Comparative Study of ELLIPTA Dry Powder Inhaler (DPI) Versus DISKUS DPI Used With HandiHaler DPI in Subjects With Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)

Sponsor
GlaxoSmithKline (Industry)
Overall Status
Completed
CT.gov ID
NCT03227445
Collaborator
(none)
240
18
4
3.5
13.3
3.8

Study Details

Study Description

Brief Summary

This randomized, cross over study aims to find out the benefits of delivering triple therapy using a single ELLIPTA® DPI (fixed-dose combination triple therapy) versus delivering triple therapy using two different types of inhalers (open triple therapy) including DISKUS® with HandiHaler® to subjects with COPD. Correct inhaler use, critical errors and performance attributes will also be assessed. Approximately 240 subjects with COPD will be randomized in the study. The study will be conducted in 3 visits and will be completed in approximately 56 days. At Visit 1 (Day 1) and Visit 2 (Day 28) subjects will be randomized to receive a placebo ELLIPTA inhaler once daily (QD) or a placebo DISKUS twice daily (BID) with placebo HandiHaler QD inhaler in 1:1 ratio in a cross-over manner for the study period (28 days for each period). At Visit 3 (Day 56), subjects will be asked to complete preference questionnaire 1 or 2. There will be no active treatment and subjects will continue to take their own prescribed COPD maintenance and rescue medication during the entire study period. ELLIPTA and DISKUS are the registered trademarks of GlaxoSmithKline group of companies. HandiHaler is the registered trademark of Boehringer Ingelheim group of companies.

Condition or Disease Intervention/Treatment Phase
  • Device: ELLIPTA placebo DPI
  • Device: DISKUS placebo DPI
  • Device: HandiHaler placebo DPI
  • Other: Inhaler preference questionnaires
Phase 4

Study Design

Study Type:
Interventional
Actual Enrollment :
240 participants
Allocation:
Randomized
Intervention Model:
Crossover Assignment
Intervention Model Description:
Subjects will be randomized to receive a placebo ELLIPTA inhaler QD or a placebo DISKUS BID with placebo HandiHaler QD inhaler at Visit 1 and Visit 2 in a cross-over manner followed by Preference Questionnaire 1 or 2Subjects will be randomized to receive a placebo ELLIPTA inhaler QD or a placebo DISKUS BID with placebo HandiHaler QD inhaler at Visit 1 and Visit 2 in a cross-over manner followed by Preference Questionnaire 1 or 2
Masking:
None (Open Label)
Masking Description:
This will an open-label study and blinding will not be performed.
Primary Purpose:
Treatment
Official Title:
A Randomized, Open-label, Cross-over, Placebo Inhaler Study to Evaluate the Correct Use of ELLIPTA™ Dry Powder Inhaler (DPI) Compared to DISKUS™ DPI Used in Combination With HandiHaler DPI in Participants With Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)
Actual Study Start Date :
Sep 20, 2017
Actual Primary Completion Date :
Jan 4, 2018
Actual Study Completion Date :
Jan 4, 2018

Arms and Interventions

Arm Intervention/Treatment
Experimental: Treatment sequence A

Eligible subjects will use ELLIPTA DPI QD for 28 days in Period 1 followed by DISKUS BID with HandiHaler QD use for 28 days in Period 2. These subjects will then be asked to complete preference questionnaire 1 at Visit 3 (Day 56).

Device: ELLIPTA placebo DPI
ELLIPTA is a dry powder inhaler used via oral route. It will be a placebo DPI with two strips with 30 blisters per strip. First strip will contain lactose monohydrate and the second strip will contain lactose monohydrate blended with magnesium stearate.

Device: DISKUS placebo DPI
DISKUS is a dry powder inhaler used via oral route. It will be a placebo DPI with one blister strip that will contain lactose monohydrate.

Device: HandiHaler placebo DPI
HandiHaler is a dry powder inhaler used via oral route. It will be a DPI with placebo capsules that will contain lactose monohydrate.

Other: Inhaler preference questionnaires
Preference questionnaires will be given to subjects to understand the inhaler preference. There will be 2 types of questionnaire, preference questionnaires 1 and 2, which will be randomized at visit 3 (Day 56).

Experimental: Treatment sequence B

Eligible subjects will use ELLIPTA DPI QD for 28 days in Period 1 followed by DISKUS BID with HandiHaler QD use for 28 days in Period 2. These subjects will then be asked to complete preference questionnaire 2 at Visit 3 (Day 56).

Device: ELLIPTA placebo DPI
ELLIPTA is a dry powder inhaler used via oral route. It will be a placebo DPI with two strips with 30 blisters per strip. First strip will contain lactose monohydrate and the second strip will contain lactose monohydrate blended with magnesium stearate.

Device: DISKUS placebo DPI
DISKUS is a dry powder inhaler used via oral route. It will be a placebo DPI with one blister strip that will contain lactose monohydrate.

Device: HandiHaler placebo DPI
HandiHaler is a dry powder inhaler used via oral route. It will be a DPI with placebo capsules that will contain lactose monohydrate.

Other: Inhaler preference questionnaires
Preference questionnaires will be given to subjects to understand the inhaler preference. There will be 2 types of questionnaire, preference questionnaires 1 and 2, which will be randomized at visit 3 (Day 56).

Experimental: Treatment sequence C

Eligible subjects will use DISKUS BID with HandiHaler QD for 28 days in Period 1 followed by ELLIPTA DPI QD use for 28 days in Period 2. These subjects will then be asked to complete preference questionnaire 1 at Visit 3 (Day 56).

