Silodosin Versus Tamsulosin for Treatment of Ureteral Stones
Study Details
Study Description
Brief Summary
Ureteral calculi, commonly known as kidney stones, are a frequent cause of Emergency Department (ED) visits. These stones can get caught in the ureter (the tube connecting the kidney to the bladder) and cause symptoms including pain, nausea, and vomiting. As long as the obstructing stone meets certain conditions and the patient isn't too sick, the patient is usually sent home to try and pass the stone without surgery. This treatment is known as medical expulsive therapy (MET), and routinely involves the use of a drug called tamsulosin, which relaxes the smooth muscle of the urinary system to help the stone pass. Silodosin is a drug in the same class of tamsulosin, but which is thought to have a more selective action and a quicker onset, which would theoretically make it better for aiding in kidney stone passage. The purpose of this study is a head-to-head, blinded comparison of these two drugs to see how quickly they result in stone passage. Subjects are patients presenting to the ED with acute kidney stone shown by CT scan, and who are appropriate for MET. The main study intervention is randomization to receiving either tamsulosin or silodosin. The hypothesis is that silodosin will have decreased time to stone passage compared to tamsulosin.
Subjects who qualify and consent are randomized to a two-week course of either silodosin or tamsulosin. They are also given prescriptions for standard of care medications for pain and nausea, as well as a pain diary. They receive a follow-up phone call after one week to remind them of their follow-up appointment, ask about adverse events, and determine if their stone has passed. They have a follow-up visit with study staff at the end of their two week treatment to collect their pain diary, pill count, adverse events, and to determine if their stone has passed. Study participation ends after this follow-up visit.
Condition or Disease | Intervention/Treatment | Phase |
---|---|---|
Phase 4 |
Detailed Description
Procedures Involved in the Research. This study is a prospective, randomized, double-blinded, head-to-head trial comparing two medications. Patients with symptoms of renal colic who present to the emergency department will be evaluated by the ED staff as per usual routine. After a work-up (including routine chemistry, complete blood count, urine analysis, urine culture, and non-contrast CT scan of the abdomen and pelvis) has been completed, patients who meet inclusion criteria will be asked whether they are willing to enroll in the study. Those who are unsuitable for the study or unwilling to participate will continue to receive routine care for their ureteral calculus. Those who consent will be enrolled as subjects in the study, and given a 2-week supply of either tamsulosin or silodosin in blinded bottles with the appropriate dosing instructions. The prescriptions will be dispensed by the pharmacy; therefore the subjects and study staff will be blinded to which prescription the subject receives. Randomization will be done in advance and a key made to correlate subject enrollment number with which prescription they have received. Throughout the study, the study staff will make no efforts to ascertain which medication the subject has been given, unless an adverse event is suspected. Each participant will be given an information card that details the two possible medications they are taking, which can be presented to their physicians as needed.
Subjects will then be discharged to home as per routine care with instructions to drink plenty of fluids, and will be given a strainer and asked to attempt to catch their ureteral calculus. They will also be given a standardized prescription analgesic package (Percocet 5/325mg #20, Motrin 600mg #60, Zofran OD 4mg #20 with standard dosing instructions) and a Visual Analog Pain Scale diary to be filled out daily. Subjects will be given standardized discharge instructions as per standard of care that will include indications for immediate ED return for signs and symptoms of infection or MET failure (fever, worsening pain, vomiting, lethargy, unsteadiness, syncope or inability to tolerate oral pain medications). As per standard of care, they will be instructed to return to the ER immediately if they develop any of these symptoms. Finally, the subject's contact information will be collected at the time of enrollment and a follow-up appointment will be scheduled for them with Urology in 4 weeks to ensure they get appropriate and timely specialty follow-up. This follow-up is also standard of care, and will occur after the subject's participation in the study ends.
Each subject will be scheduled to return to the ER in 2 weeks to be seen by the research staff for data collection. They will be asked to bring their pill bottle and visual analog pain scale diary to this visit. If the subject reports having passed a stone consistent with their initial imaging, or have resolution of their pain to suggest they passed the stone unseen, this will conclude their participation in the study. However, if they are still having symptoms, their case will be categorized as an outpatient treatment failure and the subject will be registered to be seen by an ER Physician and a Urology consult will be ordered, concluding their participation in the study. This is current standard of care, and will be covered by insurance. Any subject that has an unscheduled visit to an ER for a ureterolithiasis-related complaint will also be considered an outpatient treatment failure. This will also conclude their participation in this study.
