Hyp-hOP: Brain-Centered Therapy Versus Medication for Urgency Urinary Incontinence : Hypnotherapy Or Pharmacotherapy

Sponsor
University of New Mexico (Other)
Overall Status
Completed
CT.gov ID
NCT01829425
Collaborator
National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) (NIH)
165
1
2
54.2
3

Study Details

Study Description

Brief Summary

This study is randomized controlled trial in which urgency incontinent women (approximately 150-160) will be randomized to hypnotherapy or pharmacotherapy and evaluated at months 2, 6 &12 Hypotheses: Among patients with urgency urinary incontinence (UUI), hypnotherapy will be non-inferior pharmacotherapy in diminishing UUI episodes. Hypnotherapy may be superior or may not differ from pharmacotherapy in diminishing symptoms or quality of life based on validated questionnaires and/or other diary parameters.

Condition or Disease Intervention/Treatment Phase
  • Drug: Anticholinergic medications
  • Behavioral: Hypnotherapy
N/A

Detailed Description

Study Objectives Primary: To compare change in Urgency Urinary Incontinence (UUI) episodes at 2 month follow-up on voiding diaries between hypnotherapy and pharmacotherapy groups (to determine whether hypnotherapy is at least as effective and durable in treating UUI as pharmacotherapy)

Secondary Analyses:
  • To determine whether hypnotherapy is at least as effective in treating UUI as pharmacotherapy comparing change in UUI episodes on voiding diary at 6 and 12 month follow-up

  • To determine whether hypnotherapy differs from pharmacotherapy in treating UUI comparing change in questionnaire results and urinary frequency

  • enrolled following administration of the Overactive Bladder (OAB) Awareness tool. Participants will keep voiding diaries then be randomized to either pharmacotherapy and conventional behavioral therapy or hypnotherapy and conventional behavioral therapy. Approximately 150-160 women will be randomized.

Randomization will occur using a computer-generated randomization scheme in varying permuted block sizes. Study personnel performing data entry will be masked to participants' treatment. Masking participants to treatment is not feasible. Participants will be followed at 2,6 & 12 months. Measurements will be performed before treatment, following completion of treatment visits (approximately 8 weeks), and at 6 and 12 months. Primary analysis will be intention to treat. Exploratory analyses of secondary outcomes will also be performed.

Study Visits: UUI participant screening: Study information given. Screening questionnaire given. Visit 1 Enrollment: Formal screening for eligibility, voiding diary reviewed, if eligible, written consent obtained with administration of study questionnaires, demographic and past medical history administration forms, Pelvic Organ Prolapse Quantitation (POP-Q) exam & hypnotic susceptibility testing scheduled. Pariticipants undergo hypnotic susceptibility testing prior to randomization. Participants randomized to treatment and contacted, treatments arranged. Hypnotherapy group: undergo weekly treatments over 8 weeks. Pharmacotherapy group: weekly counseling sessions over 8 week: Following hypnotherapy or medication counseling completion, f/u voiding diaries collected & study questionnaires administered. One of two long acting anti-cholinergic medications offered (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin or equivalent generic substitutes).

6 & 12 month follow-up: Pharmacotherapy subjects receive medications for 1 year and Hypnotherapy subjects encouraged to continue self-hypnosis for 1 year with assistance of audio-recordings, with 1 optional hypnotherapy session between 6-12 months..

Participants informed pharmacotherapy & hypnotherapy sessions are audio-recorded and reviewed ensuring manual of procedures are followed.

Study Design

Study Type:
Interventional
Actual Enrollment :
165 participants
Allocation:
Randomized
Intervention Model:
Parallel Assignment
Masking:
Single (Investigator)
Primary Purpose:
Treatment
Official Title:
Protocol for Brain-Centered Therapy Versus Medication for Urgency Urinary Incontinence An RCT: Hypnotherapy Or Pharmacotherapy
Actual Study Start Date :
Apr 22, 2013
Actual Primary Completion Date :
Oct 27, 2017
Actual Study Completion Date :
Oct 27, 2017

Arms and Interventions

Arm Intervention/Treatment
Active Comparator: Anticholinergic medications

Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year.