Device: ELLIPTA placebo DPI
ELLIPTA is a dry powder inhaler used via oral route. It will be a placebo DPI with two strips with 30 blisters per strip. First strip will contain lactose monohydrate and the second strip will contain lactose monohydrate blended with magnesium stearate.

Device: DISKUS placebo DPI
DISKUS is a dry powder inhaler used via oral route. It will be a placebo DPI with one blister strip that will contain lactose monohydrate.

Device: HandiHaler placebo DPI
HandiHaler is a dry powder inhaler used via oral route. It will be a DPI with placebo capsules that will contain lactose monohydrate.

Other: Inhaler preference questionnaires
Preference questionnaires will be given to subjects to understand the inhaler preference. There will be 2 types of questionnaire, preference questionnaires 1 and 2, which will be randomized at visit 3 (Day 56).

Experimental: Treatment sequence D

Eligible subjects will use DISKUS BID with HandiHaler QD for 28 days in Period 1 followed by ELLIPTA DPI QD use for 28 days in Period 2. These subjects will then be asked to complete preference questionnaire 2 at Visit 3 (Day 56).

Device: ELLIPTA placebo DPI
ELLIPTA is a dry powder inhaler used via oral route. It will be a placebo DPI with two strips with 30 blisters per strip. First strip will contain lactose monohydrate and the second strip will contain lactose monohydrate blended with magnesium stearate.

Device: DISKUS placebo DPI
DISKUS is a dry powder inhaler used via oral route. It will be a placebo DPI with one blister strip that will contain lactose monohydrate.

Device: HandiHaler placebo DPI
HandiHaler is a dry powder inhaler used via oral route. It will be a DPI with placebo capsules that will contain lactose monohydrate.

Other: Inhaler preference questionnaires
Preference questionnaires will be given to subjects to understand the inhaler preference. There will be 2 types of questionnaire, preference questionnaires 1 and 2, which will be randomized at visit 3 (Day 56).

Outcome Measures

Primary Outcome Measures

  1. Percentage of Participants With Zero Errors After 28 Days of Inhaler Use in Each Treatment Phase (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical) [Up to Day 56]

    A checklist for correct use of each inhaler was developed in Patient Instruction Leaflets (PIL's). Participants were guided by trained health care provider (HCP) to demonstrate correct use of inhaler. Baseline assessment was conducted when participant initially dispensed the inhaler. Second assessment was conducted after each 28day dosing period. Correct Use Check list was completed by HCP at each visit. Primary hypothetical estimand is the estimate of treatment effect of all participants who stayed on their randomized study device sequence and did not change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER, throughout both 28 day treatment periods. Participants could attend visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. Participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included

  2. Percentage of Participants With Atleast One Error After 28 Days of Inhaler Use in Each Treatment Phase (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical) [Up to Day 56]

    Primary estimand is the treatment effect estimated in participants who stayed on their randomised study device sequence and did not change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER, throughout both 28 day treatment periods. The participant could attend the visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. For primary estimand, a sensitivity analysis using Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included

  3. Percentage of Participants With Atleast One Error After 28 Days of Inhaler Use in Each Treatment Phase (Supplementary Estimand: Composite) [Up to Day 56]

    Supplementary estimand estimated the composite effect of initial randomized treatment. A sensitivity analysis using the Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Participants who withdrew during period 2 were included in the analysis using early withdrawal data where available or imputation otherwise. Participants who experienced an intercurrent event in Period 1 were excluded from the analysis.

  4. Percentage of Participants With Zero Errors After 28 Days of Inhaler Use in Each Treatment Phase(Supplementary Estimand: Composite) [Up to Day 56]

    Supplementary estimand estimated the composite effect of initial randomized treatment. The analysis was performed using stratified exact logistic model. Participants were included in the model as fixed strata, treatment option was included in the exact statement and period included as fixed effects. Participants who withdrew during period 2 were included in the analysis using early withdrawal data where available or imputation otherwise. Participants who experienced an intercurrent event in Period 1 were excluded from the analysis.

Secondary Outcome Measures

  1. Number of Errors by Type for Each Inhaler After 28 Days of Use in Each Treatment Phase (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical) [Up to Day 56]

    The occurrence of each type of error for each inhaler (ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER) were evaluated based on the information collected in Correct Use Checklists. Primary estimand is the treatment effect estimated in participants who stayed on their randomised study device sequence & did not change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER, throughout both 28 day treatment periods. The participant could attend the visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. For primary estimand, a sensitivity analysis using Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups & experienced no intercurrent events were included. The number of error is reported as NA for the type of error which was not applicable to the particular inhaler type

  2. Number of Errors Per Participant for Each Treatment Group After 28 Days of Use (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical) [Up to Day 56]

    Participants were provided with PIL explaining correct use of inhaler. Overall error includes both critical and non-critical errors. Primary estimand is the treatment effect estimated in participants who stayed on their randomised study device sequence and did not change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER, throughout both 28 day treatment periods. The participant could attend the visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. For primary estimand, a sensitivity analysis using Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included.

  3. Change in Errors Per Participant for Each Treatment Group After 28 Days of Use [Day 1 and Day 28 of each treatment group]

    Assessment of errors was conducted by HCP trained in the correct inhaler use of the three inhalers based on the checklist of errors. The median number of overall errors made by per participant was assessed for ELLIPTA and DISKUS + HandiHaler both on Day 1 and Day 28 for each treatment group. The difference was calculated by subtracting values of Day 28 from Day1 for each treatment regimen. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included.

