MELODY: To Compare Conservative Management Vs. Balloon Kyphoplasty in the Treatment of VCFs in Patients With Multiple Myeloma

Sponsor

Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital NHS Trust (Other)

Overall Status

Terminated

CT.gov ID

NCT02732925

Collaborator

(none)

Enrollment

Location

Arms

9.6

Actual Duration (Months)

0.2

Patients Per Site Per Month

Study Details

Study Description

Brief Summary

The purpose of this study is to determine whether surgical treatment, balloon kyphoplasty is more effective compared to conservative treatment alone (sham procedure) when assessing clinical, translational, radiological & patient outcomes in patients with multiple myeloma.

Subjects will be recruited to the study if they have VAS score ≥ 6 and has given informed consent to participate in the Melody Study will be randomised to Arm 1 Sham Procedure and Conservative treatment or Arm 2 Balloon Kyphoplasty and Conservative treatment. Subjects recruited to Arm 1 (Sham Procedure and Conservative treatment) can cross over into Arm 2 (Balloon Kyphoplasty and Conservative Treatment) if they have a VAS score ≥ 6 between 8-12 weeks.

Condition or Disease	Intervention/Treatment	Phase
Multiple Myeloma	Device: Arm 2 Balloon Kyphoplasty Procedure: Conservative Management	N/A

Detailed Description

Multiple myeloma (MM) accounts for 10% of the malignant haematological diseases and approximately 1% of all cancer-related deaths in Western countries. MM is characterised by the accumulation of malignant plasma cells in the bone marrow leading to impaired haematopoiesis and the highest incidence of bone involvement among the malignant diseases. MM bone disease is the result of increased destruction of bone that cannot be compensated for by new bone formation. Approximately 80% of patients with MM develop skeletal complications including bone pain, hypercalcemia, osteoporosis, osteolytic lesions and pathologic fractures. Vertebral fractures may be associated with spinal cord compression and neurological complications requiring surgery and/or radiotherapy. Osteolytic bone destruction is the most debilitating manifestation of MM, has a severe impact on patients' quality of life and is responsible for increased morbidity and mortality. Furthermore, bone resorption activity has been shown to be an independent risk factor for overall survival in patients with symptomatic MM. Moreover, myeloma-associated lytic bone lesions do not repair, even in patients who are disease free for years.

More than 50% of patients develop vertebral compression fractures (VCFs) either by the time of diagnosis or during the course of the diagnosed disease. These fractures can compromise the spinal cord and patients' height and stature, cause angulation of the spine, increasing sternum pressure, eventually resulting in sternal fractures and compromising the pulmonary capacity. 9% loss in predicted forced vital capacity is associated with each vertebral fracture. Deformity, Insomnia, depression, substantial physical, functional and psychological impairment and ultimately disability can be the result of severe vertebral compression fractures poorly managed at presentation.

Management of spinal MM bone disease

Bisphosphonates he use of bisphosphonates, which inhibit bone reabsorption, for the treatment of MM bone disease has led to an improvement in the quality of life for patients with MM.
Conservative (non-surgical) management (this is standard of care management for patients with multiple myeloma)
Pain relief
Systemic chemotherapy for Myeloma disease
Bed rest
Radiotherapy
Physiotherapy
Standard surgical procedures

Open surgical decompression Anterior or posterior decompression and stabilisation through internal fixation hardware and bone grafting (in <0.5% with gross spinal deformity or neurologic impairment). Higher morbidity and mortality in MM patients because of comorbid conditions related to age, disease associated end-organ damage and immunosuppression B. Minimally invasive - Cement Augmentation

Percutaneous Vertebroplasty
Percutaneous Kyphoplasty (i.e. Balloon Kyphoplasty)

COST BURDEN, HEALTH ECONOMIC IMPACT AND COST UTILITY ANALYSIS There is little evidence on differences across health systems in choice and outcome of multiple myeloma being treated with conservative treatment, chemotherapy and spinal surgery are three of many treatment options for managing multiple myeloma. The true cost associated with current therapies in addition to supportive care, is significant and poses a tremendous financial burden to both patient and health care providers.

There is therefore a need to begin to systematically optimise the guidance for treatment for this subgroup of patients especially when comparing the two treatment arms in this study, conservative treatment alone versus surgical treatment, balloon kyphoplasty.