Drug: Anticholinergic medications
The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year.
Other Names:
  • Tolterodine (Detrol LA or equivalent generic)
  • Oxybutynin (Ditropan Extended Release or equivalent generic)
  • Active Comparator: Hypnotherapy

    Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year.

    Behavioral: Hypnotherapy
    Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study.

    Outcome Measures

    Primary Outcome Measures

    1. Percent Change in Urgency Urinary Incontinence Episodes [Baseline and 2 month follow-up]

      Percent change in UUI episodes from baseline to 2 months with comparison made between hypnotherapy & pharmacotherapy

    Secondary Outcome Measures

    1. Percent Change in Urgency Urinary Incontinence Episodes [6 months]

      Differences comparing hypnotherapy to pharmacotherapy percent change in median UUI episodes

    2. Percent Change in Urgency Urinary Incontinence Episodes [12 months]

      Percent change in median UUI episodes from baseline to 12 months with comparison made between hypnotherapy & pharmacotherapy

    3. Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form Symptom Bother [2 months]

      Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form symptom bother Scale. Sub-Scale range 0-100. Higher numbers are worse (more bother) and lower numbers are better (less bother)

    4. Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form Symptom Bother [6 months]

      Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form symptom bother. Sub-scale range 0-100. Higher numbers are worse (more bother) and lower numbers are better (less bother)

    5. Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form Symptom Bother [12 months]

      Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form symptom bother. Sub-scale range 0-100. Higher numbers are worse (more bother) and lower numbers are better (less bother)

    6. Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form Quality of Life [2 months]

      Overactive Bladder questionnaire-Short Form Quality of Life. Higher scores are better (better quality of life) and lower scores are worse (poorer quality of life). sub-score range 0-100.

    7. Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form Quality of Life [6 months]

      Overactive Bladder questionnaire Short Form Quality of Life. Higher scores are better (better quality of life) and lower scores are worse (poorer quality of life). sub-scale score range 0-100.

    8. Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form Quality of Life [12 months]

      Overactive Bladder questionnaire-Short Form Quality of Life. Higher scores are better (higher quality of life) and lower scores are worse (poorer quality of life). score range 0-100.

    9. Voids on Bladder Diary [2 months]

      Total Number of voids on 3-day bladder diary.

    10. Voids on Bladder Diary [6 months]

      number of voids on 3-day bladder diary

    11. Voids on Bladder Diary [12 months]

      number of voids on 3-day bladder diary

    Eligibility Criteria

    Criteria

    Ages Eligible for Study:
    18 Years and Older
    Sexes Eligible for Study:
    Female
    Accepts Healthy Volunteers:
    Yes

    Inclusion Criteria:(For randomized trial)

    1. Non-pregnant English-speaking women

    2. 18 yo or older

    3. Overactive Bladder (OAB) Awareness scores ≥ 8

    4. 3 UUI episodes/week for ≥ 3 months

    Exclusion Criteria: (For Randomized trial)

    1. Women with a history of neurologic diseases such as Multiple Sclerosis, Parkinson's disease, stroke, or dementia

    2. History of schizophrenia or untreated bipolar disorder or current drug or alcohol dependence

    3. Women who have taken anticholinergic medications for UUI within the last 3 weeks (women who have taken anti-cholinergics for UUI but discontinued them > than 3 weeks ago may participate in the study) or have a sacral neuromodulator in place to treat UUI or have received Onabotulinum toxin A in the last 12 months to treat UUI

    4. Contraindications to anticholinergic medications (untreated narrow angle glaucoma, significant urinary retention or gastric retention)

    5. Pregnant women or lactating women, women who plan to become pregnant in the next year, or pre-menopausal women unwilling to use contraception if engaging in sexual relations during the year of study participation (hysterectomy is considered to be a form of contraception)

    6. Untreated urinary tract infection

    7. Prolapse which extends past the hymen (POP-Q points of ≥ 1+) which may be responsible for UUI symptoms

    8. Women who cannot keep the majority of the study therapy appointments or those without reliable contact phone numbers or methods of communication with the study personnel.