  4. Number of Errors for Each Treatment Group in Participants With One or More Errors After 28 Days of Use (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical) [Up to Day 56]

    Participants were provided with the PIL, explaining correct use of the inhaler. Overall error includes both critical and non-critical errors. Assessment of errors was conducted by HCP trained in the correct inhaler use of the three inhalers based on the checklist of errors. Primary estimand is the treatment effect estimated in participants who stayed on their randomised study device sequence and did not change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER, throughout both 28 day treatment periods. The participant could attend the visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. For primary estimand, a sensitivity analysis using Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included.

  5. Change in Errors for Each Treatment Group in Participants With One or More Errors After 28 Days of Use [Day 1 and Day 28 of each treatment group]

    Assessment of errors was conducted by health care professionals trained in the correct inhaler use of the three inhalers based on the checklist of errors. The median of overall errors made by each participant was assessed for ELLIPTA and DISKUS + HandiHaler both on Day 1 and Day 28. The difference was calculated by subtracting values of Day 28 from Day1 for each treatment regimen. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included.

  6. Number of Participants With Zero Critical Errors After 28 Days of Each Treatment Group Use (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical) [Up to Day 56]

    A checklist for correct use of each inhaler was developed based on the steps identified in the PIL. A critical error was defined as an error that was most likely to result in no, or a significantly reduced amount, of medication being inhaled by the participant. Primary estimand is the treatment effect estimated in participants who stayed on their randomised study device sequence and did not change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER, throughout both 28 day treatment periods. The participant could attend the visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. For primary estimand, a sensitivity analysis using Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included.

  7. Number of Participants With Atleast One Critical Error After 28 Days of Each Treatment Group Use (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical) [Up to Day 56]

    A critical error was defined as an error that was most likely to result in no, or a significantly reduced amount, of medication being inhaled by the participant. Primary estimand is the treatment effect estimated in participants who stayed on their randomised study device sequence and did not change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER, throughout both 28 day treatment periods. The participant could attend the visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. For primary estimand, a sensitivity analysis using Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included.

  8. Number of Participants With Atleast One Critical Error After 28 Days of Each Treatment Group Use (Supplementary Estimand: Composite) [Up to Day 56]

    Supplementary estimand estimated the composite effect of initial randomized treatment. A sensitivity analysis using the Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Participants who withdrew during period 2 were included in the analysis using early withdrawal data where available or imputation otherwise. Participants who experienced an intercurrent event in Period 1 were excluded from the analysis.

Eligibility Criteria

Criteria

Ages Eligible for Study:
40 Years and Older
Sexes Eligible for Study:
All
Accepts Healthy Volunteers:
No
Inclusion Criteria:
  • Subjects must be capable of giving signed informed consent.

  • Subjects must have a diagnosis of COPD with a documented history of COPD for at least 12 months, in accordance with the definition by the American Thoracic Society/European Respiratory Society.

  • Subjects must be 40 years of age inclusive, at the time of signing the informed consent.

  • Male or female subjects will be included. Females must not be pregnant or planning pregnancy during the study or not lactating.

  • Subjects must have a documented post albuterol forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1)/ forced vital capacity (FVC) ratio <0.70 and FEV1 <=70% of predicted obtained within two years of Visit 1.

  • Current or former (defined as subjects who have quit smoking for at least 3 months prior to Screening/Visit 1) cigarette smokers with a > 10 pack-year smoking history [Number of pack-years = (number of cigarettes per day/20) x number of years smoked (example, 10 pack-years is equal to 20 cigarettes per day for 10 years, or 10 cigarettes per day for 20 years].

  • All subjects should be currently receiving maintenance treatment for COPD for at least 4 weeks prior to Randomization/Visit 1 and evaluated as unlikely to change COPD treatment within 4 weeks of Visit 1.

  • All subjects should be able to stay on their prescribed maintenance COPD inhaler (s) without change throughout the entire treatment period.

  • Subjects must be able to read, comprehend, and record information in English.

Exclusion Criteria:
  • Subjects must not have a current diagnosis of asthma.

  • Subjects must not have used the ELLIPTA, DISKUS, or HandiHaler inhalers in the 12 months prior to Visit 1.

  • Subjects must not be receiving their current COPD medications with the ELLIPTA, DISKUS, or HandiHaler inhalers.

  • Subjects must not be receiving only inhaled short-acting beta-adrenergic agonists, i.e., albuterol as their daily COPD therapy (as needed or regularly scheduled).

  • Subjects must not have experienced more than 1 COPD exacerbation which required hospitalization in the 12 months prior to Visit 1.

  • Subjects must not have a known or suspected history of alcohol or drug abuse within the last 2 years.

  • Subjects must not have a history of hypersensitivity to any component of the study inhalers (example, lactose, magnesium stearate). In addition, subjects with a history of severe milk protein allergy that, in the opinion of the study physician, contraindicates participation will also be excluded.

  • Subjects with other respiratory disorders, including active tuberculosis, active lung cancer, sarcoidosis, lung fibrosis, pulmonary hypertension, or pulmonary disease (including but not confined to asthma, bronchiectasis with the need for treatment, cystic fibrosis, and bronchopulmonary dysplasia), interstitial lung diseases or other active pulmonary diseases.

