LAGGS: Comparing the Variation in Laparoscopic Skills Acquisition in Obstetrics & Gynaecology and General Surgical Trainees
Study Details
Study Description
Brief Summary
The investigators postulate that there is a difference in the acquisition of fundamental laparoscopic skills (FLS) between general surgical and Obstetrics & Gynecology (O&G) trainees, although not investigated previously. This discrepancy is also likely to influence the musculoskeletal and cognitive fatigue trainees experience within both specialties.
Additionally, there is likely to be a discrepancy in the expectations by consultants and trainees on skills perceived to be important at the completion of training (CCT).
This study aims to compare and evaluate the discrepancy in FLS acquisition amongst O&G and GS trainees in order to identify areas for improvement in the training pathway, the associated fatigue experience and highlight the expectations perceived to be required at the completion of training.
| Condition or Disease | Intervention/Treatment | Phase |
|---|---|---|
|
|
Detailed Description
Laparoscopic surgery (LS) is currently the gold standard for many operative procedures in general surgery and obstetrics and gynecology (O&G). However, the psychomotor skills of laparoscopic surgery can be difficult to develop and trainees pursuing a laparoscopic surgical career often face a steep learning curve. Whilst simulation-based training can lead to a demonstrable acquisition of transferrable laparoscopic skills,(1) they must be considered an adjunct rather than a substitute for in-theatre operating.
In both specialties, obtaining adequate exposure to operative work is a multifaceted challenge for the trainees as well as those involved in designing and delivering surgical training. Amongst other factors, NHS pressures driving service provision, European Working Time Directive (EWTD), loss of firm structures, and the cost of training to the trainees themselves have been identified as factors affecting the quality of surgical training in the UK. (2,3) This is reflected in annual training surveys highlighting concerns over loss of practical training and experience across both specialties.(4,5,6) Within O&G, when obtaining a Certificate of Completion of Training (CCT), there is concern that trainees lack the confidence and skills to perform the same breadth of procedures as the previous generation. (3) An intra deanery survey showed that 67% of O&G trainees felt inadequately prepared for CCT(8). In 2012, an analysis of 155 successful applications for CCT in general surgery (GS) revealed that only 67% of the cohort had achieved the logbook requirement of 1600 cases and around 73% had the necessary experience in index procedures(9). There is currently no literature to highlight expectations and opinions of consultants or programme directors reagrding trainees' skills within GS or O&G in the UK, which the investigators believe to be one of the indicators of training standards.
Whilst the requirements for CCT for general operative skills in open and laparoscopic surgery are comparable in both specialties, the training pathways defer significantly. GS training is 8 years in duration (CT1, CT2, ST3-ST8), whereas O&G consists of 7 years of specialty training (ST1-ST7). The ST1-ST5 years in O&G is mainly devoted to obstetrics and only those trainees pursuing a gynaecological training pathway undertake an intensive period of surgical training in the last two years of their training. The investigators believe there is also earlier exposure to laparoscopy in GS training with a greater volume of laparoscopic work in comparison to O&G training. So far there is no direct comparison of O&G and GS training pathways and outcomes in laparoscopic skills.
It is known that greater exposure to laparoscopic training is associated with "muscle memory" and may contribute to reducing the physical and mental stress of the surgeon. It is not known whether the existing training is sufficient to meet the demands of a laparoscopic gynaecological or GS consultant or whether the differences in training affect the development of fundamental laparoscopic skills (FLS). These FLS include spatial awareness, hand-eye coordination, bimanual dexterity, and laparoscopic suturing. The investigators would expect trainees to be better at FLS with more laparoscopic surgery exposure. The measurement of muscular and cognitive fatigue can be regarded as a surrogate marker of exposure to laparoscopy giving further insights into the quality of laparoscopic training between the two training programs.
The objectives of the study include; To compare FLS in O&G and GS trainees at ST3/4/5 and those in their final 2 years [ST7/8(GS) and ST6/7 (O&G)], to compare the musculoskeletal and cognitive fatigue experienced by O&G and GS trainees in performing FLS as a marker of their competence, and to compare the standards of laparoscopic ability expected from trainees by experienced GS and gynecological consultants.