    Contacts and Locations

    Locations

    Site City State Country Postal Code
    1 University of New Mexico Health Science Center Albuquerque New Mexico United States 87131

    Sponsors and Collaborators

    • University of New Mexico
    • National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH)

    Investigators

    • Principal Investigator: Yuko Komesu, MD, University of New Mexcio Health Science Center

    Study Documents (Full-Text)

    More Information

    Publications

    Responsible Party:
    Yuko Komesu, MD, University of New Mexico
    ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier:
    NCT01829425
    Other Study ID Numbers:
    • 09-314
    • 1R01AT007171-01A1
    First Posted:
    Apr 11, 2013
    Last Update Posted:
    Apr 23, 2019
    Last Verified:
    Apr 1, 2019
    Individual Participant Data (IPD) Sharing Statement:
    Yes
    Plan to Share IPD:
    Yes
    Keywords provided by Yuko Komesu, MD, University of New Mexico
    Additional relevant MeSH terms:

    Study Results

    Participant Flow

    Recruitment Details Patients recruited March 2013 through October 2016 from the UNMH Urogynecology clinics
    Pre-assignment Detail Patients required to keep 3 day voiding diary to confirm their eligibility for the study prior to randomization. Pts also underwent hypnotic susceptibility testing prior to randomization. Of those consented, 13 did not go on to randomization: 8 were excluded because they did not meet inclusion criteria and 5 were lost to further followup
    Arm/Group Title Anticholinergic Medications Hypnotherapy
    Arm/Group Description Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year. Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study.
    Period Title: Overall Study
    STARTED 78 74
    COMPLETED 72 70
    NOT COMPLETED 6 4

    Baseline Characteristics

    Arm/Group Title Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications Total
    Arm/Group Description Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study. Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year. Total of all reporting groups
    Overall Participants 70 72 142
    Age (years) [Mean (Standard Deviation) ]
    Mean (Standard Deviation) [years]
    57.6
    (12.77)
    59.5
    (10.30)
    58.55
    (11.54)
    Sex: Female, Male (Count of Participants)
    Female
    70
    100%
    72
    100%
    142
    100%
    Male
    0
    0%
    0
    0%
    0
    0%
    Ethnicity (NIH/OMB) (Count of Participants)
    Hispanic or Latino
    24
    34.3%
    15
    20.8%
    39
    27.5%
    Not Hispanic or Latino
    45
    64.3%
    55
    76.4%
    100
    70.4%
    Unknown or Not Reported
    1
    1.4%
    2
    2.8%
    3
    2.1%
    Race (NIH/OMB) (Count of Participants)
    American Indian or Alaska Native
    2
    2.9%
    2
    2.8%
    4
    2.8%
    Asian
    0
    0%
    0
    0%
    0
    0%
    Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander
    1
    1.4%
    0
    0%
    1
    0.7%
    Black or African American
    3
    4.3%
    1
    1.4%
    4
    2.8%
    White
    52
    74.3%
    61
    84.7%
    113
    79.6%
    More than one race
    11
    15.7%
    7
    9.7%
    18
    12.7%
    Unknown or Not Reported
    1
    1.4%
    1
    1.4%
    2
    1.4%
    Region of Enrollment (participants) [Number]
    United States
    70
    100%
    72
    100%
    142
    100%
    Urgency Incontinence episodes on 3 day diary (episodes) [Median (Inter-Quartile Range) ]
    Median (Inter-Quartile Range) [episodes]
    8
    7
    7.5
    Overactive bladder short form (OABq-SF) questionnaires (units on a scale) [Mean (Standard Deviation) ]
    Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form Bother
    66.88
    (21.26)
    66.99
    (21.60)
    66.94
    (21.43)
    Overactive Bladder Short Form Quality of Life
    47.11
    (27.40)
    50.38
    (25.29)
    48.75
    (26.35)
    number of voids on bladder diary (episodes) [Mean (Standard Deviation) ]
    Mean (Standard Deviation) [episodes]
    29.07
    (8.71)
    29.19
    (8.43)
    29.13
    (8.57)

    Outcome Measures

    1. Primary Outcome
    Title Percent Change in Urgency Urinary Incontinence Episodes
    Description Percent change in UUI episodes from baseline to 2 months with comparison made between hypnotherapy & pharmacotherapy
    Time Frame Baseline and 2 month follow-up

