MeaTIc: Meat-based Versus Pesco-vegetarian Diet and Colorectal Cancer

Sponsor

Azienda Ospedaliero-Universitaria Careggi (Other)

Overall Status

Completed

CT.gov ID

NCT03416777

Collaborator

(none)

103

Enrollment

Location

Arms

Actual Duration (Months)

4.5

Patients Per Site Per Month

Study Details

Study Description

Brief Summary

Colorectal cancer (CRC) is strongly affected by diet, with red and processed meat increasing risk. To understand the role of microbiome in this phenomenon and to identify specific microbiome/metabolomics profiles associated with CRC risk, will be studied: 1) healthy volunteers fed for 3 months with: a high-CRC risk diet (meat-based MBD), a normalized CRC risk diet (MBD plus alpha-tocopherol, MBD-T), a low-CRC risk diet (pesco-vegetarian, PVD). At the beginning and at the end of the intervention, gut microbiome profiles (metagenomics and metabolomics), and CRC biomarkers (genotoxicity, cytotoxicity, peroxidation in faecal water; lipid/glycemic indexes, inflammatory cytokines, oxidative stress), 2) Colon carcinogenesis: the same diets will be fed (3 months) to carcinogen-induced rats or to Pirc rats, mutated in Apc, the key gene in CRC; faecal microbiome profiles, will be correlated to carcinogenesis measuring preneoplastic lesions, colon tumours, and faecal and blood CRC biomarkers as in humans; 3) To further elucidate the mechanisms underlying the effect of different microbiomes in determining CRC risk, faeces from rats fed the experimental diets will be transplanted into carcinogen-induced germ-free rats, measuring how microbiome changes correlate with metabolome and disease outcomes. The results will provide fundamental insight in the role of microbiome in determining the effect of the diet, in particular red/processed meat intake, on CRC risk

Condition or Disease	Intervention/Treatment	Phase
Nutrition Aspect of Cancer Diet Modification Cancer of Colon	Behavioral: Meat-based diet Dietary Supplement: Meat-based diet supplemented with alpha-tocopherol (MBD-T) Behavioral: Pesco-vegetarian diet	N/A

Detailed Description

Colorectal cancer (CRC) is the second leading cause of cancer death in Europe. The geographical variation of incidence demonstrates how environmental factors, chiefly dietary habits, play a major role in this disease. Convincing evidence suggests that risk of CRC is increased by red meat and processed meat consumption (classified, as regard cancer hazard as 2A and 1, respectively, WHO) and decreased by foods containing dietary fibers. As regarding other food groups, like fish, although epidemiological studies suggest a reduction of CRC risk associated with its consumption, the evidence for this link is considered limited; similarly, for non-starchy vegetables and fruits, although there is suggestive evidence of a protective effect, this is considered limited, and thus less convincing than that for red and processed meat.

Several hypotheses are proposed to explain the positive association between red, processed meat and CRC: meat-based diets contain mutagens-carcinogens formed during cooking, but also lipid peroxidation and N-nitroso compounds whose formation is catalyzed by heme in the colon. Accordingly, recent experimental and epidemiological studies on the E3N cohort and on the randomized placebo-controlled trial SUVIMAX carried out by our group, demonstrated the central role of heme iron in the positive association between meat and CRC. According to these studies, this effect is largely explained by the ability of heme iron to catalyze peroxidation and induce high luminal polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) peroxidation, forming cytotoxic and genotoxic alkenals which will in turn induce positive selection of precancerous cells mutated for Apc, the key gene in CRC. On this basis, it was also demonstrated that antioxidants, in particular tocopherol, modulate the risk of cancer associated with red meat in experimental animals and humans by controlling heme iron-induced peroxidation. Recent data from the investigators demonstrated that microbiota is involved in the heme-induced peroxidation and it has been reported that the gut microbiota is required for heme-induced epithelial hyperproliferation and hyperplasia because of the capacity to reduce mucus barrier function. Notwithstanding these reports, the role of gut microbiome in determining cancer risk associated with red and processed meat is not clear.