To ensure follow-up, subjects will be called one week after enrollment. They will be reminded of their 2-week follow-up appointment and the need to bring in their pill bottles. Each subject will also be asked if they have passed the stone or had resolution of the pain. The will be reminded that they must follow-up even if they are no longer having symptoms.
Study Design
Arms and Interventions
Arm | Intervention/Treatment |
---|---|
Active Comparator: Silodosin Subjects in the Silodosin Group will be given silodosin 8 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. |
Drug: Silodosin
8mg tablet, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks
Other Names:
|
Active Comparator: Tamsulosin Subjects in the Tamsulosin Group will be given tamsulosin 0.4 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. |
Drug: Tamsulosin
0.4 mg Tab, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks
Other Names:
|
Outcome Measures
Primary Outcome Measures
- Time to Stone Passage [at 2 weeks]
The primary outcome measure will be the time it takes for the stone to pass. Stone passage will be defined as the subject self-reporting passage of a stone that is consistent with their imaging, or resolution of their pain to suggest unseen passage of their stone. This outcome will be measured from the initial emergency department visit, and gathered at the one-week follow-up call as well as the two-week follow-up visit.
Secondary Outcome Measures
- Use of Pain Medication [at 2 weeks]
The subject will be given a standardized pain medication prescription at their initial visit, and will be asked to keep track of how much pain medication they used each day, as well as to bring their pill bottle with them to the two-week follow-up appointment for a pill count. This information will be collected at the two-week follow-up appointment.
- Outpatient Treatment Failure [at 2 weeks]
Subjects will be given instructions at the initial visit to return to the emergency department immediately for signs and symptoms of infection or MET failure (fever, worsening pain, vomiting, lethargy, unsteadiness, syncope or inability to tolerate oral pain medications). These subjects will be considered to have failed outpatient treatment and will be removed from the study. Subjects who do not experience these issues but who still report having symptoms at the two-week follow-up visit will also be considered to have failed outpatient treatment.
- Adverse Hemodynamic Reaction [at 2 weeks]
Both tamsulosin and silodosin carry the possibility of causing orthostatic hypotension, which can manifest as unsteadiness, syncope, headache, and/or dizziness, especially when changing position from sitting/laying to standing. Subjects will be asked to assess themselves for these symptoms continuously from the initial visit, with serious reactions resulting in cessation of study medication. For reactions which are not serious, the information will be collected at the one-week follow-up call as well as the two-week follow-up visit.
Eligibility Criteria
Criteria
Inclusion Criteria:
-
Adults age 18 to 70 years
-
Non-diabetic
-
Unilateral ureteral calculus 4 to 10 mm visible on CT scan within the ureter
-
Serum creatinine level within normal range
-
Ability to tolerate oral fluids and oral pain medication
-
Ability to make informed medical decisions regarding consent
-
Willingness to follow up in the ER in two weeks
Exclusion Criteria:
-
Adults unable to consent
-
Age <18
-
Signs of infection including Temperature >38º C or Urinalysis with any of the following: Positive Leukocyte Esterase, Positive Nitrates, or White Blood Cell Count
5/hfp in the setting of a positive urine culture (defined as a single isolated bacterial species population of >100,000 CFU)
-
Patients with chronic pain already undergoing treatment with narcotic medications
-
Patients already taking an alpha adrenergic antagonist medication
-
Pregnant women
-
Prisoners
-
No working phone number
Contacts and Locations
Locations
Site | City | State | Country | Postal Code | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Einstein Medical Center Philadelphia | Philadelphia | Pennsylvania | United States | 19141 |
Sponsors and Collaborators
- Albert Einstein Healthcare Network
Investigators
- Principal Investigator: William Boroughf, DO, Einstein Healthcare Network
- Principal Investigator: James Gardner, MD, Einstein Healthcare Network
Study Documents (Full-Text)
None provided.More Information
Publications
- H Lepor et al. Double-Blind, Randomized, Parallel-Group Study To Define Electrocardiographic Effects Of Silodosin. Journal of Urology 179(4), May 2008
- Hermanns T, Sauermann P, Rufibach K, Frauenfelder T, Sulser T, Strebel RT. Is there a role for tamsulosin in the treatment of distal ureteral stones of 7 mm or less? Results of a randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. Eur Urol. 2009 Sep;56(3):407-12. doi: 10.1016/j.eururo.2009.03.076. Epub 2009 Apr 3.