Study design: This is a prospective comparative study and the investigators will recruit participants from professional membership bodies and the North West health education formerly known as the North West deanery. The study is divided into two parts. In part 1, Consultants and trainees from O&G and GS specialties will be contacted electronically through professional membership bodies (O&G consultants through RCOG/BSGE, GS consultants through ASGBI, O&G trainees through RCOG/BSGE, and GS trainees through ASiT). In addition to the above communication methods, the investigators will consider the use of social media and direct emails to increase the survey response rate. The consultants and trainees will be requested to fill out an online short questionnaire designed to assess trainees perceptions of FLS required at CCT and the consultants' expectations of laparoscopic competencies required by trainees at CCT. These surveys will not include any personal details and will be returned anonymously to the investigators via the survey monkey platform. In the second part, the investigators will recruit trainees from the two specialties via the North West deanery by sending out a centralized email requesting them to volunteer for the FLS tasks. In addition to the above recruitment methods, the investigators will consider the use of social media and direct emails to increase trainee recruitment for the study. Trainees will be able to volunteer their help by replying to a secure email address. Those trainees who respond and meet the inclusion criteria will subsequently be invited to attend a study day to perform four FLS tasks with a choice of 6 days across 3 possible weekends. On the day, trainees will be asked to fill out another short questionnaire to gather some demographic information and account for potential confounding variables. Personal details from these questionnaires will be separated and a study number will be randomly allocated to both parts of the questionnaires and this number will be written on the trainee's badge which will be used for filling out the task evaluation sheets. A single sheet of paper will allow the investigators recognize the study number against the relevant trainee in case there is a need to contact them at some point. This form will be securely stored in a locked cabinet in an NHS locked office accessible only to the research team. A sub-selection of trainees will be randomly chosen to have an electromyography (EMG) and electroencephalography (EEG) monitoring whilst performing the tasks.
There are four FLS tasks and they are carried out using validated training models called LASTT (Laparoscopic Skills Training and Testing method) and SUTT-1 (Suturing and knot tying Training and Testing method). LASTT is a wooden model and SUTT-1 is a foam sponge. The tasks are:
-
Laparoscopic Camera Navigation; Laparoscopic camera navigation (LCN) assesses the trainee's ability to navigate a 30 degrees camera using either their dominant hand (DH) or their non-dominant hand (NDH). The task requires the trainee to insert a 10mm 30 degrees optic through the central port of the Szabo box trainer. 14 targets will be dispersed around the LASTT model. Each target contains a large size character (either a large number or a large alphabet letter) and a small size character (either a number or an alphabet letter). The large character can be seen from a panoramic field but the smaller character requires the trainee to zoom in. The trainees will be required to sequentially locate all targets whilst being timed.
-
Hand-eye coordination (HEC); Task 2 - Hand-eye co-ordination (HEC) To assess HEC, trainees are assessed on their ability to transfer objects as well as navigate the camera. The trainee is expected to use the dominant hand (DH) to hold grasping forceps and the non-dominant hand (NDH) to hold the camera. The LASTT model will be used to assess this. There will be coloured cylinders of different colours, which the trainees will be required to place in corresponding coloured targets nails.
-
Bimanual co-ordination (BMC); BMC is assessed by measuring the time taken for a trainee to transfer 6 objects between their DH and NDH and position them correctly on the LASTT model. Coloured pins will be transferred from a central location to the corresponding coloured targets. The trainees are expected to identify a coloured pushpin (e.g. red), grasp it by the head with grasping forceps(Johans) using their NDH, then transfer the pin to their DH and grasp the pin by its tail using curved forceps like Maryland. The pushpin then needs to be placed in the corresponding disc of the same colour correctly before moving on to the next coloured pushpin.
-
Suturing and knot placement; All trainees will be shown a video demonstration of laparoscopic suturing and intra-corporeal knotting.