Microbial fermentation of plant-based foods, associated with a low CRC risk increases intestinal Short Chain Fatty Acids (SCFAs), among which butyrate, endowed with antineoplastic activity through its inhibition of histone deacetylase and promotion of apoptosis and microbial activated phytochemicals, such as polyphenols with anti-inflammatory and antioxidant activities. Accordingly, it is also known that the process of fermenting fibers to SCFAs needs intestinal bacteria because germ-free mice produce almost no SCFAs. These data clearly indicate that, at least part of the effect of the diet on colon carcinogenesis is mediated by the intestinal microbiome. Accordingly, it is well know that diet shapes gut microbiome composition, as described in a human rural population study and emerging evidences implicate an involvement of the gut microbiota in CRC. Microorganisms and their metabolites have been proposed to promote carcinogenesis by several mechanisms, including induction of inflammatory signaling pathways, genetic mutations, and epigenetic dysregulation. Recently, a review conducted on 31 studies (human and animal models) has shown that certain bacterial groups are increased (eg. Fusobacterium spp, Alistipes, Staphylococcaceae, Akkermansia spp. and Methanobacteriales), while others (eg. Bifidobacterium, Lactobacillus, Faecalibacterium spp) are consistently diminished in CRC, with consequent increase of potentially carcinogenic metabolites (nitrogen compounds, bile acids) and decrease of SCFAs (eg. butyrate). However, it is still not clear whether dysbiosis (imbalanced microbiota) is the cause or consequence of CRC. Tumorigenesis can indeed produce inflammation, ulceration and necrosis of the mucosa, by changing the microenvironment and growth conditions for different microorganisms, thus it is difficult to understand what comes first. And furthermore, how dietary risk is mediated by the interaction with the gut microbiome? How can the modulation of the microbiome promote or prevent the development of a microenvironment containing pro-inflammatory and carcinogenic metabolites that favour the neoplastic initiation process? Cohort studies with subjects consuming various types of diets (i.e omnivores, vegetarians, vegans) suggest that diet alters the intestinal microbiome as well as the cytotoxic and genotoxic activities of the luminal colonic content. In a study on ten volunteers following for 5 days a strictly vegetarian diet and then moving to a strictly carnivorous diet, it was demonstrated that the intestinal bacteria react very quickly (24-48 hours). In particular, bacterial species capable of digesting complex carbohydrates prevailed during the vegetarian diet period while during the animal proteins based diet, specific bacterial species were selected, such as Bilophila wadsworthia, which are able to metabolize proteins and produce toxic compounds like secondary bile acids (BA, promoters of carcinogenesis) and with great pro-inflammatory potential. Feeding a high-fibre low-fat African-style diet to African Americans at high risk of colon cancer and, vice versa, feeding a high-fat, low-fiber western style diet to rural Africans at low risk of cancer, causes variation in microbiome and in parameters associated with CRC risk. Preliminary data in humans also demonstrate that when an animal-based diet rich in fat and simple sugars is introduced into a traditional African diet, composed of cereals, legumes and vegetables, the gut microbiome shifts, leading to progressive loss of biochemical functions associated with SCFAs production, suggesting indeed that faecal microbiome may act as determinant of colon cancer risk related to the diet. Regarding heme iron, the investigators recently demonstrated that after a short term exposure (14 days), the gut microbiota of heme-fed rats was enriched with Enterobacteriaceae and B. fragilis whereas Roseburia spp. and Lactobacillus spp. were underrepresented. Notably, Enterobacteriaceae expansion is also found in Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD) patients at high risk for CRC and can induce inflammation in the host gut epithelium. Moreover, B. fragilis has been associated with inflammation-induced colon cancer. It has also been shown that Lactobacilli can inhibit iron-induced lipoperoxidation. Remarkably, the gut microbiota modulations observed after heme iron intake present similarities with that observed comparing colorectal cancer patients and healthy volunteers. However, although the association between gut microbiota and CRC is conceptually interesting, these outcomes do not help to explain the mechanism behind the modulations of the gut microbiota by the diet and the consequent impact on CRC risk. In addition, while many studies have been conducted for bacteria, fungi have been virtually unexplored by metagenomic studies, yet they are emerging as key players involved in autoimmune or inflammatory disorders, as recently demonstrated. Their relative under-representation in number compared to bacteria, results in their underestimation, since fungal DNA often cannot be purified using standard approaches. Preliminary results revealed a higher frequency of S. cerevisiae in IBD, a group pathologies associated with increased risk of CRC.

Study Design

Study Type:

Interventional

Actual Enrollment :

103 participants

Allocation:

Randomized

Intervention Model:

Parallel Assignment

Intervention Model Description:

Randomized parallel open dietary intervention study with 3 arms of interventionRandomized parallel open dietary intervention study with 3 arms of intervention

Masking:

None (Open Label)

Masking Description:

In this trial blinding of participants and investigators will not be possible because of obvious differences between the intervention diets

Primary Purpose:

Prevention

Official Title:

Faecal Microbiome as Determinant of the Effect of Diet on Colorectal-cancer Risk: Comparison of Meat Based Versus Pesco-vegetarian Diets (MeaTIc)

Actual Study Start Date :

Jun 1, 2019

Actual Primary Completion Date :

Dec 31, 2019

Actual Study Completion Date :