  • Subjects with historical, or current evidence of clinically significant or rapidly progressing or unstable cardiovascular, neurological, renal, hepatic, immunological, endocrine (including uncontrolled diabetes or thyroid disease) or hematological abnormalities that are uncontrolled. Significant is defined as any disease that, in the opinion of the investigator, would put the safety of the participant at risk through participation, or which would affect the analysis if the disease/condition exacerbated during the study will be excluded.

  • Subjects with history of psychiatric disease, intellectual impairment, poor motivation or other conditions that will limit the validity of informed consent to participate in the study will be excluded.

  • Subjects at risk of non-compliance, or unable to comply with the study procedures, or unable to continue their current medications.

  • Subjects who have received an investigational drug and/or medical device/inhaler within 30 days of entry into this study (Screening/Visit 1), or within five drug half-lives of the investigational drug, whichever is longer.

  • Subjects will not be eligible for this study if he/she is an immediate family member of the participating investigator, sub investigator, study coordinator, or employee of the participating investigator.

Contacts and Locations

Locations

Site City State Country Postal Code
1 GSK Investigational Site Orlando Florida United States 32825
2 GSK Investigational Site Natchitoches Louisiana United States 71457
3 GSK Investigational Site Saint Charles Missouri United States 63301
4 GSK Investigational Site Charlotte North Carolina United States 28207
5 GSK Investigational Site Gastonia North Carolina United States 28054
6 GSK Investigational Site Monroe North Carolina United States 28112
7 GSK Investigational Site Mooresville North Carolina United States 28117
8 GSK Investigational Site Canton Ohio United States 44718
9 GSK Investigational Site Cincinnati Ohio United States 45231
10 GSK Investigational Site Dayton Ohio United States 45419
11 GSK Investigational Site Oklahoma City Oklahoma United States 73120
12 GSK Investigational Site Medford Oregon United States 97504
13 GSK Investigational Site Anderson South Carolina United States 29621
14 GSK Investigational Site Greenville South Carolina United States 29615
15 GSK Investigational Site Rock Hill South Carolina United States 29732
16 GSK Investigational Site Spartanburg South Carolina United States 29303
17 GSK Investigational Site Richmond Virginia United States 23225
18 GSK Investigational Site Richmond Virginia United States 23229

Sponsors and Collaborators

  • GlaxoSmithKline

Investigators

  • Study Director: GSK Clinical Trials, GlaxoSmithKline

Study Documents (Full-Text)

More Information

Publications

Responsible Party:
GlaxoSmithKline
ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier:
NCT03227445
Other Study ID Numbers:
  • 206901
First Posted:
Jul 24, 2017
Last Update Posted:
Jul 8, 2020
Last Verified:
Jun 1, 2020
Individual Participant Data (IPD) Sharing Statement:
Yes
Plan to Share IPD:
Yes
Studies a U.S. FDA-regulated Drug Product:
Yes
Studies a U.S. FDA-regulated Device Product:
Yes
Keywords provided by GlaxoSmithKline
Additional relevant MeSH terms:

Study Results

Participant Flow

Recruitment Details This is a randomized, multi-center, open-label study comparing placebo ELLIPTA with placebo DISKUS + HandiHaler to assess correct inhaler use in participants with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD). A total of 17 centers across United States participated in the study.
Pre-assignment Detail Out of 240 randomized participants (par), 239 entered the study as 1 par was randomized in error. In order to minimize potential bias the order of placebo devices & order of responses, in preference questionnaire (PQ), was randomized in a crossover design. All par on study received placebo only & participant flow reflects this as the only treatment
Arm/Group Title ELLIPTA/DISKUS+HANDIHALER/Q1 ELLIPTA/DISKUS+HANDIHALER/Q2 DISKUS+HANDIHALER/ELLIPTA/Q1 DISKUS+HANDIHALER/ELLIPTA/Q2
Arm/Group Description Participants received placebo via ELLIPTA dry powder inhaler (DPI) in period 1 and DISKUS DPI + HandiHaler in period 2, followed by preference questionnaire (PQ) version 1. There was no active treatment and participants continued to take their own prescribed COPD medication and rescue medications for the duration of the study Participants received placebo via ELLIPTA DPI in period 1 and DISKUS DPI + HandiHaler in period 2, followed by PQ2. There was no active treatment and participants continued to take their own prescribed COPD medication and rescue medications for the duration of the study Participants received placebo via DISKUS DPI + HandiHaler in period 1 and ELLIPTA DPI in period 2, followed by PQ1. There was no active treatment and participants continued to take their own prescribed COPD medication and rescue medications for the duration of the study Participants received placebo via DISKUS DPI + HandiHaler in period 1 and ELLIPTA DPI in period 2, followed by PQ2. There was no active treatment and participants continued to take their own prescribed COPD medication and rescue medications for the duration of the study
Period Title: Period 1 (28 Days)
STARTED 60 59 60 60
COMPLETED 58 57 59 58
NOT COMPLETED 2 2 1 2
Period Title: Period 1 (28 Days)
STARTED 58 57 59 58
COMPLETED 57 56 57 55
NOT COMPLETED 1 1 2 3

