The Dental Care Revolution: Health Education Using AI or Humanized Counseling on Plague Control and Periodontal Treatment Outcome in Patients With Periodontal Disease
Study Details
Study Description
Brief Summary
The aim of this study was to evaluate the long-term effectiveness of an AI dental monitoring intervention on patients' periodontal disease, preventive behaviors and motivation. This randomized controlled trial included experimental group: AI group (EG-A), AI-humanized group (EG-B) and control group(CG), respectively.
The EG-A and EG-B received AI dental monitoring intervention by taking mouth image at home once a week for six month. Baseline and follow-up surveys were used to collect the data in oral health related quality of life,periodontal parameters, periodontal preventive behaviors and motivation.
| Condition or Disease | Intervention/Treatment | Phase |
|---|---|---|
|
N/A |
Detailed Description
A randomized experimental design was used. Patients with periodontal disease whose aged 35-65 years were recruited through department of Periodontics in Kaohsiung Medical University Hospital.
Each group was expected for 100 per group, patients will be randomized into each group. G*Power (version 3.1.9.4) was used for power analysis.
All patients will underwent periodontal examination at baseline and at 1-month, 3-month, 6-month follow-ups.
Each patients will be diagnosed periodontal disease by dentist and have more than 16 functional teeth.
Each patients will completed the questionnaire at baseline and at 1-month, 3-month and 6-month follow-up.
Study Design
Arms and Interventions
| Arm | Intervention/Treatment |
|---|---|
| Experimental: Experimental group A (AI Group: EG-A) The AI group scanned their own mouths at home once a week for 6 months, with each scan taking approximately 5 min. After scanning, they uploaded the results to the AI system for evaluation. The AI system then selected and sent a message to each patient depending on their intraoral conditions. |
Behavioral: The AI-assisted tool used in this study was called Dental Monitoring (DM).
DM is the first APP system used in orthopedics patients in the world,it has been widely used in Asian countries (Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singapore, Japan,etc.) and has been used by 2140 patients so far. DM allows patients to take in-mouth photos at home, and uses AI as a background analysis to evaluate the patient's current oral condition (including oral hygiene and gum status) based on the photo.
|
| Experimental: Experimental group B (AI and health counseling group: EG-B) The AI and health counseling group scanned their own mouths at home once a week for 6 months, with each scan taking approximately 5 min. After scanning, they uploaded the results to the AI system for evaluation. The EG-B received both AI-assisted DM and real-person oral health counseling and advice from a counselor, who assessed their oral hygiene conditions on the basis of their scanning results and then provided individualized counseling, such as pointing out unclean teeth and offering suggestions on cleaning tools. |
Behavioral: The AI-assisted tool used in this study was called Dental Monitoring (DM).
DM is the first APP system used in orthopedics patients in the world,it has been widely used in Asian countries (Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singapore, Japan,etc.) and has been used by 2140 patients so far. DM allows patients to take in-mouth photos at home, and uses AI as a background analysis to evaluate the patient's current oral condition (including oral hygiene and gum status) based on the photo.