Apr 30, 2021

Arms and Interventions

Arm	Intervention/Treatment
Active Comparator: Meat-based diet (MBD) Behavioral intervention with diet including 4 servings per week of red meat, 3 servings per week of processed meat, and 1 servings per week of poultry, for a total amount of 900 g per week of meat.	Behavioral: Meat-based diet Diet including 4 servings per week of red meat (1 serving = 150 g), 3 servings per week of processed meat (1 serving = 50 g), and 1 servings per week of poultry (1 serving = 150 g), for a total amount of 900 g per week of meat. Other Names: MBD
Experimental: Meat-based alpha-tocopherol (MBD-T) Behavioral intervention including diet with 4 servings per week of red meat, 3 servings per week of processed meat, and 1 servings per week of poultry, for a total amount of 900 g per week of meat with a dietary supplement of 100 mg/day of alpha-tocopherol in the form of tablet	Dietary Supplement: Meat-based diet supplemented with alpha-tocopherol (MBD-T) Dietary intervention like the MBD with supplementation of alpha-tocopherol at a dosage of 100 mg/die. Available evidence suggests that alpha-tocopherol may help prevent colon cancer by decreasing the formation of mutagens arising from the oxidation of faecal lipids, by decreasing oxidative stress in the epithelial cells of the colon and by molecular mechanisms that influence cell death, cell cycle and transcriptional events (Pierre 2013, Bastide 2016, Bastide 2017, Diallo 2016). It is important to note that 200 mg/day of tocopherol was administered to 20,000 women for 10 years without side effects (Lee et al.,2005). Other Names: MBD-T
Experimental: Pesco-vegetarian (PVD) Behavioral intervention with diet excluding fresh and processed meat, poultry but including 3 servings per week of any type of fish, excluding shellfish	Behavioral: Pesco-vegetarian diet Diet excluding fresh and processed meat, poultry but including 3 servings per week of any type of fish, excluding shellfish (1 serving = 150 g), for a total amount of 450 g per week. Diet will contain other sources of proteins (e.g. eggs, dairy, legumes/beans). There is suggestive evidence that fish and vegetable consumption has protective effects against CRC (Vieira et al., 2017). Other Names: PVD

Arm

Intervention/Treatment

Active Comparator: Meat-based diet (MBD)

Behavioral intervention with diet including 4 servings per week of red meat, 3 servings per week of processed meat, and 1 servings per week of poultry, for a total amount of 900 g per week of meat.

Behavioral: Meat-based diet

Diet including 4 servings per week of red meat (1 serving = 150 g), 3 servings per week of processed meat (1 serving = 50 g), and 1 servings per week of poultry (1 serving = 150 g), for a total amount of 900 g per week of meat.

Other Names:

MBD

Experimental: Meat-based alpha-tocopherol (MBD-T)

Behavioral intervention including diet with 4 servings per week of red meat, 3 servings per week of processed meat, and 1 servings per week of poultry, for a total amount of 900 g per week of meat with a dietary supplement of 100 mg/day of alpha-tocopherol in the form of tablet

Dietary Supplement: Meat-based diet supplemented with alpha-tocopherol (MBD-T)

Dietary intervention like the MBD with supplementation of alpha-tocopherol at a dosage of 100 mg/die. Available evidence suggests that alpha-tocopherol may help prevent colon cancer by decreasing the formation of mutagens arising from the oxidation of faecal lipids, by decreasing oxidative stress in the epithelial cells of the colon and by molecular mechanisms that influence cell death, cell cycle and transcriptional events (Pierre 2013, Bastide 2016, Bastide 2017, Diallo 2016). It is important to note that 200 mg/day of tocopherol was administered to 20,000 women for 10 years without side effects (Lee et al.,2005).

Other Names:

MBD-T

Experimental: Pesco-vegetarian (PVD)

Behavioral intervention with diet excluding fresh and processed meat, poultry but including 3 servings per week of any type of fish, excluding shellfish

Behavioral: Pesco-vegetarian diet

Diet excluding fresh and processed meat, poultry but including 3 servings per week of any type of fish, excluding shellfish (1 serving = 150 g), for a total amount of 450 g per week. Diet will contain other sources of proteins (e.g. eggs, dairy, legumes/beans). There is suggestive evidence that fish and vegetable consumption has protective effects against CRC (Vieira et al., 2017).

Other Names:

PVD

Outcome Measures

Primary Outcome Measures

DNA damage [3 months]
Decrease (<25%) of DNA damage by faecal water (genotoxicity), using comet assay in a cellular model

Secondary Outcome Measures

Microbiome and metabolomics profiles [3 months]
Changes of microbiome and the relative metabolomics profiles from baseline
Peroxidation [3 months]
Global and specific peroxidation of omega-3 and omega-6 of the faecal water change from baseline
Inflammatory parameters [3 months]
Pro- and anti-inflammatory profile's change from baseline
Oxidative stress [3 months]
Oxidative stress profile's change from baseline

Eligibility Criteria

Criteria

Ages Eligible for Study:

18 Years to 50 Years

Sexes Eligible for Study:

All

Accepts Healthy Volunteers:

Yes

Inclusion Criteria:

clinically healthy (both sexes)
age >18 years and ≤ 50 years.

The study population will be selected with an age ranging from 18 to 50 years because after 50 years the risk for CRC shows a significant increase in incidence. In fact, more than 90% of the people diagnosed with the disease are older than 50, with the average age at the time of diagnosis being 64 (Amersi et al., 2005). With respect to gender, its role in the development of colorectal cancer remains unclear (Amersi et al., 2005).