A Suturing and knot tying Training and Testing method (SUTT1) foam pad will be used for assessment of suturing and knot placement. This has 5 rows of dots. For this task, the top 4 rows are used and the 5th row is disregarded. Trainees will be expected to place interrupted sutures between two dots and perform 4 intracorporeal knots with 3 throws. A total of 15 minutes will be allowed for this task and the time taken to complete 4 sutures and 4 knots if performed will be recorded. If the trainee runs out of time, then a total number of sutures +/- knots performed within the 15 minutes will be recorded.
Measurement of EMG and EEG A random selection of trainees will have wireless electromyography (EMG) and electroencephalography (EEG) monitoring whilst performing the above tasks. As the equipment is wireless, it is anticipated that the trainee's freedom of movement will not be affected by it. EMG activity will be measured in the arm, shoulder, upper and lower back muscles, and the EEG activity of interest will be the alpha wave pattern observed during the activities.
Study Design
Arms and Interventions
| Arm | Intervention/Treatment |
|---|---|
| Obstetrics and Gynaecology (O&G) We aim to recruit trainees from ST3/ST4/ST5 levels (n=10) and ST6/ST7 (n=10). As OG training covers both obstetrics and gynaecology curriculums, we will recruit trainees in their final two years of training, with gynaecology special interest, who are undertaking at least one gynaecology Advanced Training Skills Modules (ATSM). These include advanced laparoscopic training, open and laparoscopic benign abdomen, urogynaecology, gynaecology-oncology and reproductive medicine. |
|
| General Surgery (GS) We aim to recruit trainees from ST3/ST4/ST5* (n=10) and ST7/ST8 (n=10) |
Outcome Measures
Primary Outcome Measures
- Average time to complete Fundamental of Laparoscopic surgery (FLS) tasks [Over the duration of 45 minutes when trainees undertake the FLS tasks]
Mean Time taken (in minutes: seconds) taken to perform each FLS task
Secondary Outcome Measures
- EMG measurements of Maximal Voluntary Contraction (MVC) [Over the duration of 45 minutes when trainees undertake the FLS tasks]
Observed frequency and amplitude of contractions across muscle groups to establish the musculoskeletal demands (demonstrated as muscle fatigue)
- EEG measurements of peak alpha power [Over the duration of 45 minutes when trainees undertake the FLS tasks]
Alpha spindle duration and amplitude during FLS tasks to measure cognitive fatigue
Eligibility Criteria
Criteria
Inclusion Criteria:
-
General surgery trainees at ST3/ST4/ST5/ST7/ST8 levels
-
Obstetrics and Gynaecology (O&G) at ST3/ST4/ST5/ST6/ST7 levels
-
Consultants in general surgery and O&G
Exclusion Criteria:
-
Those trainees who have had substantial pre-training experience in laparoscopic surgery such as those who have completed another surgical specialty training, have worked as clinical fellows or specialty doctors with substantial exposure to laparoscopic work will be excluded
-
Those trainees who are currently out of program/training and not doing regular clinical work or those trainees outside the North West deanery will also be excluded.
-
For the safety of others, anybody with a positive Covid-19 test, symptoms, or contact with someone infected with the virus will be excluded.
-
Trainees from outside of northwest deanery.
-
Currently out of training (maternity leave, Higher degrees not involving any clinical work)
-
Those trainees who have had substantial pre-training experience in laparoscopic surgery.
-
Those who have completed another surgical specialty training, have worked as clinical fellows or specialty doctor with significant exposure to operative laparoscopic work.
-
withdrawal of consent.
Contacts and Locations
Locations
| Site | City | State | Country | Postal Code | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust | Blackburn | Lancashire | United Kingdom | BB2 3HH |
Sponsors and Collaborators
- Lancaster University
- East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust
- British Society for Gynaecological Endoscopy
- Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists
- Association of Surgeons of Great Britain and Ireland
- KARL STORZ Endoscopy-America, Inc.
- Medtronic
Investigators
None specified.Study Documents (Full-Text)
More Information
Publications
None provided.- FHMREC20033