|
| No Intervention: No Intervention: Control group (CG) the control group(CG) only have standard oral hygiene education |
Outcome Measures
Primary Outcome Measures
- gingival index (GI) [Change from Baseline GI at 1-month after intervention]
The gingival inflammation status of 6 tooth was recorded using the gingiva index, as follows: 0 = No inflammation. = Mild inflammation, slight change in color, slight edema, no bleeding on probing = Moderate inflammation, moderate glazing, redness, bleeding on probing = Severe inflammation, marked redness and hypertrophy, ulceration, tendency to spontaneous bleeding. For each patient, GI will measured by the teeth 12,16,24,32,36,44
- gingival index (GI) [Change from Baseline GI at 3-month after intervention]
The gingival inflammation status of 6 tooth was recorded using the gingiva index, as follows: 0 = No inflammation. = Mild inflammation, slight change in color, slight edema, no bleeding on probing = Moderate inflammation, moderate glazing, redness, bleeding on probing = Severe inflammation, marked redness and hypertrophy, ulceration, tendency to spontaneous bleeding. For each patient, GI will measured by the teeth 12,16,24,32,36,44
- gingival index (GI) [Change from Baseline GI at 6-month after intervention]
The gingival inflammation status of 6 tooth was recorded using the gingiva index, as follows: 0 = No inflammation. = Mild inflammation, slight change in color, slight edema, no bleeding on probing = Moderate inflammation, moderate glazing, redness, bleeding on probing = Severe inflammation, marked redness and hypertrophy, ulceration, tendency to spontaneous bleeding. For each patient, GI will measured by the teeth 12,16,24,32,36,44
- plaque index (PI) [Change from Baseline PI at 1-month after intervention]
The plaque status of 6 tooth was recorded using the plaque index, as followes: 0 = No plaque = Thin film of plaque, scraped with explorer = Moderate amount of plaque, visible with naked eyes = Abundance of soft matter within the gingival pocket and/or on the tooth and gingival margin. For each patient, PI will measured by the teeth 12,16,24,32,36,44
- plaque index (PI) [Change from Baseline PI at 3-month after intervention]
The plaque status of 6 tooth was recorded using the plaque index, as followes: 0 = No plaque = Thin film of plaque, scraped with explorer = Moderate amount of plaque, visible with naked eyes = Abundance of soft matter within the gingival pocket and/or on the tooth and gingival margin. For each patient, PI will measured by the teeth 12,16,24,32,36,44
- plaque index (PI) [Change from Baseline PI at 6-month after intervention]
The plaque status of 6 tooth was recorded using the plaque index, as followes: 0 = No plaque = Thin film of plaque, scraped with explorer = Moderate amount of plaque, visible with naked eyes = Abundance of soft matter within the gingival pocket and/or on the tooth and gingival margin. For each patient, PI will measured by the teeth 12,16,24,32,36,44
- Probing Pocket Depth (PPD) [Change from Baseline PPD at 1-month after intervention]
Using periodontal probe to measure the depth from the bottom of the periodontal pocket to the gingival margin, recorded at six sites (mesial [buccal and lingual/palatal], distal [buccal and lingual/palatal], mid-buccal, and mid-lingual/palatal) around each tooth, except for the third molar.
- Probing Pocket Depth (PPD) [Change from Baseline PPD at 3-month after intervention]
Using periodontal probe to measure the depth from the bottom of the periodontal pocket to the gingival margin, recorded at six sites (mesial [buccal and lingual/palatal], distal [buccal and lingual/palatal], mid-buccal, and mid-lingual/palatal) around each tooth, except for the third molar.
- Probing Pocket Depth (PPD) [Change from Baseline PPD at 6-month after intervention]
Using periodontal probe to measure the depth from the bottom of the periodontal pocket to the gingival margin, recorded at six sites (mesial [buccal and lingual/palatal], distal [buccal and lingual/palatal], mid-buccal, and mid-lingual/palatal) around each tooth, except for the third molar.
- Clinical Attachment Loss(CAL) [Change from Baseline CAL at 1-month after intervention]
Using periodontal probe to measure the distance from the enamel-dentin junction to the bottom of the periodontal pocket. - Page 4 of 8 - For each patient, CAL will measured each teeth.
- Clinical Attachment Loss(CAL) [Change from Baseline CAL at 3-month after intervention]
Using periodontal probe to measure the distance from the enamel-dentin junction to the bottom of the periodontal pocket. - Page 4 of 8 - For each patient, CAL will measured each teeth.
- Clinical Attachment Loss(CAL) [Change from Baseline CAL at 6-month after intervention]
Using periodontal probe to measure the distance from the enamel-dentin junction to the bottom of the periodontal pocket. - Page 4 of 8 - For each patient, CAL will measured each teeth.