- Hollingsworth JM, Rogers MA, Kaufman SR, Bradford TJ, Saint S, Wei JT, Hollenbeck BK. Medical therapy to facilitate urinary stone passage: a meta-analysis. Lancet. 2006 Sep 30;368(9542):1171-9. Review.
- Kobayashi S, Tomiyama Y, Hoyano Y, Yamazaki Y, Sasaki S, Kohri K. Effects of silodosin and naftopidil on the distal ureter and cardiovascular system in anesthetized dogs: comparison of potential medications for distal ureteral stone passage. J Urol. 2010 Jan;183(1):357-61. doi: 10.1016/j.juro.2009.08.106.
- Parsons JK, Hergan LA, Sakamoto K, Lakin C. Efficacy of alpha-blockers for the treatment of ureteral stones. J Urol. 2007 Mar;177(3):983-7; discussion 987.
- Pedro RN, Hinck B, Hendlin K, Feia K, Canales BK, Monga M. Alfuzosin stone expulsion therapy for distal ureteral calculi: a double-blind, placebo controlled study. J Urol. 2008 Jun;179(6):2244-7; discussion 2247. doi: 10.1016/j.juro.2008.01.141. Epub 2008 Apr 18.
- Preminger GM, Tiselius HG, Assimos DG, Alken P, Buck AC, Gallucci M, Knoll T, Lingeman JE, Nakada SY, Pearle MS, Sarica K, Türk C, Wolf JS Jr; American Urological Association Education and Research, Inc; European Association of Urology. 2007 Guideline for the management of ureteral calculi. Eur Urol. 2007 Dec;52(6):1610-31.
- Steinberg PL. Re: Karim Bensalah, Margaret Pearle and Yair Lotan. Cost-effectiveness of medical expulsive therapy using alpha-blockers for the treatment of distal ureteral stones. Eur urol 2008;53:411-9. Eur Urol. 2008 Aug;54(2):469; author reply 469. doi: 10.1016/j.eururo.2008.01.077. Epub 2008 Feb 4.
- HN 4441
Study Results
Participant Flow
Recruitment Details | 0 Participants analyzed. PI has left the institution. Efforts made to contact the PI were unsuccessful. No study data available |
---|---|
Pre-assignment Detail | 0 Participants analyzed. PI has left the institution. Efforts made to contact the PI were unsuccessful. No study data available |
Arm/Group Title | Silodosin | Tamsulosin |
---|---|---|
Arm/Group Description | Subjects in the Silodosin Group will be given silodosin 8 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. Silodosin: 8mg tablet, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks | Subjects in the Tamsulosin Group will be given tamsulosin 0.4 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. Tamsulosin: 0.4 mg Tab, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks |
Period Title: Overall Study | ||
STARTED | 0 | 0 |
COMPLETED | 0 | 0 |
NOT COMPLETED | 0 | 0 |
Baseline Characteristics
Arm/Group Title | Silodosin | Tamsulosin | Total |
---|---|---|---|
Arm/Group Description | Subjects in the Silodosin Group will be given silodosin 8 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. Silodosin: 8mg tablet, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks | Subjects in the Tamsulosin Group will be given tamsulosin 0.4 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. Tamsulosin: 0.4 mg Tab, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks | Total of all reporting groups |
Overall Participants | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Age () [] | |||
<=18 years | |||
Between 18 and 65 years | |||
>=65 years | |||
Age () [] | |||
Sex: Female, Male () [] | |||
Female | |||
Male | |||
Region of Enrollment (participants) [] |
Outcome Measures
Title | Time to Stone Passage |
---|---|
Description | The primary outcome measure will be the time it takes for the stone to pass. Stone passage will be defined as the subject self-reporting passage of a stone that is consistent with their imaging, or resolution of their pain to suggest unseen passage of their stone. This outcome will be measured from the initial emergency department visit, and gathered at the one-week follow-up call as well as the two-week follow-up visit. |
Time Frame | at 2 weeks |
Outcome Measure Data
Analysis Population Description |
---|
Data is not available |
Arm/Group Title | Silodosin | Tamsulosin |
---|---|---|
Arm/Group Description | Subjects in the Silodosin Group will be given silodosin 8 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. Silodosin: 8mg tablet, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks | Subjects in the Tamsulosin Group will be given tamsulosin 0.4 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. Tamsulosin: 0.4 mg Tab, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks |
Measure Participants | 0 | 0 |
Title | Use of Pain Medication |
---|---|
Description | The subject will be given a standardized pain medication prescription at their initial visit, and will be asked to keep track of how much pain medication they used each day, as well as to bring their pill bottle with them to the two-week follow-up appointment for a pill count. This information will be collected at the two-week follow-up appointment. |