Baseline Characteristics

Arm/Group Title All Study Participants
Arm/Group Description Participants received placebo via ELLIPTA dry powder inhaler (DPI) or DISKUS DPI in combination with HandiHaler DPI based on the following treatment sequences: Treatment Sequence A (ELLIPTA in period 1 and DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 2, followed by PQ 1.); Treatment Sequence B (ELLIPTA in period 1 and DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 2, followed by PQ2); Treatment Sequence C (DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 1 and ELLIPTA in period 2, followed by PQ1); or Treatment Sequence D (DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 1 and ELLIPTA in period 2, followed by PQ2). Participants continued to take their own prescribed COPD medication and rescue medications for the entire 56-day study period.
Overall Participants 239
Age (Years) [Mean (Standard Deviation) ]
Mean (Standard Deviation) [Years]
65.9
(8.25)
Sex: Female, Male (Count of Participants)
Female
108
45.2%
Male
131
54.8%
Race/Ethnicity, Customized (Count of Participants) [Number]
African American/African Heritage
23
9.6%
White - Arabic/North African Heritage
3
1.3%
White - White/Caucasian/European Heritage
213
89.1%

Outcome Measures

1. Primary Outcome
Title Percentage of Participants With Zero Errors After 28 Days of Inhaler Use in Each Treatment Phase (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical)
Description A checklist for correct use of each inhaler was developed in Patient Instruction Leaflets (PIL's). Participants were guided by trained health care provider (HCP) to demonstrate correct use of inhaler. Baseline assessment was conducted when participant initially dispensed the inhaler. Second assessment was conducted after each 28day dosing period. Correct Use Check list was completed by HCP at each visit. Primary hypothetical estimand is the estimate of treatment effect of all participants who stayed on their randomized study device sequence and did not change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER, throughout both 28 day treatment periods. Participants could attend visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. Participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included
Time Frame Up to Day 56

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
Intent-to-treat (ITT) Population comprised of all randomized participants, excluding those who were randomized in error, and did not have at least one error assessment at Visit 1. Only those participants with data available at specified time point were analyzed.
Arm/Group Title ELLIPTA DISKUS + HANDIHALER
Arm/Group Description Participants were randomized to use placebo via ELLIPTA in either period 1 or 2. Participants were randomized to use placebo via DISKUS + HANDIHALER in period 1 or 2.
Measure Participants 217 217
Number [Percentage of participants]
96
40.2%
87
NaN
Statistical Analysis 1
Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection ELLIPTA, DISKUS + HANDIHALER
Comments
Type of Statistical Test Superiority
Comments
Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value <0.001
Comments
Method stratified exact logistic model
Comments
Method of Estimation Estimation Parameter Odds Ratio (OR)
Estimated Value 6.88
Confidence Interval (2-Sided) 95%
1.97 to 54.28
Parameter Dispersion Type:
Value:
Estimation Comments Participants included in the model as fixed strata, treatment option was included in the exact statement and period included as fixed effects.
Other Statistical Analysis There are three intercurrent events identified which could impact upon the estimand of interest: The participant could withdraw from randomised study device sequence and therefore withdraw from the study The participant could change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER; these subjects should have been withdrawn from the study according to the protocol. The participant could attend the visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. Rescue Medication use and change to maintenance COPD medication which is not delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER are not considered intercurrent events
2. Secondary Outcome
Title Number of Errors by Type for Each Inhaler After 28 Days of Use in Each Treatment Phase (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical)
Description The occurrence of each type of error for each inhaler (ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER) were evaluated based on the information collected in Correct Use Checklists. Primary estimand is the treatment effect estimated in participants who stayed on their randomised study device sequence & did not change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER, throughout both 28 day treatment periods. The participant could attend the visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. For primary estimand, a sensitivity analysis using Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups & experienced no intercurrent events were included. The number of error is reported as NA for the type of error which was not applicable to the particular inhaler type
Time Frame Up to Day 56

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
ITT Population. Only those participants with data available at specified time point were analyzed.
Arm/Group Title ELLIPTA DISKUS HandiHaler
Arm/Group Description Participants were randomized to use placebo via ELLIPTA in either period 1 or 2. Participants were randomized to use placebo via DISKUS + HANDIHALER in period 1 or 2. Participants were randomized to use placebo via DISKUS + HANDIHALER in period 1 or 2.
Measure Participants 217 217 217
Par exhales while holding inhaler away from mouth
6
9
14
Par takes long steady deep breath in through mouth
2
NA
NA
Par breathes out slowly and gently
1
NA
NA
Par opened cover
NA
1
NA
Par slid lever away from mouthpiece
NA
1
NA
Par didn't tilt/shake device post dose preparation
NA
2
1
Par took a quick deep breath through the Diskus
NA
1
NA
Par removed Diskus from mouth,held breath for long
NA
2
NA
Par breathed out slowly
NA
1
NA
Par closed the cover of the inhaler
NA
2
NA
Par did not exhale into the mouthpiece
NA
NA
10
Par opened mouthpiece & center chamber is showing
NA
NA
1
Par opened only 1 capsule from the blister card
NA
NA
5
Par placed capsule in center chamber of inhaler
NA
NA
1
Par pressed green piercing button&released button
NA
NA
4
Par exhaled fully
NA
NA
7
Par closed lips tightly around mouthpiece
NA
NA
9
Par didn't block air intake vents with fingers
NA
NA
9
Par breathed in deeply
NA
NA
10
Par heard or felt the capsule vibrate
NA
NA
14
Par held breath for few seconds & removed inhaler
NA
NA
10
Par resumed normal breathing
NA
NA
9
Par didn't pierce use capsule for 2nd inhalation
NA
NA
1
3. Primary Outcome
Title Percentage of Participants With Atleast One Error After 28 Days of Inhaler Use in Each Treatment Phase (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical)
Description Primary estimand is the treatment effect estimated in participants who stayed on their randomised study device sequence and did not change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER, throughout both 28 day treatment periods. The participant could attend the visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. For primary estimand, a sensitivity analysis using Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included
Time Frame Up to Day 56