- OHRQoL(OHIP-14T scales) [Change from Baseline at 1 month after intervention]
Item including that because of problems with your teeth or mouth, you: Have you had trouble pronouncing any words because of problems" Have you felt that your sense of taste has worsened" Have you had painful aching in your mouth" Have you found it uncomfortable to eat any foods" Have you been self-conscious" Have you felt tense" Has been your diet been unsatisfactory" Have you had to interrupt meals?" Have you found it difficult to relax" Have you been a bit embarrassed" Have you been a bit irritable with other people" Have you had difficulty doing your usual jobs" Have you felt that life in general was less satisfying" Have you been totally unable to function" Responses are scored on a 5-point Likert scale with endpoints ranging from 0 (never) to 4 (very often), indicating the frequency of the problem over the preceding 6 months. The possible scores were 0-56, with lower scores indicating more favorable OHRQoL.
- OHRQoL(OHIP-14T scales) [Change from Baseline at 3 month after intervention]
Item including that because of problems with your teeth or mouth, you: Have you had trouble pronouncing any words because of problems" Have you felt that your sense of taste has worsened" Have you had painful aching in your mouth" Have you found it uncomfortable to eat any foods" Have you been self-conscious" Have you felt tense" Has been your diet been unsatisfactory" Have you had to interrupt meals?" Have you found it difficult to relax" Have you been a bit embarrassed" Have you been a bit irritable with other people" Have you had difficulty doing your usual jobs" Have you felt that life in general was less satisfying" Have you been totally unable to function" Responses are scored on a 5-point Likert scale with endpoints ranging from 0 (never) to 4 (very often), indicating the frequency of the problem over the preceding 6 months. The possible scores were 0-56, with lower scores indicating more favorable OHRQoL.
- OHRQoL(OHIP-14T scales) [Change from Baseline at 6 month after intervention]
Item including that because of problems with your teeth or mouth, you: Have you had trouble pronouncing any words because of problems" Have you felt that your sense of taste has worsened" Have you had painful aching in your mouth" Have you found it uncomfortable to eat any foods" Have you been self-conscious" Have you felt tense" Has been your diet been unsatisfactory" Have you had to interrupt meals?" Have you found it difficult to relax" Have you been a bit embarrassed" Have you been a bit irritable with other people" Have you had difficulty doing your usual jobs" Have you felt that life in general was less satisfying" Have you been totally unable to function" Responses are scored on a 5-point Likert scale with endpoints ranging from 0 (never) to 4 (very often), indicating the frequency of the problem over the preceding 6 months. The possible scores were 0-56, with lower scores indicating more favorable OHRQoL.
Secondary Outcome Measures
- Protection Motivation Theory (PMT) scores [Change from Baseline PMT at 1-month after intervention]
Item including that "I think periodontal disease is a serious disease" If I do not have periodontal disease prevention behavior, the risk of developing periodontal disease in the future is very high" If I stick to periodontal disease prevention behavior, it will improve my oral health" I believe that I can follow the periodontal health guidance" I find it hard to remember/hard to do periodontal health care guidance" Periodontal disease bothers me" I want to complete my personal periodontal disease prevention behavior plan" All the items' scores ranged from one to ten, with higher scores indicating a higher level of motivation toward change behaviors. Cronbach's α was 0.70 for this scale. The scores ranged from one ("impossible") to ten ("very possible"), with the total possible score ranging from seven to seventy
- Protection Motivation Theory (PMT) scores [Change from Baseline PMT at 3-month after intervention]
Item including that "I think periodontal disease is a serious disease" If I do not have periodontal disease prevention behavior, the risk of developing periodontal disease in the future is very high" If I stick to periodontal disease prevention behavior, it will improve my oral health" I believe that I can follow the periodontal health guidance" I find it hard to remember/hard to do periodontal health care guidance" Periodontal disease bothers me" I want to complete my personal periodontal disease prevention behavior plan" All the items' scores ranged from one to ten, with higher scores indicating a higher level of motivation toward change behaviors. Cronbach's α was 0.70 for this scale. The scores ranged from one ("impossible") to ten ("very possible"), with the total possible score ranging from seven to seventy
