annual report for the grant (RPPR) without an NCT number for projects that have started collecting participants. Accordingly, the investigators are describing one experiment here that would be part of the "Project 2" bundle of studies.
These experiments take what is known about "hybrid search" tasks from the lab and applies it to clinical mammography. Hybrid search tasks are tasks that involve looking for more than one type of target at the same time (e.g. search for this pillow and any animal in the scene in front of you).
Standard 2D mammography and 3D DBT can be thought of as hybrid search tasks. That is, mammography can be thought of as a hybrid search for masses and calcifications. What is the optimal way to do this task? Should readers look for both types of targets at the same time or should they be asked to look for one target type and then the other. It is likely that the sequential approach improves accuracy but at some cost in time. The investigators will test that hypothesis of a "speed/accuracy tradeoff".
The investigators have developed a version of the 2D mammography task that can be run on non-experts. Breast parenchyma is simulated with 1/fk noise (k=1.8 - 2.8). Artificial masses and calcifications (calcs) can be added to this background. Masses are relatively low contrast blobs that are deemed to be "bad" if they have many irregular bumps and benign if they are smoother. Calcs are brighter, higher contrast, small spots. These are deemed to be benign unless they form a cluster of nearby spots in the image. The task is designed to be hard. The goal is performance producing a d' value in the range of 2.0 to 2.5. Bad and benign stimuli are selected from uniformly distributed stimuli sets. For masses, when the target is 'bad', bad mass is randomly selected from 5 levels of bumpiness. The same rule is applied for selecting benign stimuli from five less-bumpy levels. For calcifications, the number of pixels in a cluster is randomly selected between 4~12.
There are four conditions to be tested in the first experiment:
-
Search for masses alone
-
Search for calcs alone
-
Search for both together
-
Search for one after the other (mass -> calc) or (calc -> mass)
In addition, there are two different ways of presenting the four conditions. These could be considered to be two arms of the study. Either participants could see each condition in a block of 100 trials or the four conditions could be mixed into one set of 400 trials (with breaks every 100 trials to keep the pacing of the experiment consistent.
In the initial experiment, target prevalence will be 60%. In future experiments, lower prevalence will be tested. The measures of interest are accuracy and RT and the most interesting question is whether the sequential condition produces any benefits that might be worth the presumed cost in time.
The 3D version is like the 2D version except that a volume of 1/fk noise is created and masses and calcs are added so that they fade in and out of view as the observer scrolls through "slices" through the 3D volume. This simulates DBT.
Study Design
Arms and Interventions
| Arm | Intervention/Treatment |
|---|---|
| Experimental: Blocked Trials There are four conditions in the experiment. Each condition will be presented in a separate block of 100 trials. |
Behavioral: Search only for masses
Participants search the simulated mammogram for simulated masses.
Behavioral: Search only for calcifications
Participants search the simulated mammogram for simulated calcifications.
Behavioral: Search for both together
Search the simulated mammogram for both simulated masses and simulated calcifications at the same time.
Behavioral: Search for one after the other
Search the simulated mammogram for first for simulated masses and then for simulated calcifications sequentially (or vice versa).
|
| Experimental: Mixed Trials There are four conditions in the experiment. All condition will be presented, randomly mixed in a single block of 400 trials (with breaks every 100 trials). |
Behavioral: Search only for masses
Participants search the simulated mammogram for simulated masses.
Behavioral: Search only for calcifications
Participants search the simulated mammogram for simulated calcifications.
Behavioral: Search for both together
Search the simulated mammogram for both simulated masses and simulated calcifications at the same time.
Behavioral: Search for one after the other
Search the simulated mammogram for first for simulated masses and then for simulated calcifications sequentially (or vice versa).
|
Outcome Measures
Primary Outcome Measures
- Time required to respond to a case [Through study completion, an average of 1 year]
The measure of response time is an index of the difficulty of each case.
- Rates of false positive and false negative errors [through study completion, an average of 1 year]
Cases are either positive or negative for simulated cancer. Responses are either correct or incorrect in identifying if the case is positive or negative. Hence each response is either a true or false positive and or a true or false negative response. The relative percentages of these errors provides a measure of accuracy.
Eligibility Criteria
Criteria
Inclusion Criteria:
-
Age over 18 yrs
-
Pass Ishihara color vision test
Exclusion Criteria:
-
vision less than 20/25 with correction
-
history of neuromuscular or visual disorders
Contacts and Locations
Locations
| Site | City | State | Country | Postal Code | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Brigham and Women's Hospital | Boston | Massachusetts | United States | 02215 |
Sponsors and Collaborators
- Brigham and Women's Hospital
Investigators
- Principal Investigator: Jeremy M Wolfe, PhD, Brigham and Women's Hospital
Study Documents (Full-Text)
None provided.More Information
Publications
None provided.- 2007P000646-E