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
ITT Population. Only those participants with data available at specified time point were analyzed.
Arm/Group Title All Study Participants
Arm/Group Description Participants received placebo via ELLIPTA dry powder inhaler (DPI) or DISKUS DPI in combination with HandiHaler DPI based on the following treatment sequences: Treatment Sequence A (ELLIPTA in period 1 and DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 2, followed by PQ 1.); Treatment Sequence B (ELLIPTA in period 1 and DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 2, followed by PQ2); Treatment Sequence C (DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 1 and ELLIPTA in period 2, followed by PQ1); or Treatment Sequence D (DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 1 and ELLIPTA in period 2, followed by PQ2). Participants continued to take their own prescribed COPD medication and rescue medications for the entire 56-day study period. All participants on study received placebo only and participant flow reflects this as the only treatment.
Measure Participants 217
Atleast 1 error-ELLIPTA&0 errors-DISKUS+HandiHaler
3
1.3%
Atleast 1error-DISKUS+HandiHaler&0errors-ELLIPTA
23
9.6%
Statistical Analysis 1
Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection ELLIPTA
Comments
Type of Statistical Test Superiority
Comments
Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value <0.001
Comments
Method Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel
Comments Sensitivity Analyses (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical)
4. Secondary Outcome
Title Number of Errors Per Participant for Each Treatment Group After 28 Days of Use (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical)
Description Participants were provided with PIL explaining correct use of inhaler. Overall error includes both critical and non-critical errors. Primary estimand is the treatment effect estimated in participants who stayed on their randomised study device sequence and did not change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER, throughout both 28 day treatment periods. The participant could attend the visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. For primary estimand, a sensitivity analysis using Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included.
Time Frame Up to Day 56

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
ITT Population. Only those participants with data available at specified time point were analyzed.
Arm/Group Title ELLIPTA DISKUS + HandiHaler
Arm/Group Description Participants were randomized to use placebo via ELLIPTA in either period 1 or 2. Participants were randomized to use placebo via DISKUS + HANDIHALER in period 1 or 2.
Measure Participants 217 217
Median (Full Range) [Errors per participant]
0.0
0.6
5. Secondary Outcome
Title Change in Errors Per Participant for Each Treatment Group After 28 Days of Use
Description Assessment of errors was conducted by HCP trained in the correct inhaler use of the three inhalers based on the checklist of errors. The median number of overall errors made by per participant was assessed for ELLIPTA and DISKUS + HandiHaler both on Day 1 and Day 28 for each treatment group. The difference was calculated by subtracting values of Day 28 from Day1 for each treatment regimen. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included.
Time Frame Day 1 and Day 28 of each treatment group

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
ITT Population. Only those participants with data available at specified time point were analyzed.
Arm/Group Title ELLIPTA DISKUS + HandiHaler
Arm/Group Description Participants were randomized to use placebo via ELLIPTA in either period 1 or 2. Participants were randomized to use placebo via DISKUS + HANDIHALER in period 1 or 2.
Measure Participants 217 217
Median (Full Range) [Errors per participant]
0.0
0.0
6. Secondary Outcome
Title Number of Errors for Each Treatment Group in Participants With One or More Errors After 28 Days of Use (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical)
Description Participants were provided with the PIL, explaining correct use of the inhaler. Overall error includes both critical and non-critical errors. Assessment of errors was conducted by HCP trained in the correct inhaler use of the three inhalers based on the checklist of errors. Primary estimand is the treatment effect estimated in participants who stayed on their randomised study device sequence and did not change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER, throughout both 28 day treatment periods. The participant could attend the visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. For primary estimand, a sensitivity analysis using Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included.
Time Frame Up to Day 56

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
ITT Population. Only those participants with data available at specified time point were analyzed.
Arm/Group Title ELLIPTA DISKUS + HandiHaler
Arm/Group Description Participants were randomized to use placebo via ELLIPTA in either period 1 or 2. Participants were randomized to use placebo via DISKUS + HANDIHALER in period 1 or 2.
Measure Participants 217 217
Median (Full Range) [Errors per participant]
1.0
4.4
7. Secondary Outcome
Title Change in Errors for Each Treatment Group in Participants With One or More Errors After 28 Days of Use
Description Assessment of errors was conducted by health care professionals trained in the correct inhaler use of the three inhalers based on the checklist of errors. The median of overall errors made by each participant was assessed for ELLIPTA and DISKUS + HandiHaler both on Day 1 and Day 28. The difference was calculated by subtracting values of Day 28 from Day1 for each treatment regimen. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included.
Time Frame Day 1 and Day 28 of each treatment group

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
ITT Population. Only those participants with data available at specified time point were analyzed.
Arm/Group Title ELLIPTA DISKUS + HandiHaler
Arm/Group Description Participants were randomized to use placebo via ELLIPTA in either period 1 or 2. Participants were randomized to use placebo via DISKUS + HANDIHALER in period 1 or 2.
Measure Participants 217 217
Median (Full Range) [Errors per participant]
0.7
2.6
8. Secondary Outcome
Title Number of Participants With Zero Critical Errors After 28 Days of Each Treatment Group Use (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical)
Description A checklist for correct use of each inhaler was developed based on the steps identified in the PIL. A critical error was defined as an error that was most likely to result in no, or a significantly reduced amount, of medication being inhaled by the participant. Primary estimand is the treatment effect estimated in participants who stayed on their randomised study device sequence and did not change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER, throughout both 28 day treatment periods. The participant could attend the visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. For primary estimand, a sensitivity analysis using Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included.
Time Frame Up to Day 56