- Protection Motivation Theory (PMT) scores [Change from Baseline PMT at 6-month after intervention]
Item including that "I think periodontal disease is a serious disease" If I do not have periodontal disease prevention behavior, the risk of developing periodontal disease in the future is very high" If I stick to periodontal disease prevention behavior, it will improve my oral health" I believe that I can follow the periodontal health guidance" I find it hard to remember/hard to do periodontal health care guidance" Periodontal disease bothers me" I want to complete my personal periodontal disease prevention behavior plan" All the items' scores ranged from one to ten, with higher scores indicating a higher level of motivation toward change behaviors. Cronbach's α was 0.70 for this scale. The scores ranged from one ("impossible") to ten ("very possible"), with the total possible score ranging from seven to seventy
- oral self-care behavior [Change from Baseline at 1 month after intervention]
Item including that: "How many times do you brush your teeth a day?" The response was (once or twice day or three times or fours times or more/ day). "How long do you usually brush your teeth each time?" The response was lower than 1 min or 1-2 min or 2-3 min or more than 3 min/ day. "What is your main method of brushing your teeth?"The response was horizontally or vertically or Circle brush or Rotating brush or Horizontal+vertical+ and by the gum at a 45 degree angle. "How often do you replace your toothbrush?" The response was 3-6 month or more than 6 month or lower than 1 month or 1-2 month or 2-3 month. "Do you use a soft-bristled toothbrush?" The response was no or unknown or yes. "Do you have a habit of using interdental brushes?" The response was no or yes. "Do you have a habit of eating snack?" The response was no or yes.
- oral self-care behavior [Change from Baseline at 3 month after intervention]
Item including that: "How many times do you brush your teeth a day?" The response was (once or twice day or three times or fours times or more/ day). "How long do you usually brush your teeth each time?" The response was lower than 1 min or 1-2 min or 2-3 min or more than 3 min/ day. "What is your main method of brushing your teeth?"The response was horizontally or vertically or Circle brush or Rotating brush or Horizontal+vertical+ and by the gum at a 45 degree angle. "How often do you replace your toothbrush?" The response was 3-6 month or more than 6 month or lower than 1 month or 1-2 month or 2-3 month. "Do you use a soft-bristled toothbrush?" The response was no or unknown or yes. "Do you have a habit of using interdental brushes?" The response was no or yes. "Do you have a habit of eating snack?" The response was no or yes.
- oral self-care behavior [Change from Baseline at 6 month after intervention]
Item including that: "How many times do you brush your teeth a day?" The response was (once or twice day or three times or fours times or more/ day). "How long do you usually brush your teeth each time?" The response was lower than 1 min or 1-2 min or 2-3 min or more than 3 min/ day. "What is your main method of brushing your teeth?"The response was horizontally or vertically or Circle brush or Rotating brush or Horizontal+vertical+ and by the gum at a 45 degree angle. "How often do you replace your toothbrush?" The response was 3-6 month or more than 6 month or lower than 1 month or 1-2 month or 2-3 month. "Do you use a soft-bristled toothbrush?" The response was no or unknown or yes. "Do you have a habit of using interdental brushes?" The response was no or yes. "Do you have a habit of eating snack?" The response was no or yes.
Eligibility Criteria
Criteria
Inclusion Criteria:
-
Age between 35-65 years old
-
Diagnosed periodontal disease by dentist (Comprehensive Periodontal Treatment Project)
-
More than 16 functional teeth
Exclusion Criteria:
-
Have received periodontal treatment within 3 months
-
Patient has disease related to periodontal disease (ex. Drug-related excessive gum growth or blood clotting problems, pregnancy, mental illness)
-
Disability patients
Contacts and Locations
Locations
| Site | City | State | Country | Postal Code | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Kaohsiung Medical University Chung-Ho Memorial Hospital | Kaohsiung | Taiwan |
Sponsors and Collaborators
- Kaohsiung Medical University Chung-Ho Memorial Hospital
Investigators
- Principal Investigator: Hsiao-Ling Huang, Dr.PH, Kaohsiung Medical University, College of Dental Medicine, Department of Oral Hygiene
Study Documents (Full-Text)
None provided.More Information
Publications
None provided.- KMUHIRB-F(II)-20200059