Time Frame | at 2 weeks |
Outcome Measure Data
Analysis Population Description |
---|
Data is not available |
Arm/Group Title | Silodosin | Tamsulosin |
---|---|---|
Arm/Group Description | Subjects in the Silodosin Group will be given silodosin 8 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. Silodosin: 8mg tablet, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks | Subjects in the Tamsulosin Group will be given tamsulosin 0.4 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. Tamsulosin: 0.4 mg Tab, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks |
Measure Participants | 0 | 0 |
Title | Outpatient Treatment Failure |
---|---|
Description | Subjects will be given instructions at the initial visit to return to the emergency department immediately for signs and symptoms of infection or MET failure (fever, worsening pain, vomiting, lethargy, unsteadiness, syncope or inability to tolerate oral pain medications). These subjects will be considered to have failed outpatient treatment and will be removed from the study. Subjects who do not experience these issues but who still report having symptoms at the two-week follow-up visit will also be considered to have failed outpatient treatment. |
Time Frame | at 2 weeks |
Outcome Measure Data
Analysis Population Description |
---|
Data is not available |
Arm/Group Title | Silodosin | Tamsulosin |
---|---|---|
Arm/Group Description | Subjects in the Silodosin Group will be given silodosin 8 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. Silodosin: 8mg tablet, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks | Subjects in the Tamsulosin Group will be given tamsulosin 0.4 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. Tamsulosin: 0.4 mg Tab, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks |
Measure Participants | 0 | 0 |
Title | Adverse Hemodynamic Reaction |
---|---|
Description | Both tamsulosin and silodosin carry the possibility of causing orthostatic hypotension, which can manifest as unsteadiness, syncope, headache, and/or dizziness, especially when changing position from sitting/laying to standing. Subjects will be asked to assess themselves for these symptoms continuously from the initial visit, with serious reactions resulting in cessation of study medication. For reactions which are not serious, the information will be collected at the one-week follow-up call as well as the two-week follow-up visit. |
Time Frame | at 2 weeks |
Outcome Measure Data
Analysis Population Description |
---|
Data is not available |
Arm/Group Title | Silodosin | Tamsulosin |
---|---|---|
Arm/Group Description | Subjects in the Silodosin Group will be given silodosin 8 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. Silodosin: 8mg tablet, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks | Subjects in the Tamsulosin Group will be given tamsulosin 0.4 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. Tamsulosin: 0.4 mg Tab, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks |
Measure Participants | 0 | 0 |
Adverse Events
Time Frame | 0 | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Adverse Event Reporting Description | Data is not available: PI no longer at institution; attempts to contact unsuccessful | |||
Arm/Group Title | Silodosin | Tamsulosin | ||
Arm/Group Description | Subjects in the Silodosin Group will be given silodosin 8 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. Silodosin: 8mg tablet, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks | Subjects in the Tamsulosin Group will be given tamsulosin 0.4 mg tablets, one tablet to be taken PO each day for two weeks. Tamsulosin: 0.4 mg Tab, 1 tab PO daily for 2 weeks | ||
All Cause Mortality |
||||
Silodosin | Tamsulosin | |||
Affected / at Risk (%) | # Events | Affected / at Risk (%) | # Events | |
Total | 0/0 (NaN) | 0/0 (NaN) | ||
Serious Adverse Events |
||||
Silodosin | Tamsulosin | |||
Affected / at Risk (%) | # Events | Affected / at Risk (%) | # Events | |
Total | 0/0 (NaN) | 0/0 (NaN) | ||
Other (Not Including Serious) Adverse Events |
||||
Silodosin | Tamsulosin | |||
Affected / at Risk (%) | # Events | Affected / at Risk (%) | # Events | |
Total | 0/0 (NaN) | 0/0 (NaN) |
Limitations/Caveats
More Information
Certain Agreements
All Principal Investigators ARE employed by the organization sponsoring the study.
There is NOT an agreement between Principal Investigators and the Sponsor (or its agents) that restricts the PI's rights to discuss or publish trial results after the trial is completed.
Results Point of Contact
Name/Title | Kamran Mohiuddin; Director ED Clinical Research |
---|---|
Organization | Albert Einstein Medical Center |
Phone | 2154562313 |
MOHIUDDK@EISNTEIN.EDU |
- HN 4441