This study will determine the cost burden, health economic impact and cost utility analysis by combining the quality of life measurements, the cost analysis will allow a calculation of the relative cost-effectiveness of conservative treatment standard of care versus standard of care plus balloon kyphoplasty.17

RATIONALE FOR CURRENT STUDY

Osteolytic lesions of vertebral bodies are frequent problems in multiple myeloma patients predisposing to severe pain, vertebral fractures and consequent neurological complications.Open surgical procedures to stabilise or correct deformed vertebral bodies are associated with major complications in this group of immunocompromised patients. In addition, open procedures are often not possible, due to a severely impaired strength of the bone tissue, which does not allow the safe application of screws and plates. As a result the standard management to reduce the local pain secondary to vertebral compression fracture has for many years been with pain relief, radiotherapy and the other elements of conservative management listed above. The development of minimally invasive procedures such as kyphoplasty and vertebroplasty has been demonstrated to be an additional effective treatment option to improve mobility and quality of life and to reduce pain.

Percutaneous vertebroplasty involves the injection of acrylic bone cement into the vertebral body in order to relieve pain and/or stabilise the fractured vertebrae and in some cases, restore vertebral height.

Percutaneous Kyphoplasty (or Balloon Kyphoplasty) is performed by inserting a balloon-like device (inflatable bone tamp) through a channel created by a hand drill in the fractured vertebrae. The tamp is positioned and inserted into the vertebral body. The balloon is then inflated slowly until normal height of the vertebral body is restored or the balloon reaches its maximum volume. The procedure is intended to restore vertebral height and correct kyphosis. It may also help to improve pulmonary and gastrointestinal function and reduce the likelihood of subsequent vertebral compression fractures. The inflation of the balloon tamp creates a cavity in the vertebral body so that when the bone tamp is withdrawn, bone cement can be injected into the cavity at a lower pressure, potentially reducing the risk of cement leakage. The cement increases the strength of the vertebra and is intended to provide pain relief.

Study Design

Study Type:

Interventional

Actual Enrollment :

2 participants

Allocation:

Randomized

Intervention Model:

Crossover Assignment

Masking:

Single (Participant)

Primary Purpose:

Treatment

Official Title:

Multiple Myeloma Spinal Disease Study; A Multi-centre, Prospective, Single Blinded, Randomized, Controlled Study to Compare Conservative Management Alone Vs. Balloon Kyphoplasty With the Treatment of VCFs in Patients With Multiple Myeloma

Actual Study Start Date :

Jun 9, 2017

Actual Primary Completion Date :

Mar 28, 2018

Actual Study Completion Date :

Mar 28, 2018

Arms and Interventions

Arm	Intervention/Treatment
Sham Comparator: Arm 1 - Sham Procedure Sham Procedure & Conservative Treatment Subjects will be blinded and randomised to Arm 1 and will undergo a general anaesthetic and undergo a sham procedure. They will also be treated under conservative management alone. Below is a list of the conservative management they will be managed by their Doctor: Bisphosphonates Pain relief Systemic chemotherapy for Myeloma disease Bed rest Radiotherapy Physiotherapy This is a non interventional as conservative treatment (standard of care for multiple myeloma patients) is used.	Procedure: Conservative Management Patients recruited to Arm 1 and Arm 2 will undergo conservative management for Multiple Myeloma recommended by their Consultant Hematologist. Concomitant treatment with bisphosphonates Pain relief as required Systemic chemotherapy for Myeloma disease Bed rest Radiotherapy Physiotherapy
Active Comparator: Arm 2 - Balloon Kyphoplasty Balloon Kyphoplasty & Conservative Treatment - Interventional Arm Subjects will be blinded and randomised to Arm 2 (balloon kyphoplasty) and will undergo a general anaesthetic and undergo a balloon kyphoplasty surgical procedure. They will also be treated with conservative management. Below is a list of the conservative management they will be managed by their Doctor: Bisphosphonates Pain relief Systemic chemotherapy for Myeloma disease Bed rest Radiotherapy Physiotherapy This is a interventional arm (balloon kyphoplasty procedure) and the patient will receive conservative treatment (standard of multiple myeloma patients) is used.	Device: Arm 2 Balloon Kyphoplasty Arm 2 Balloon Kyphoplasty (Medtronic LCC) and Conservative Treatment Subjects will be blinded and randomised to Arm 2 and will undergo a general anaesthetic and undergo a balloon kyphoplasty surgical procedure. They will also be treated with conservative management. Below is a list of the conservative management they will be managed by their Doctor: Bisphosphonates Pain relief Systemic chemotherapy for Myeloma disease Bed rest Radiotherapy Physiotherapy Procedure: Conservative Management Patients recruited to Arm 1 and Arm 2 will undergo conservative management for Multiple Myeloma recommended by their Consultant Hematologist. Concomitant treatment with bisphosphonates Pain relief as required Systemic chemotherapy for Myeloma disease Bed rest Radiotherapy Physiotherapy