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    Randomized patients with primary outcome (diary information) 2 months. Hypnotherapy: 74 randomized; of those randomized 3 had withdrawn, 1 was lost=70 with primary outcome information for analysis. Medications: 78 randomized-- 4 withdrawn. 2 were missing diary information=72 with primary outcome information for analysis
    Arm/Group Title Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Arm/Group Description Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study. Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year.
    Measure Participants 70 72
    Median (95% Confidence Interval) [percentage change in median UUI episodes]
    73
    88.6
    Statistical Analysis 1
    Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection Hypnotherapy, Anticholinergic Medications
    Comments
    Type of Statistical Test Non-Inferiority
    Comments The study design will use a non-inferiority design to compare the primary outcome (change in UUI episodes in the hypnotherapy versus pharmacotherapy groups). With respect to the outcome variable of percent reduction in UUI episodes as determined by bladder diaries, we will use a one-sided non- inferiority test at level alpha = 0.25 and a non-inferiority margin of 5%.
    Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value <.025
    Comments
    Method Exact Mann Whitney
    Comments Due dispersion, medians were calculated. Exact Mann Whitney test was used for this analysis.
    Method of Estimation Estimation Parameter Difference in median % change between gr
    Estimated Value 5
    Confidence Interval (1-Sided) 95%
    5 to
    Parameter Dispersion Type:
    Value:
    Estimation Comments Hypnotherapy - Pharmacotherapy. % difference in median % change in UUI episodes with lower bounds > - 5% would be consistent with non-inferiority
    2. Secondary Outcome
    Title Percent Change in Urgency Urinary Incontinence Episodes
    Description Differences comparing hypnotherapy to pharmacotherapy percent change in median UUI episodes
    Time Frame 6 months

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    At 6 months. Hypnotherapy: 74 women randomized-- 4 withdrawn, 2 lost and 1 missing diary information=67 analyzed with diary data. Medication: 78 randomized, 6 had withdrawn and 1 lost=71 analyzed with diary data
    Arm/Group Title Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Arm/Group Description Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study. Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year.
    Measure Participants 67 71
    Median (95% Confidence Interval) [percentage change in median UUI episodes]
    85.7
    83.3
    Statistical Analysis 1
    Statistical Analysis Overview Comparison Group Selection Hypnotherapy, Anticholinergic Medications
    Comments
    Type of Statistical Test Non-Inferiority
    Comments The study design will use a non-inferiority design to compare the primary outcome (change in UUI episodes in the hypnotherapy versus pharmacotherapy groups). With respect to the outcome variable of percent reduction in UUI episodes as determined by bladder diaries, we will use a one-sided non- inferiority test at level alpha = 0.25 and a non-inferiority margin of 5%. If
    Statistical Test of Hypothesis p-Value <.025
    Comments
    Method Exact Mann Whitney
    Comments
    Method of Estimation Estimation Parameter Difference in median % change between gr
    Estimated Value 5
    Confidence Interval (1-Sided) 95%
    5 to
    Parameter Dispersion Type:
    Value:
    Estimation Comments
    3. Secondary Outcome
    Title Percent Change in Urgency Urinary Incontinence Episodes
    Description Percent change in median UUI episodes from baseline to 12 months with comparison made between hypnotherapy & pharmacotherapy
    Time Frame 12 months

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    Pts with diary data at 12 months. For the Hypnotherapy group, of the 74 women randomized, 4 had withdrawn and 1 was missing diary data. For the medication group, of the 78 women randomized, 7 had withdrawn.
    Arm/Group Title Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Arm/Group Description Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study. Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year.
    Measure Participants 69 71
    Median (95% Confidence Interval) [percentage change in median UUI episodes]
    85.7
    80.0
    4. Secondary Outcome
    Title Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form Symptom Bother
    Description Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form symptom bother Scale. Sub-Scale range 0-100. Higher numbers are worse (more bother) and lower numbers are better (less bother)
    Time Frame 2 months

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    Randomized patients with primary outcome (diary information) 2 months. Hypnotherapy: 70 had diary information; of those randomized 3 had withdrawn, 1 was lost=70 with primary outcome information for analysis. Medications: 78 randomized-- 4 withdrawn. 2 were missing diary information=72 with primary outcome information for analysis
    Arm/Group Title Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Arm/Group Description Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study. Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year.
    Measure Participants 70 72
    Least Squares Mean (95% Confidence Interval) [scores on a sub-scale]
    38.17
    35.33
    5. Secondary Outcome
    Title Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form Symptom Bother
    Description Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form symptom bother. Sub-scale range 0-100. Higher numbers are worse (more bother) and lower numbers are better (less bother)
    Time Frame 6 months