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
ITT Population. Only those participants with data available at specified time point were analyzed.
Arm/Group Title ELLIPTA DISKUS + HandiHaler
Arm/Group Description Participants were randomized to use placebo via ELLIPTA in either period 1 or 2. Participants were randomized to use placebo via DISKUS + HANDIHALER in period 1 or 2.
Measure Participants 217 217
Count of Participants [Participants]
215
90%
193
NaN
Statistical Analysis 1
Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection ELLIPTA, DISKUS + HANDIHALER
Comments
Type of Statistical Test Superiority
Comments
Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value <0.001
Comments
Method stratified exact logistic model
Comments
Method of Estimation Estimation Parameter Odds Ratio (OR)
Estimated Value 8.85
Confidence Interval (2-Sided) 95%
3.45 to
Parameter Dispersion Type:
Value:
Estimation Comments Participants included in the model as fixed strata, treatment option was included in the exact statement and period included as fixed effects.
9. Primary Outcome
Title Percentage of Participants With Atleast One Error After 28 Days of Inhaler Use in Each Treatment Phase (Supplementary Estimand: Composite)
Description Supplementary estimand estimated the composite effect of initial randomized treatment. A sensitivity analysis using the Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Participants who withdrew during period 2 were included in the analysis using early withdrawal data where available or imputation otherwise. Participants who experienced an intercurrent event in Period 1 were excluded from the analysis.
Time Frame Up to Day 56

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
[Not Specified]
Arm/Group Title All Study Participants
Arm/Group Description Participants received placebo via ELLIPTA dry powder inhaler (DPI) or DISKUS DPI in combination with HandiHaler DPI based on the following treatment sequences: Treatment Sequence A (ELLIPTA in period 1 and DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 2, followed by PQ 1.); Treatment Sequence B (ELLIPTA in period 1 and DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 2, followed by PQ2); Treatment Sequence C (DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 1 and ELLIPTA in period 2, followed by PQ1); or Treatment Sequence D (DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 1 and ELLIPTA in period 2, followed by PQ2). Participants continued to take their own prescribed COPD medication and rescue medications for the entire 56-day study period. All participants on study received placebo only and participant flow reflects this as the only treatment.
Measure Participants 224
Atleast 1 error-ELLIPTA&0 errors-DISKUS+HandiHaler
4
1.7%
Atleast 1error-DISKUS+HandiHaler&0errors-ELLIPTA
27
11.3%
Statistical Analysis 1
Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection ELLIPTA
Comments
Type of Statistical Test Superiority
Comments
Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value <0.001
Comments
Method Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel
Comments Sensitivity Analyses (Supplementary Estimand: Composite)
10. Secondary Outcome
Title Number of Participants With Atleast One Critical Error After 28 Days of Each Treatment Group Use (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical)
Description A critical error was defined as an error that was most likely to result in no, or a significantly reduced amount, of medication being inhaled by the participant. Primary estimand is the treatment effect estimated in participants who stayed on their randomised study device sequence and did not change their standard COPD maintenance medication device to one delivered via ELLIPTA, DISKUS or HANDIHALER, throughout both 28 day treatment periods. The participant could attend the visit without the device/s they were randomised to, in which case correct use cannot be assessed as described in the protocol. For primary estimand, a sensitivity analysis using Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Only those participants who completed error assessments for both randomized treatment groups and experienced no intercurrent events were included.
Time Frame Up to Day 56

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
ITT Population. Only those participants with data available at specified time point were analyzed.
Arm/Group Title All Study Participants
Arm/Group Description Participants received placebo via ELLIPTA dry powder inhaler (DPI) or DISKUS DPI in combination with HandiHaler DPI based on the following treatment sequences: Treatment Sequence A (ELLIPTA in period 1 and DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 2, followed by PQ 1.); Treatment Sequence B (ELLIPTA in period 1 and DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 2, followed by PQ2); Treatment Sequence C (DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 1 and ELLIPTA in period 2, followed by PQ1); or Treatment Sequence D (DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 1 and ELLIPTA in period 2, followed by PQ2). Participants continued to take their own prescribed COPD medication and rescue medications for the entire 56-day study period. All participants on study received placebo only and participant flow reflects this as the only treatment.
Measure Participants 217
Atleast 1 critical error with ELLIPTA
1
0.4%
Atleast 1 critical error with DISKUS+HandiHaler
23
9.6%
Statistical Analysis 1
Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection ELLIPTA
Comments
Type of Statistical Test Superiority
Comments
Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value <0.001
Comments
Method Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel
Comments Sensitivity Analyses (Primary Estimand: Hypothetical)
11. Secondary Outcome
Title Number of Participants With Atleast One Critical Error After 28 Days of Each Treatment Group Use (Supplementary Estimand: Composite)
Description Supplementary estimand estimated the composite effect of initial randomized treatment. A sensitivity analysis using the Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test was performed on participants with discordant results. Participants who withdrew during period 2 were included in the analysis using early withdrawal data where available or imputation otherwise. Participants who experienced an intercurrent event in Period 1 were excluded from the analysis.
Time Frame Up to Day 56