Arm

Intervention/Treatment

Sham Comparator: Arm 1 - Sham Procedure

Sham Procedure & Conservative Treatment Subjects will be blinded and randomised to Arm 1 and will undergo a general anaesthetic and undergo a sham procedure. They will also be treated under conservative management alone. Below is a list of the conservative management they will be managed by their Doctor: Bisphosphonates Pain relief Systemic chemotherapy for Myeloma disease Bed rest Radiotherapy Physiotherapy This is a non interventional as conservative treatment (standard of care for multiple myeloma patients) is used.

Procedure: Conservative Management

Patients recruited to Arm 1 and Arm 2 will undergo conservative management for Multiple Myeloma recommended by their Consultant Hematologist. Concomitant treatment with bisphosphonates Pain relief as required Systemic chemotherapy for Myeloma disease Bed rest Radiotherapy Physiotherapy

Active Comparator: Arm 2 - Balloon Kyphoplasty

Balloon Kyphoplasty & Conservative Treatment - Interventional Arm Subjects will be blinded and randomised to Arm 2 (balloon kyphoplasty) and will undergo a general anaesthetic and undergo a balloon kyphoplasty surgical procedure. They will also be treated with conservative management. Below is a list of the conservative management they will be managed by their Doctor: Bisphosphonates Pain relief Systemic chemotherapy for Myeloma disease Bed rest Radiotherapy Physiotherapy This is a interventional arm (balloon kyphoplasty procedure) and the patient will receive conservative treatment (standard of multiple myeloma patients) is used.

Device: Arm 2 Balloon Kyphoplasty

Arm 2 Balloon Kyphoplasty (Medtronic LCC) and Conservative Treatment Subjects will be blinded and randomised to Arm 2 and will undergo a general anaesthetic and undergo a balloon kyphoplasty surgical procedure. They will also be treated with conservative management. Below is a list of the conservative management they will be managed by their Doctor: Bisphosphonates Pain relief Systemic chemotherapy for Myeloma disease Bed rest Radiotherapy Physiotherapy

Procedure: Conservative Management

Outcome Measures

Primary Outcome Measures

the effect of sham procedure & conservative management alone (arm 1) versus balloon kyphoplasty (arm 2) on patient reported pain scores as assessed by VAS (at week 4) [At week 4]

Secondary Outcome Measures

the effect of conservative management alone versus balloon kyphoplasty on patient reported pain scores as assessed by VAS (at weeks 1, 8, 12, 16, 26, year 1 and year 2) [At week 1, 8, 12, 26, year 1 and year 2]
the pain relief requirements of conservative management alone versus balloon kyphoplasty using a daily pain diary (capturing usage of pain relief by type) [At week 1, 8, 12, 26, year 1 and year 2]
the effect of conservative management alone versus balloon kyphoplasty on patient reported Quality Of Life outcomes [At week 1, 8, 12, 26, year 1 and year 2]
procedure related complications of conservative management alone versus balloon kyphoplasty [At week 1, 8, 12, 26, year 1 and year 2]
recording of any adverse events
the cost utility of the conservative management alone versus the balloon kyphoplasty [at 2 years]
Data collected for all intervention groups from the study will be assessed to compare the overall cost of care for conservative management vs. kyphoplasty

Eligibility Criteria

Criteria

Ages Eligible for Study:

18 Years to 80 Years

Sexes Eligible for Study:

All

Accepts Healthy Volunteers:

Inclusion Criteria:

Age ≥ 18 and ≤80 years old
Diagnosis of Multiple Myeloma
Confirmed acute (MRI, a detectable low signal T1 ± oedema) painful vertebral compression fracture(s) VAS score is ≥6
The patient is able to read and understand the Patient Information Sheet and study procedures
The patient is able and willing to give written informed consent

Exclusion Criteria:

Contraindications to anaesthesia
Cord Compression or large epidural mass necessitating conservative management before balloon kyphoplasty
Pain unrelated to vertebral collapse
Infection at the site
Presence of overt instability as judged by the principle investigator
Known pregnancy at time of screening
Severe Cardiopulmonary insufficiency
Osteoblastic lesions
Any co-morbidity, (e.g., diabetes, heart condition, obesity, psychiatric illness) which, in the opinion of the investigator, is of a severe enough nature to; interfere with the patient's ability to complete the study assessments; or present an unacceptable risk to the patient's safety to undergo study treatment