ECOSTRESS: Effects of Relaxing Breathing With Biofeedback or Meditative Stimulation on Performances During OSCE of Medical Students
Study Details
Study Description
Brief Summary
Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) is a newly implemented evaluation standard for medical student and is a determinant part of the national competition they have to undergo.
Medical studies, especially during examen period, are significantly associated with risk of developping depressions or anxious trouble, wich led to lesser performance, impaired memorization and impaired workload capacities.
Relaxation breathing techniques coupled with heart rate variability (HRV) biofeedback and meditation are procedures used to reduce the stress level.
There is currently no study on the effect of stress management procedures on the performance during OSCE for medical student.
| Condition or Disease | Intervention/Treatment | Phase |
|---|---|---|
|
N/A |
Detailed Description
This randomized, controlled, monocentric study will take place during mandatory rehearsal of Objective Structured Clinical Examination for third year medical student. For examination purpose, the students will be divided in four groups that will undergo identical exam in the same time in four parallels circuits.
Before entering the circuit, all the students will received information for the study and sign consent.
All the students will be equipped with emWAve® devices that allows us to collect heart rate variability as physiological stress marker during the time of the intervention. Participants will undergo short questionnaires regarding perceived stress.
Then the groups of students will be randomized in four interventions groups for receiving a combination of intervention before and/or after the examination circuit. All the interventions last six minutes long. The randomisation groups are :
-
Relaxing breathing exercise coupled with biofeedback before the circuit, no intervention after
-
Meditative stimulation audio tape before the circuit, no intervention after
-
Standardised video as controlled group before the circuit and a relaxing breathing exercise coupled with biofeedback after
-
Standardised video as controlled group before and not intervention after
At the end of the examination circuit, all the students will undergo short questionnaires regarding stress, participants will get equipped with emWAve ® devices again and participants will get the second intervention depending on the randomisation group.
Main objective is to show that relaxing breathing exercise coupled with biofeedback or meditative stimulation is better than an standardised video on performance during OSCE.
The main outcome is student grade at the exam, as determined by university evaluator who is blind to the intervention and with no links to the study.
Secondary objectives are to compare the effects of the interventions on measured physiological stress, psychological stress, and negative rumination.
Study Design
Arms and Interventions
| Arm | Intervention/Treatment |
|---|---|
| Experimental: Biofeedback Relaxing breathing exercise coupled with biofeedback before the circuit, no intervention after |
Other: Biofeedback
6 minutes of relaxing breathing exercise coupled with hert rate variability biofeedback guided on eMWave Pro software on a computer just before entering the examination circuit.
After the circuit, 6 minutes of free activity where the participants will not be given any instruction.
Other Names:
|
| Experimental: Meditation Meditative stimulation audio tape before the circuit, no intervention after |
Other: Meditation
6 minutes of listening an audio tape made for the study that inspire mindfulness like meditation associated with psychological stimulation (positive encouragement) just before entering the examination circuit.
After the circuit, 6 minutes of free activity where the participants will not be given any instructions.
Other Names:
|
| Experimental: Control and biofeedback post OSCE Standardised video before the circuit, Relaxing breathing exercise coupled with biofeedback after the OSCE |
Other: Control and biofeedback post OSCE
6 minutes of standardised neutral video on general topics that generates no modification of affects just before entering the examination circuit.
After the circuit, 6 minutes of relaxing breathing exercise coupled with hert rate variability biofeedback guided on eMWave Pro software on a computer
Other Names:
|
| Sham Comparator: Control and control post OSCE Standardised video before the circuit, no intervention after |
Other: Control and control post OSCE
6 minutes of standardised neutral video on general topics that generates no modification of affects just before entering the examination circuit.
After the circuit, 6 minutes of of free activity where the participants will not be given any instruction.
Other Names:
|
Outcome Measures
Primary Outcome Measures
- Differences in Performance [During the first 2 hours of the inclusion]
The performance is student grade at the exam, as determined by university evaluator
Secondary Outcome Measures
- Differences of Physiological stress [During the first 2 hours of the inclusion]
Heart rate variation collected by emWave® devices
- Differences of Psychological stress [Four times : before first intervention, before OSCE circuit, just after OSCE circuit, just after second intervention]
Numerical Visual analog scales (VAS) on perceived stress from zero to 100: maximum Numerical VAS on resourcefulness nedeed an avalaible perceived from zero to maximum
- Difference of Resourcefulness [Four times : before first intervention, before OSCE circuit, just after OSCE circuit, just after second intervention]
Numerical VAS on resourcefulness needeed an available perceived from zero to 100: maximum
- Characterisation of stress [Four times : before first intervention, before OSCE circuit, just after OSCE circuit, just after second intervention]
Numerical VAS on characterisation of stress perceived from negative to positive
- Differences of Self confidence [Four times : before first intervention, before OSCE circuit, just after OSCE circuit, just after second intervention]
Numerical VAS on self confidence perceived from zero to 100: maximum
- Differences of Psychological stress consequences [Three times : before first intervention, before OSCE circuit, just after second intervention]
Activation-Deactivation Adjective Check List: for the four subscales: Energy, Tiredness, Tension , and Calmness
- Differences of Ruminations [Just after second intervention at the end of the OSCE]
Brief rumination scale questionnaire
- Individual psychological characteristics [Just after second intervention at the end of the OSCE]
Personality traits (Big-5)
Eligibility Criteria
Criteria
Inclusion Criteria:
-
Adult person
-
Registered as medical student at the university
-
Participating at OSCE examination
-
Have signed an informed consent form.
Exclusion Criteria:
- None
Contacts and Locations
Locations
No locations specified.Sponsors and Collaborators
- Claude Bernard University
Investigators
- Study Chair: Gilles Rode, M.D., Ph.D., Claude Bernard University
Study Documents (Full-Text)
None provided.More Information
Publications
None provided.- ECOSTRESS