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    At 6 months in the hypnotherapy group, 4 had withdrawn and 2 were lost and 1 missing diary. In the medication group, 6 had withdrawn and 1 was missing.
    Arm/Group Title Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Arm/Group Description Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study. Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year.
    Measure Participants 67 71
    Least Squares Mean (95% Confidence Interval) [sub-scale scores]
    34.61
    27.93
    6. Secondary Outcome
    Title Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form Symptom Bother
    Description Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form symptom bother. Sub-scale range 0-100. Higher numbers are worse (more bother) and lower numbers are better (less bother)
    Time Frame 12 months

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    12 months. Hypnotherapy: 74 randomized, 4 withdrawn & 1 was missing diary=69 analyzed with diary data. Medication: 78 randomized, 7 had withdrawn=71 analyzed with diary data.
    Arm/Group Title Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Arm/Group Description Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study. Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year.
    Measure Participants 69 71
    Least Squares Mean (95% Confidence Interval) [sub-scale scores]
    32.27
    30.74
    7. Secondary Outcome
    Title Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form Quality of Life
    Description Overactive Bladder questionnaire-Short Form Quality of Life. Higher scores are better (better quality of life) and lower scores are worse (poorer quality of life). sub-score range 0-100.
    Time Frame 2 months

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    Randomized patients with primary outcome (diary information) 2 months. Hypnotherapy: 74 randomized; 3 withdrawn, 1 lost=70 with primary outcome information used for analysis for secondary outcomes. Medications: 78 randomized-- 4 withdrawn, 2 were missing diary information=72 for analysis of secondary outcome.
    Arm/Group Title Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Arm/Group Description Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study. Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year.
    Measure Participants 70 72
    Least Squares Mean (95% Confidence Interval) [sub-scale scores]
    73.96
    74.86
    8. Secondary Outcome
    Title Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form Quality of Life
    Description Overactive Bladder questionnaire Short Form Quality of Life. Higher scores are better (better quality of life) and lower scores are worse (poorer quality of life). sub-scale score range 0-100.
    Time Frame 6 months

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    At 6 months, in the hypnotherapy group: 4 had withdrawn and 2 were lost and 1 missing diary. In the medication group: 6 had withdrawn and 1 was lost.
    Arm/Group Title Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Arm/Group Description Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study. Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year.
    Measure Participants 67 71
    Least Squares Mean (95% Confidence Interval) [sub-scale scores]
    75.85
    80.19
    9. Secondary Outcome
    Title Overactive Bladder Questionnaire Short Form Quality of Life
    Description Overactive Bladder questionnaire-Short Form Quality of Life. Higher scores are better (higher quality of life) and lower scores are worse (poorer quality of life). score range 0-100.
    Time Frame 12 months

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    At 12 months in the hypnotherapy group: 4 had withdrawn, 1 missing diary. In the medication group, 7 had withdrawn.
    Arm/Group Title Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Arm/Group Description Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study. Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year.
    Measure Participants 69 71
    Least Squares Mean (95% Confidence Interval) [sub-scale scores]
    75.71
    81.57
    10. Secondary Outcome
    Title Voids on Bladder Diary
    Description Total Number of voids on 3-day bladder diary.
    Time Frame 2 months

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    At 2 months in the hypnotherapy group of the 74 randomized, 3 had withdrawn and 1 was lost. In the medication group, of 78 randomized: 4 had withdrawn and 2 were missing diaries.
    Arm/Group Title Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Arm/Group Description Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study. Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year.
    Measure Participants 70 72
    Mean (95% Confidence Interval) [counts]
    26.4
    25.35
    11. Secondary Outcome
    Title Voids on Bladder Diary
    Description number of voids on 3-day bladder diary
    Time Frame 6 months

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    Of the 74 women randomized to hypnotherapy, at 6 months: 4 had withdrawn and 2 were lost and 1 was missing diary information. Of the 78 women randomized to medications, 6 had withdrawn and 1 was lost.
    Arm/Group Title Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Arm/Group Description Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study. Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year.
    Measure Participants 67 71
    Mean (95% Confidence Interval) [counts]
    25.58
    24.28
    12. Secondary Outcome
    Title Voids on Bladder Diary
    Description number of voids on 3-day bladder diary
    Time Frame 12 months