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
ITT Population. Only those participants with data available at specified time point were analyzed.
Arm/Group Title All Study Participants
Arm/Group Description Participants received placebo via ELLIPTA dry powder inhaler (DPI) or DISKUS DPI in combination with HandiHaler DPI based on the following treatment sequences: Treatment Sequence A (ELLIPTA in period 1 and DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 2, followed by PQ 1.); Treatment Sequence B (ELLIPTA in period 1 and DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 2, followed by PQ2); Treatment Sequence C (DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 1 and ELLIPTA in period 2, followed by PQ1); or Treatment Sequence D (DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 1 and ELLIPTA in period 2, followed by PQ2). Participants continued to take their own prescribed COPD medication and rescue medications for the entire 56-day study period. All participants on study received placebo only and participant flow reflects this as the only treatment.
Measure Participants 217
Atleast 1 error-ELLIPTA&0 errors-DISKUS+HandiHaler
3
1.3%
Atleast 1error-DISKUS+HandiHaler&0errors-ELLIPTA
27
11.3%
Statistical Analysis 1
Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection ELLIPTA
Comments
Type of Statistical Test Superiority
Comments
Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value <0.001
Comments
Method Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel
Comments Sensitivity Analyses (Supplementary Composite Estimand)
12. Primary Outcome
Title Percentage of Participants With Zero Errors After 28 Days of Inhaler Use in Each Treatment Phase(Supplementary Estimand: Composite)
Description Supplementary estimand estimated the composite effect of initial randomized treatment. The analysis was performed using stratified exact logistic model. Participants were included in the model as fixed strata, treatment option was included in the exact statement and period included as fixed effects. Participants who withdrew during period 2 were included in the analysis using early withdrawal data where available or imputation otherwise. Participants who experienced an intercurrent event in Period 1 were excluded from the analysis.
Time Frame Up to Day 56

Outcome Measure Data

Analysis Population Description
ITT Population. Only those participants with data available at specified time point were analyzed.
Arm/Group Title ELLIPTA DISKUS + HandiHaler
Arm/Group Description Participants were randomized to use placebo via ELLIPTA in either period 1 or 2. Participants were randomized to use placebo via DISKUS + HANDIHALER in period 1 or 2.
Measure Participants 224 224
Number [Percentage of participants]
95
39.7%
85
NaN
Statistical Analysis 1
Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection ELLIPTA, DISKUS + HANDIHALER
Comments
Type of Statistical Test Superiority
Comments
Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value <0.001
Comments
Method stratified exact logistic model
Comments
Method of Estimation Estimation Parameter Odds Ratio (OR)
Estimated Value 6.06
Confidence Interval (2-Sided) 95%
2.08 to 24.55
Parameter Dispersion Type:
Value:
Estimation Comments Participants included in the model as fixed strata, treatment option was included in the exact statement and period included as fixed effects.

Adverse Events

Time Frame Up to Day 56
Adverse Event Reporting Description Intent-to-Treat Population was used to collect Adverse Events. Since all participants received placebo as treatment, data has been clubbed for all the arms. The non-serious AEs are reported using a frequency threshold of >5%
Arm/Group Title All Study Participants
Arm/Group Description Participants received placebo via ELLIPTA dry powder inhaler (DPI) or DISKUS DPI in combination with HandiHaler DPI based on the following treatment sequences: Treatment Sequence A (ELLIPTA in period 1 and DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 2, followed by PQ 1.); Treatment Sequence B (ELLIPTA in period 1 and DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 2, followed by PQ2); Treatment Sequence C (DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 1 and ELLIPTA in period 2, followed by PQ1); or Treatment Sequence D (DISKUS + HandiHaler in period 1 and ELLIPTA in period 2, followed by PQ2). Participants continued to take their own prescribed COPD medication and rescue medications for the entire 56-day study period.
All Cause Mortality
All Study Participants
Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
Total 0/239 (0%)
Serious Adverse Events
All Study Participants
Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
Total 10/239 (4.2%)
Cardiac disorders
Cardiac failure congestive 1/239 (0.4%) 1
General disorders
Chest pain 1/239 (0.4%) 1
Infections and infestations
Pneumonia 3/239 (1.3%) 3
Bronchitis 1/239 (0.4%) 1
Metabolism and nutrition disorders
Hyponatraemia 1/239 (0.4%) 1
Nervous system disorders
Dysarthria 1/239 (0.4%) 1
Hemiparesis 1/239 (0.4%) 1
Respiratory, thoracic and mediastinal disorders
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease 5/239 (2.1%) 5
Acute respiratory failure 2/239 (0.8%) 2
Pneumonia aspiration 1/239 (0.4%) 1
Other (Not Including Serious) Adverse Events
All Study Participants
Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
Total 0/239 (0%)

Limitations/Caveats

[Not Specified]

More Information

Certain Agreements

Principal Investigators are NOT employed by the organization sponsoring the study.

GSK agreements may vary with individual investigators, but will not prohibit any investigator from publishing. GSK supports the publication of results from all centers of a multi-center trial but requests that reports based on single-site data not precede the primary publication of the entire clinical trial.

Results Point of Contact

Name/Title GSK Response Center
Organization GlaxoSmithKline
Phone 866-435-7343
Email GSKClinicalSupportHD@gsk.com
Responsible Party:
GlaxoSmithKline
ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier:
NCT03227445
Other Study ID Numbers:
  • 206901
First Posted:
Jul 24, 2017
Last Update Posted:
Jul 8, 2020
Last Verified:
Jun 1, 2020