    Outcome Measure Data

    Analysis Population Description
    At 12 months, of the 74 randomized to hypnotherapy: 4 had withdrawn and 1 was missing diary information. Of the 78 women randomized to medications, 7 had withdrawn.
    Arm/Group Title Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Arm/Group Description Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study. Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year.
    Measure Participants 69 71
    Mean (95% Confidence Interval) [counts]
    25.74
    25.37

    Adverse Events

    Time Frame 1 year; from study randomization to study completion
    Adverse Event Reporting Description Adverse event collection occurred at all follow-up and by spontaneous participant report
    Arm/Group Title Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Arm/Group Description Subjects will receive approximately weekly hypnotherapy sessions over 8 weeks and will receive/download digital recordings for home practice. Subjects will be encouraged to practice self-hypnosis +/or listen to their recordings for 1 year. Hypnotherapy: Hypnotherapy will be administered approximately weekly over 8 weeks by certified, trained clinical hypnotherapists. Sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the hypnotherapist administers the hypnotherapy session in a standardized fashion.Subjects will receive or download a digital recording specially prepared for them to for home practice of hypnotherapy sessions.Following the 8 weeks of therapy, subjects will be encouraged to continue to practice self-hypnosis and/or listen to their home practice digital recording and this practice will be tracked for the 1 year duration of the study. Either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications (Long acting Tolterodine or Extended Release Oxybutynin)will be given. Subjects receive 8 weeks of medication counseling in conjunction with the medications. Medications will be continued for 1 year. Anticholinergic medications: The study will use either of two standard, long acting anti-cholinergic medications and dosages. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will also be administered over 8 weeks by trained research personnel. Pharmacotherapy counseling sessions will be audio-recorded and one or more sessions will be reviewed by study personnel to ensure that the medication counselor administers the sessions in a standardized fashion. Pill counts will be performed at the conclusion of the 8 weeks of pharmacotherapy counseling. Subjects will be provided the medication for 1 year.
    All Cause Mortality
    Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
    Total 0/70 (0%) 0/72 (0%)
    Serious Adverse Events
    Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
    Total 1/70 (1.4%) 3/72 (4.2%)
    Cardiac disorders
    1 inpatient hospitalization for observation 0/70 (0%) 0 1/72 (1.4%) 1
    Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders
    1 inpatient hospitalization 0/70 (0%) 0 1/72 (1.4%) 1
    1 in-patient hospitalization 0/70 (0%) 0 1/72 (1.4%) 1
    Renal and urinary disorders
    1 inpatient hospitalization 1/70 (1.4%) 1 0/72 (0%) 0
    Other (Not Including Serious) Adverse Events
    Hypnotherapy Anticholinergic Medications
    Affected / at Risk (%) # Events Affected / at Risk (%) # Events
    Total 12/70 (17.1%) 27/72 (37.5%)
    General disorders
    expected adverse events pharmacotherapy 1/70 (1.4%) 1 12/72 (16.7%) 12
    Infections and infestations
    urinary tract infection 5/70 (7.1%) 5 6/72 (8.3%) 6
    Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders
    Falls 3/70 (4.3%) 3 5/72 (6.9%) 5
    back pain 3/70 (4.3%) 3 4/72 (5.6%) 4

    Limitations/Caveats

    Women willing to participate x1 yr in RCT may not represent the general population. Population limited to 1 U.S. southwestern institution

    More Information

    Certain Agreements

    Principal Investigators are NOT employed by the organization sponsoring the study.

    There is NOT an agreement between Principal Investigators and the Sponsor (or its agents) that restricts the PI's rights to discuss or publish trial results after the trial is completed.

    Results Point of Contact

    Name/Title Dr. Yuko Komesu
    Organization University of New Mexico
    Phone 5052490726
    Email ykomesu@salud.unm.edu
    Responsible Party:
    Yuko Komesu, MD, University of New Mexico
    ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier:
    NCT01829425
    Other Study ID Numbers:
    • 09-314
    • 1R01AT007171-01A1
    First Posted:
    Apr 11, 2013
    Last Update Posted:
    Apr 23, 2019
    Last Verified:
    Apr 1, 2019